Showing papers in "Journal of Rural Health in 1994"

Urban and rural differences in health insurance and access to care.

Abstract: This study considers differences in access to health care and insurance characteristics between residents of urban and rural areas. Data were collected from a telephone survey of 10,310 randomly selected households in Minnesota. Sub-samples of 400 group-insured, individually insured, intermittently insured, and uninsured people, were asked about access to health care. Those with group or individual insurance were also asked about the costs and characteristics of their insurance policies. Rural areas had a higher proportion of uninsured and individually insured respondents than urban areas. Among those who purchased insurance through an employer, rural residents had fewer covered benefits than urban residents (5.1 vs 5.7, P < 0.01) and were more likely to have a deductible (80% versus 40%, P < 0.01). In spite of this, rural uninsured residents were more likely to have a regular source of care than urban residents (69% versus 51%, P < 0.01), and were less likely to have delayed care when they thought it was necessary (21% versus 32%, P < 0.01). These differences were confirmed by multivariate analysis. Rural residents with group insurance have higher out-of-pocket costs and fewer benefits. Uninsured rural residents may have better access to health care than their urban counterparts. Attempts to expand access to health care need to consider how the current structure of employment-based insurance creates inequities for individuals in rural areas as well as the burdens this structure may place on rural providers.

To Stay or Not to Stay: Issues in Rural Primary Care Physician Retention in Eastern Kentucky

Abstract: : An important aspect of primary care physician availability is the retention of physicians once they have located. While retention has been under-researched compared to recruitment, it is especially important in rural areas where physician shortages already exist. This study reports the results of a retention survey completed by 132 primary care physicians in rural eastern Kentucky. The survey sets up an objective, hypothetical retention scenario and asks physicians to respond to structured questions and to an open-ended question about factors not appearing in the survey. In response to the structured portion of the survey, physicians indicate that relief coverage is the most important factor in rural physician retention. A content analysis of 75 open-ended responses reveals that besides the other factors in the survey, “socio-cultural integration” is the pre-eminent retention issue for rural practitioners. This article concludes that the role of the local rural community may be more important in retention than in recruitment. Finally, it is suggested that additional in-depth qualitative research be conducted within the local contexts to enhance the understanding of rural physician retention processes.

Differences in the use of health services by metropolitan and nonmetropolitan elderly.

Abstract: This study examined the importance of place of residence on the elderly's use of health services through Andersen's framework of health service utilization. The study found that nonmetropolitan elderly, both farm and nonfarm, make fewer physician visits than their metropolitan counterparts. This difference is not explained by differences in their predisposing or need characteristics. No residential differences were found in the number of short-term hospital stays or in the number of days of bed disability. No evidence was found that nonmetropolitan elderly substitute days of bed disability for physician care or for hospital stays. Also, little residential variation was found in the effect of predisposing, enabling, and need factors on physician use. The most likely explanation for the observed differences in physician use is the shortage of physicians in nonmetropolitan areas. However, without the ability to attach contextual information to national data on health status and service use, the relative importance of access to services cannot be adequately addressed.

Rural Hospital Inpatient Surgical Volume: Cutting‐edge Service or Operating on the Margin?

Abstract: Surgical services are an important part of modern health care, but providing them to isolated rural citizens is especially difficult. Public policy initiatives could influence the supply, training, and distribution of surgeons, much as they have for rural primary care providers. However, so little is known about the proper distribution of surgeons, their contribution to rural health care, and the safety of rural surgery that policy cannot be shaped with confidence. This study examined the volume and complexity of inpatient surgery in rural Washington state as a first step toward a better understanding of the current status of rural surgical services. Information about rural surgical providers was obtained through telephone interviews with administrators at Washington's 42 rural hospitals. The Washington State Department of Health's Commission Hospital Abstract Recording System (CHARS) data provided a count of the annual surgical admissions at rural hospitals. Diagnosis-related group (DRG) weights were used to measure complexity of rural surgical cases. Surgical volume varied greatly among hospitals, even among those with a similar mix of surgical providers. Many hospitals provided a limited set of basic surgical services, while some performed more complex procedures. None of these rural hospitals could be considered high volume when compared to volumes at Seattle hospitals or to research reference criteria that have assessed volume-outcome relationships for surgical procedures. Several hospitals had very low volumes for some complex procedures, raising a question about the safety of performing them. The leaders of small rural hospitals must recognize not only the fiscal and service benefits of surgical services--and these are considerable--but also the potentially adverse effect of low surgical volume on patient outcomes. Policies that encourage the proper training and distribution of surgeons, the retention of basic rural surgical services, and the rational regionalization of complex surgery are likely to enhance the convenience and safety of surgery for rural citizens.

