Should we Maintain or Break Confidentiality? The Choices Made by Social Researchers in the Context of Law Violation and Harm
TLDR
In this paper, the authors discuss the experiences and opinions of researchers concerning the maintenance or breaking of confidentiality in the context of knowledge about illegal activities and harm, and examine the ways in which the researchers justified their decisions.Abstract:
Confidentiality represents a core principle of research ethics and forms a standard practice in social research. However, what should a researcher do if they learn about illegal activities or harm during the research process? Few systematic studies consider researchers’ attitudes and reactions in such situations. This paper analyzes this issue on the basis of in-depth interviews with Polish sociologists and anthropologists who conduct qualitative research with vulnerable participants. It discusses the experiences and opinions of researchers concerning the maintenance or breaking of confidentiality in the context of knowledge about illegal activities and harm. It also examines the ways in which the researchers justified their decisions. Most of my interviewees respected confidentiality in spite of knowledge of crime or harm, and referred to their epistemological perspectives regarding the role of the researcher, implicit consequentialist ethical reasoning and personal values. Where researchers did break confidentiality, this owed to their personal values and willingness to protect their informants, especially in cases of minor levels of harm as opposed to serious crime. Therefore, their experiences indicate the failure of both obligatory unconditional assurances of confidentiality and the requirement for researchers to assure confidentiality to the extent permitted by law. I argue that researchers do not need constrictive and potentially punitive rules about confidentiality, but rather sensitizing frameworks about how to contemplate and anticipate the many complexities and moral shadings of situations in the field.read more
Citations
More filters
Journal ArticleDOI
The Politics of a National Identity Survey: Polishness, Whiteness, and Racial Exclusion
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors analyze a survey on national identity in Poland and argue that Polish identity must be seen in terms of selective racism without racism, that is, it is an identity based on racial premises but which at the same time neglects its racial character.
Journal ArticleDOI
Qualitative migration research ethics: a roadmap for migration scholars
TL;DR: In this article, a scoping review that maps current ethical challenges that migration scholars often face and provides guidance, while acknowledging the fact that many researchers deal with ethical issues on a case-by-case basis.
Journal ArticleDOI
Experiences of Academics Working from Home during COVID-19: A Qualitative View from Selected South African Universities
TL;DR: In this article , the authors examined the experiences of academics working from home across selected universities in South Africa using a qualitative approach and applying Atlas.ti for data analysis, their findings show that work from home in academia is a daunting task requiring extensive organisational, personal, and social adjustments.
Journal ArticleDOI
Ethical considerations for committees, supervisors and student researchers conducting qualitative research with young people in the United Kingdom
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors consider some of the ethical issues that can arise for novice researchers in institutions that do not have a firmly established qualitative research tradition, with particular reference to research with young people and in some instances sensitive topics.
Journal ArticleDOI
Patterns of criminal activity among residential care-leavers in South Africa
TL;DR: In this article, a longitudinal study of young adults transitioning out of care and journeying towards young adulthood over a period of five years was carried out, where 51 participants who had had at least two (and up to five) interviews (spaced approximately a year apart) since leaving care.
References
More filters
Journal ArticleDOI
The transformative power of cooperation between social movements: Squatting and tenants' movements in Poland
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors examine the relations between tenants' and squatting movements in Poland by studying two cities where both movements are established and cooperating closely, assuming that cooperation between social movements results in negotiations and transformations of the involved social movement actors.
Journal ArticleDOI
Legal Intrusion and the Politics of Fieldwork The Impact of the Brajuha Case
Mario Brajuha,Lyle Hallowell +1 more
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors explore the problem of legal intrusion into the research process and show that research experience shows that such intrusions need not be fatal, but can be catastrophic.
Journal ArticleDOI
Confidentiality in criminological research and other ethical issues
TL;DR: The issues I shall raise are also issues in other disciplines of research and teaching; some are peculiarly specific to criminology; all, I am asserting, are ethical issues.
Journal ArticleDOI
Legal Issues in Acquiring Information about Illegal Behaviour Through Criminological Research
TL;DR: In the United Kingdom, a range of legislation, including the Criminal Law Act 1967, Prevention of Terrorism (Temporary Provisions) Act 1989, Terrorism Act 2000, Police and Criminal Evidence Act 1984, Contempt of Court Act 1981 and Official Secrets Acts 1911 to 1983, have been used to force disclosure of researchers' records as mentioned in this paper.
Journal ArticleDOI
Ethikbegutachtung in der sozial- und kulturwissenschaftlichen Forschung? Ein Debattenbeitrag aus soziologischer und ethnologischer Sicht
TL;DR: In this article, the authors discuss the Entwicklungen in Deutschland aus ethnologischer and soziologischer perspektive, and sprechen uns fur eine institutionelle Verankerung des Themas aus and unterstutzen die Entwicklerung von Strukturen der forschungsethischen Begutachtung, sofern diese freiwillig bleiben und the methodische Vielfalt der Sozial-and Kulturwissenschaftlichen Fors
Related Papers (5)
Strict Confidentiality: An Alternative to Pre’s “Limited Confidentiality” Doctrine
John Lowman,Ted Palys +1 more