Bypassing of local hospitals by rural Medicare beneficiaries.

Abstract: Several previous studies of hospital utilization by nonelderly rural residents suggest that local rural hospitals have been increasingly bypassed, often for care in urban hospitals. This resulted in lost volume for rural hospitals, detracting from their financial viability. It is not clear to what extent elderly rural residents also bypass local hospitals and whether this reflects regionalization of treatment for some conditions or avoidance of local hospitals assumed to provide inadequate care. This study examines hospital use by aged rural Delaware Medicare beneficiaries living in a ZIP code area that has a local hospital during Fiscal Year (FY) 1987 (N = 670). Most of these Medicare beneficiaries were hospitalized locally. Those beneficiaries who bypassed local rural hospitals usually did so because cardiovascular surgical procedures were required and were often only performed in large urban teaching hospitals. Beneficiaries using nonlocal hospitals were similar to users of local hospitals with respect to age and sex and traveled an average of nearly 42 miles for treatment. "Bypassing" here appears to be due primarily to regional specialization of care rather than abandonment of local rural hospitals by rural residents.

Market shares for rural inpatient surgical services: where does the buck stop?

Abstract: Utilization of surgical services by rural citizens is poorly understood, and few data are available about rural hospitals' surgical market shares and their financial implications. Understanding these issues is particularly important in an era of financially stressed rural hospitals. In this study information about rural surgical providers and services was obtained through telephone interviews with administrators at Washington state's 42 rural hospitals. The Washington State Department of Health's Commission Hospital Abstract Recording System (CHARS) data were used to measure market shares and billed charges for rural surgical services. ZIP codes were used to assign rural residents to a hospital service area (HSA) of the nearest hospital, providing the geographic basis for market share calculations. "Total hospital expenses" from the American Hospital Association Guide were used as a proxy for hospital budget, and the surgical financial contribution was expressed as a ratio of billed surgical charges to total hospital expense. For rural hospitals as a whole, 21 percent of admissions and 43 percent of billed inpatient charges resulted from surgical services. In 1989, 27,202 rural Washington residents were hospitalized for surgery. Overall, 42 percent went to the closest rural hospital, 14 percent went to other rural hospitals, and 44 percent went to urban hospitals. The presence of surgical providers markedly increased local market shares, but a substantial proportion of basic surgical procedures bypassed available local services in favor of urban hospitals. For example, about one-third of patients needing cholecystectomies, a basic general surgery of low complexity, bypassed local hospitals with staff surgeons.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Studying the retention of rural physicians.

Abstract: : Rural communities and policy-makers struggle with efforts to enhance the retention of rural physicians. Research available to guide these efforts is often weak methodologically and thus may be pointing retention efforts in nonproductive directions. This article discusses a range of methodologic issues encountered in rural physician retention studies for the purpose of strengthening future studies. Ideal study approaches to answer causal questions, including questions about the “causes” of rural physician retention, must demonstrate good internal validity, for which chance, bias, and confounding are accounted. Retention studies that rely simply on asking physicians why they stay or leave rural areas can be useful at times, but are too prone to bias and their findings difficult to verify. Simply identifying what physicians find satisfying or dissatisfying about rural work also will not reliably reveal why they stay or leave, a related but still distinct question. Stronger approaches to studying retention include the traditional quantitative study – in which retention factors are identified when they are statistically related to physicians’retention, and the increasingly popular qualitative study – in which retention issues are revealed through prolonged, in-depth interactions with physicians. This article also discusses various definitions of retention, the use of survival curves to present retention findings, and the importance of studying retention in inception cohorts. The benefits and downside of studying retention with prospective and retrospective study designs are described.

Strategic activity and financial performance of U.S. rural hospitals: a national study, 1983 to 1988.

Abstract: : This study examines the effect of 13 strategic management activities on the financial performance of a national sample of 797 US rural hospitals during the period of 1983-1988 Controlled for environment-market, geographic-region, and hospital-related variables, the results show almost no measurable effect of strategic adoption on rural hospital profitability and liquidity Where statistically significant relationships existed, they were more often negative than positive These findings were not expected; it was hypothesized that positive effects across a broad range of strategies would emerge, other things being equal Discussed are possible explanations for these findings as well as their implication for a rural health policy relying on individual rural hospital strategic adaptation to environmental change

Local factors affecting the tendency to bypass local hospitals for inpatient mental health care: an exploratory analysis.

Abstract: Using the records of 2,171 rural residents of Illinois who received inpatient treatment for mental illness or substance abuse, this paper examines factors that influence the tendency to seek service from a distant rather than a local hospital. Results indicate that the age and insurance coverage of the individual, the per capita income of the community area, surrogates for the service orientation of the local hospital and the proximity of the patient's residence to an urban center are significant influences. With the exceptions of drug abuse requiring detoxification or other symptomatic treatment, drug abuse accompanied by comorbidity and psychosocial disorders, psychosis, and childhood disorders, the primary diagnosis of the individual failed to have a significant effect on the propensity to bypass local sources of inpatient treatment.

Geographic imbalances of physician supply: an international comparison.

Abstract: : This study was undertaken to compare geographic imbalances of physician manpower in developed and developing countries and to evaluate the success of policies designed to alleviate the imbalances. Data were drawn from a mail survey of countries conducted by the World Health Organization, from national statistical summaries, and from published information on national policies and programs. Information was available from 26 developing countries and 15 developed countries. Among developing countries, the degree of urbanization and rural economic development appeared to be the most important determinants of the level of geographic imbalance. Among developed countries, those with very high overall physician/ population ratios tended to have the least degree of imbalance, but this effect was not consistent. At the national level in most countries, the effect of policies or programs specifically designed to redistribute physician manpower appeared to be limited.

Impact of new information technologies on training and continuing education for rural health professionals.

Abstract: : Recently developed and emerging information and communications technologies offer the potential to move the clinical training of physicians and other health professionals away from the resource intensive urban academic health center, with its emphasis on tertiary care, and into rural settings that may be better able to place emphasis on the production of badly needed primary care providers. These same technologies also offer myriad opportunities to enhance the continuing education of health professionals in rural settings. This article explores the effect of new technologies for rural tele-education by briefly reviewing the effect of technology on health professionals’education, describing ongoing applications of tele-education, and discussing the likely effect of new technological developments on the future of tele-education. Tele-education has tremendous potential for improving the health care of rural Americans, and policy-makers must direct resources to its priority development in rural communities.

Geographic benefit from decentralized medical education: student and preceptor practice patterns.

Abstract: : The performance of area health education center (AHEC)-stimulated programs and decentralized education for medicine is not well understood. The Statewide Education Activities for Rural Colorado's Health (SEARCW/AHEC project at the University of Colorado School of Medicine was examined to determine if the program had an effect on the practice location of its graduates. Practice location and specialty of graduates of the University of Colorado School of Medicine (UCSOM) classes 1980-1985 were compared for students who had participated in decentralized SEARCH/AHEC experiences versus students who had not. The majority of the graduates were practicing out of state in 1990. Non-Colorado doctors were more often practicing in rural (non-metropolitan statistical area [MSA]) counties and in towns of fewer than 2,500, 5,000 and 10,000 residents, respectively. In addition, of the 251 active patient care physicians practicing in Colorado communities of fewer than 10,000 in non-MSA counties in 1986, those who precepted UCSOM students on SEARCH rotations were more likely to have remained in their same practice location in 1992 (77.8% versus 62.1% for those who had not precepted students). This analysis of both student and preceptor practice patterns documents the value of decentralized medical education in addressing the geographic and specialty maldistribution of physicians. These results have important policy implications for funding medical education programs.

Health and well-being of childbearing women in rural and urban contexts.

Abstract: : As part of the national focus on women's health issues, it is important to identify those health-related characteristics of rural women that distinguish them from women living in urban settings. The aim of this study was to compare rural and urban childbearing women on socioeconomic characteristics, perceived stress, health-related practices, illness symptoms, parenting confidence, and body weight. One hundred sixty-five midwestern women responded to a health survey sent to them six months after childbirth. Rural women were younger and less educationally and economically advantaged compared to urban women. Before adjusting for these differences, rural women were less self-actualized, more interpersonally isolated, and reported less healthy nutrition than urban women. These differences disappeared when socioeconomic differences were adjusted. Rural and urban mothers did not differ in most other areas, including perceived stress, parenting confidence, and body weight. Compared to national norms, the perceived stress levels of both rural and urban mothers were significantly higher than a probability sample of U.S. women. Findings support the role of socioeconomic factors as contributing to risk of poor health promotion among rural childbearing women.

Wash Day Blues: Secondhand Exposure to Agricultural Chemicals

Abstract: : The issue of personal cleanliness for farm workers exposed to pesticides is a significant health problem. One area that requires more attention centers on the issues of handling and laundering of clothing suspected of being contaminated by pesticides. This exploratory research focused on the handling and laundering behaviors of California farm workers with pesticide contaminated clothing. Of particular interest was the phenomenon of “secondhand” exposure that may result from improper handling and unsafe laundering practices. Members of farm worker families (N=109) were interviewed at two California health clinics that serve a large portion of low income farm worker families. The sample was divided into three groups based on exposure to pesticides: direct exposure, indirect exposure, nonexposed. The findings revealed the least safe handling and laundering behaviors were reported by the group most at risk from first hand exposure (i.e., handlers, loaders, applicators). Also, secondhand exposure to pesticides appears to be related to storage and laundering practices reported by those who are directly or indirectly exposed to pesticides. The findings revealed the actual laundering practices of farm workers and their knowledge of what constitutes unsafe laundering behavior, including “secondhand” contamination. This information can help to identify realistic safe laundering practices for farm worker families who come in contact with pesticides in the field or at home.

Birth outcomes to rural Illinois residents: is there a crisis?

Abstract: : In recent years, the supply of obstetric services in rural areas has been a concern. At the same time, the demand for such services has been affected by the reduction in population and economic base. This article explores the extent of these trends in Illinois and whether they have led to a deterioration in amount of prenatal care and birth outcomes. Using birth certificate and infant death data for residents of rural Illinois counties in 1983 and 1988, prenatal care and birth outcomes for each year are compared within rural areas and to the rest of the state, as well as between the two time periods. Although rural residents began prenatal care later, they obtained similar qualities of care as their urban counterparts. The data revealed no adverse impact on birth outcomes of residing in increasingly rural areas, nor was there a deterioration during the time period. An attempt was made to identify rural counties that lost providers and/ or facilities and those that gained them. Although such a classification scheme is subjective, similar results ensued. While indirect costs such as time and effort to obtain care may have increased, at 1988 levels of care availability there was no crisis in Illinois.

Physician Recruitment in Rural Canada: Programs in New Brunswick, Newfoundland, and Nova Scotia

Abstract: This paper examines programs used in the Atlantic provinces of New Brunswick, Newfoundland, and Nova Scotia to recruit and retain physicians in rural areas. The provinces have many similarities but have unique characteristics that have shaped recruitment methods. The total number of physicians in each province has grown at a faster rate than the population. Each has problems attracting physicians to underserved areas, although the magnitude of the problems vary. The data for this paper were gathered from documents available from various agencies in each province and a series of personal interviews conducted in the spring of 1993. The provinces have chosen different avenues in attempting to solve the maldistribution of physician resources, ranging from regulatory methods in New Brunswick to moves in Newfoundland to encourage graduates of the province's medical school to locate in the rural areas and lessen the dependence on foreign medical graduates. Nova Scotia, with fewer areas needing physicians, has been able to focus its efforts on selected locations. Reviewing the methods used in the three provinces provides an insight into the attempts to solve the shortage of physicians in rural areas.

The impact of informal care giving on labor force participation by rural farming and nonfarming families.

Abstract: : Using data from the National Survey of Families and Households, 1987, this study contrasts urban versus rural, and farm versus rural nonfarm informal care givers of the elderly and disabled to illustrate the conflicts that each group experiences when combining work and care giving. Women are the primary care givers in both rural and urban areas. Rural care givers spent more time providing care than urban caregivers, whether the dependent resided in the care giver's home or elsewhere in the community. A moderate difference existed in the number of hours care givers spent at work, although the rural care giver's spouses worked significantly more hours than urban spouses. Rural nonfarm care givers spent more hours caring for individuals residing in their communities, while farm caregivers spent the most time in household-related activities when caring for someone in their homes. In-home activity decreased the number of hours spent at work, while community care giving did not.

Rural primary care program survival: an analysis of financial variables.

Abstract: : This study examines the effect of financial characteristics of rural primary care programs on the probability of their continuing as federally funded entities. A randomly selected national cohort of rural primary care programs (n=162) was used to compare financial measures of programs that were continuing and those that were noncontinuing. Financial data were obtained from 1978-1987 Bureau Common Reporting Requirements (BCRR) forms submitted to the Bureau of Health Care Delivery and Assistance of the Department of Health and Human Services as part of the requirement to receive federal grant support for the programs. The results emphasize the importance of both outside funding and increased level of self-sufficiency in the continuation of rural primary care programs. Noncontinuing programs often suffer from both a lack of self-sufficiency and a lack of outside funding, mostly from federal sources. To a lesser extent, the number of patients also affects the program's chance of continuation. From a policy perspective, government intervention is both necessary and likely if rural primary care programs are to succeed and fulfill their mission of providing primary care for the medically underserved who are primarily poor, uninsured, and unable to pay.

Contracting for emergency room coverage by rural hospitals.

Abstract: : Obtaining adequate physician availability remains a challenge to many rural communities To ensure 24-hour emergency room physician coverage, many rural hospitals contracted for emergency room services from out-of-area and/or local physician Survey findings for 99 rural and rural referral Iowa hospitals addressing the nature, extent, and cost of contracting physician coverage of the emergency room are presented While nearly two-thirds of the hospitals reported contracting for at least some emergency room coverage, the extent and costs of contracts vary widely Advantages and disadvantages of contracting for emergency room services are discussed

A strategy to increase the number of urban family practice resident physicians who enter rural practice.

Abstract: : Physician geographic maldistribution is a problem in the United States health care system. Innovative strategies are needed to entice resident family physicians training in the larger, more numerous suburban and urban training programs to practice in rural areas upon completing their training. This paper describes a strategy used at St. Elizabeth Medical Center Family Practice Residency Program, Dayton, OH, to encourage rural practice. In the St. Elizabeth plan, the interested family practice resident moonlights in a rural practice provided by the local county hospital. The county medical staff covers the resident physician's practice during the frequent absences. The residency program faculty provide on-site supervision, telephone back-up coverage, and practice consultation. The county hospital provides billing services; the resident physician retains 100 percent of collections. The resident physician gains exposure to the knowledge, skills, and attitudes needed in rural practice. Upon completion of residency training, the physician remains in practice and is not required to pay back any expenses incurred by the hospital. Two resident physicians participate currently; three others have expressed interest in practicing in the community. A similar plan might work in parts of the United States where, like Ohio, training programs and rural communities are not far apart.

The health of rural homeless women with young children.

Abstract: More than 30 percent of the homeless are families with children; however, little is known about these families, particularly rural homeless mothers with children. The purpose of this study was to describe the characteristics of rural homeless mothers, their physical and mental health, and their health care practices. A descriptive cross-sectional design was used to study a sample of 76 rural mothers with children younger than age 13. An interview schedule and the SCL-90-R were used to collect data about these families. The majority of the families had been homeless for more than four months, 46 percent were woman-headed, 17 percent of the mothers reported having a physical health problem, and only 3 percent had scores on the SCL-90-R that were indicative of needing additional evaluation for possible mental health problems. The use of drugs was higher than expected, which puts both the mothers and their children at risk for health problems.

Rurality and Tuberculosis Incidence Trends in North and South Carolina, 1980 to 1992

Abstract: U.S. tuberculosis incidence rates increased steadily from 1985 through the end of 1992. Many factors have been implicated as contributors to the reversal in the historic decline of tuberculosis: the HIV epidemic, poverty and homelessness, immigration from less developed countries, and a deteriorating public health infrastructure. The purposes of this study were to demonstrate the extent of geographic variation in tuberculosis incidence rate trends in North and South Carolina and to quantify the association between aggregate-level characteristics of state economic areas and incidence rate trends. Data were obtained from the U.S. 1980 and 1990 decennial census and from the North and South Carolina health departments. In North Carolina, tuberculosis trends declined rapidly in the early 1980s, but declined much less rapidly from 1986 to 1992. In South Carolina, tuberculosis trends were nearly static during the early 1980s, but declined rapidly from 1986 to 1992. Rural and high-poverty state economic areas in South Carolina experienced especially favorable changes in tuberculosis incidence trends. South Carolina has a unique tuberculosis control program that makes widespread use of enablers, incentives, and directly observed therapy. This study demonstrates the distinct tuberculosis incidence trends that existed in two contiguous states and suggests that approaches to tuberculosis control that improve access to care may be effective in improving tuberculosis incidence trends, particularly in poor and rural areas. Strengthening tuberculosis programs may be an important strategy for controlling the current resurgence of tuberculosis in the United States.

Urban/Rural Differences in Prosthetic Dental Service Rates

Abstract: : There have been few reports of relative rates of provision of dental health services in rural and urban settings, a comparative measure of access to care in these populations. One part of a statewide survey of active North Carolina general dentists (n=959, response rate=47%) was designed to quantify provision of prosthetic services. To determine contrasting rural and urban rates, responses were analyzed according to dentists’self-report of practice city size using analysis of covariance with percent of insured patients in the practice as the covariate. Mean per-patient-visit rates for crowns, fixed partial dentures, removable partial dentures, and extractions, as well as the distributions of treatment following tooth extraction, differed by city size, with practitioners in the smallest cities reporting treatment distributions reflecting more frequent loss of teeth and less frequent replacement. These differences in patterns of prosthetic care echo the limited existing information describing oral health status, provider supply, and receipt of care, all of which suggest that differential levels of access to care exist and lead to differences in oral health outcomes.

Graduates' Reflections on Their Rural Medical Education: The Upper Peninsula Campus Experience

Abstract: : A comprehensive graduate evaluation study was conducted by the Upper Peninsula campus of Michigan State University's College of Human Medicine in 1990. The purpose of this qualitative study was to describe the effects of the program's philosophy, curriculum, and general operational features on the 56 physician graduates from the program during 1978-1989. All practicing graduates were interviewed in their practice locations and residents were interviewed by telephone. Forty-six percent of the upper peninsula graduates are practicing in primary care specialities (family practice, general pediatrics, general internal medicine) and 41 percent are living in cities of less than 50,000 population. The overall findings identify several factors that were significant to the graduates, such as excellent role models, problem-focused curriculum, and early applied clinical work in an ambulatory, primary care, rural setting. Based on the data, the program attracts students who are satisfied with its innovative medical education.

An Expert Panel Approach to Assessing the Rural Implications of Health Care Reform: The Case of the Health Security Act

Abstract: The policy arena is hungry for objective information regarding the potential effects of comprehensive national and state health care reform. Such information reduces the dependence of policy-makers on information generated solely by advocacy groups and serves as a checkpoint for such information. Unfortunately, the academic community is often unable to mobilize its resources quickly enough to help meet this information need. This article describes one model for overcoming this difficulty. When the time frame is especially short, academic expertise can be brought together in the form of an expert panel. However, for such an approach to be effective, it must be carefully configured and orchestrated. Critical ingredients include much preparatory groundwork, a well-defined framework and methodology for conducting the policy analysis, and a professional facilitator. The Rural Policy Research Institute used such an approach to analyze President Clinton's Health Security Act shortly after the initial blueprint was released (but before the legislative language was released). The consensus of the expert panel was that the Health Security Act would, on balance, represent an improvement over today's rural reality. However, a number of troubling aspects were noted. First, the Act's emphasis on primary care and nonphysician providers is a double-edged sword. While these are precisely the types of providers needed in rural areas, the short-run effect may be to create increased competition for such providers from urban areas.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)

Determinants of physician vacancy rates in rural hospitals.

Abstract: This study examines the determinants of physician vacancy rates in rural hospitals from the perspective of the rural hospital administrator. Data on community characteristics, hospital characteristics, and hospital recruitment strategies are examined for 50 rural hospitals in Kentucky using questionnaire and archival data. Physician vacancy rates in this sample were quite high (mean of 37 percent). Results indicate lower physician vacancy rates in hospitals with a chain affiliation. In addition, the "job shopping" model for physicians decisions on where to practice (Johnson, 1978) is supported. Hospitals that target physician candidates with more work experience display lower physician vacancy rates. Generally, hospital characteristics were more significant predictors of physician vacancy rates than were community characteristics. Implications for rural hospital physician recruitment/retention strategies are discussed.

The development of a state-level health manpower database using an employer-based survey: a pilot project.

Abstract: : State health care reform may provide a better approach to meeting the health care needs of rural communities than does federal reform because the planning is closer to the needs of local communities. However, state health reform requires a health manpower database (along with other data) that includes all health occupations and such databases are often nonexistent. This study reports on one element of such a database–a survey of a wide range of rural health care employers covering the full range of health occupations in Alabama. Information on current and future employment of the most significant health occupations is reported here. It was found that the greatest numbers of new health personnel employees needed in the future were, in descending order, nursing assistants, registered nurses, licensed practical nurses, radiological technicians, specialist physicians, nurse practitioners, physical therapists, primary care physicians, and respiratory care therapists. While an employer survey has limitations and should be supplemented by data on community needs and health status indicators, it does provide useful information for planning educational programs to prepare health personnel.

Decomposing area of residence differences in multiple regression studies: the relative contributions of independent variables and model coefficients.

Abstract: When rural/urban differences are found in health status or health care use, it is often desirable to identify those factors (such as age, social structure, income, etc.) that influence such differences. To this end, researchers often test rural/urban differences in age, social structure, income, etc., for statistical significance. Also, researchers commonly perform multivariate analyses (such as multiple regressions) to examine rural-urban differences in the influence of various independent variables on the dependent variable of interest. Frequently, researchers discover: (1) statistically significant rural/urban differences in the independent variables (such as age, social structure, income, etc.) and (2) statistically significant rural/urban differences in the effects of these independent variables (i.e., statistically significant rural/urban differences in regression coefficients). The analysis typically stops here, without addressing the relative contributions of (1) and (2) to the rural/urban differences in the dependent variable. This paper argues that the relative contributions of (1) and (2) have important implications for the way policy-makers address rural health problems. This paper presents a method for assessing the relative contributions of differences in the independent variables and differences in regression coefficients to observed differences in the dependent variable, and illustrates the application of the method by analyzing rural/urban differences in the risk of institutionalization.