The Antioxidant Effect of Lanthanum Complex in Natural Rubber
Qiang-Guo LI
1,a
, Wei ZHENG
1,b
, Si-Zhu WU
1,c*
1
State Key Laboratory of Organic−Inorganic Composites, Beijing University of Chemical Technology,
Beijing 100029, P.R. China
a
lqg875@163.com,
b
978757391@qq.com,
c
wusz@mail.buct.edu.cn
*Corresponding author
Keywords: Thermal-oxidative Aging, Antioxidant, Lanthanum, Natural Rubber, Model-free Kinetic
Methods, Mechanism.
Abstract. Mixed antioxidants composed of antioxidant N-phenyl-N’-isopropyl-p-phenylenediamine
(IPPD) and lanthanum (La) complex were added as a filler to prepare natural rubber (NR) composites.
By mechanical testing, X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy, and thermogravimetric analysis, a string of
data, including the mechanical properties, the variation of chemical surface characterization, and the
thermo-oxidative decomposition kinetics parameters, was presented in this article to study the
antioxidant effect of the mixed antioxidants in NR. The density function theoretical calculations were
also used as an assistant to study the thermo-oxidative aging mechanism of NR and the different
function mechanisms of antioxidants IPPD and La complex. The data revealed that except for
functioning as a labile-hydrogen doner which was similar to antioxidant IPPD, this La complex had
strong coordination abilities and large coordination numbers, resulting in the high efficiency in
enhancing the thermal-oxidative stability of NR.
Introduction
Natural rubber (NR) is widely applied in many fields due to its excellent properties. But it is easily
attacked by oxygen, especially under thermal condition. The thermal-oxidative aging of NR will lead
to the deterioration of its properties[1]. Thus, the thermal-oxidative stability is essential for the
processing and applications of NR. So far, adding antioxidants has been found to be one of the most
convenient methods to retard or prevent the thermal-oxidative aging of rubbers[2].
Recent studies have found that coordination compounds composed of rare earth metals and certain
organic compounds containing O, S and N atoms could exert excellent long-term protective effect on
the thermal oxidation process of rubbers[3,4]. The thermal-oxidative aging of NR follows an
autocatalytic, free radical chain reaction mechanism[3]. With shell structure like 4f0-145d0-106s2,
lanthanide series rare earth ions, whose atom numbers are from 57 to 71, have long atom radius and a
large quantity of unoccupied orbits, resulting in strong abilities in scavenging free radicals generated
in the thermal-oxidative process[5].
This study made a comparative study of thermal-oxidative stability for two NR samples—one with
the antioxidant N-phenyl-N’-isopropyl-p-phenylenediamine (IPPD) and the other with the
combination of antioxidant IPPD and lanthanum (La) complex. The combination of experiments and
simulations clarified the variations of properties and structures, and the corresponding function
mechanisms of antioxidants IPPD and La complex.
Experimental
Materials
The base formulation of the two NR composites was described as follows (phr): RSS, 70; E-SBR
1500, 30; zinc oxide, 5; stearic acid, 2; antioxidants, 3; silica-VN3, 40; Si69, 4; Carbon black 234, 5;
sulfur, 1.8; accelerator CZ, 1.5. In addition, 3 phr of antioxidant IPPD was added into the base
Proceedings of the 3rd International Conference on Material Engineering and Application (ICMEA 2016)
Copyright © 2016, the Authors. Published by Atlantis Press.
This is an open access article under the CC BY-NC license (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc/4.0/).
187
Advances in Engineering Research, volume 103
formulation to prepare Sample A, while 3 phr of mixed antioxidants (antioxidant IPPD, 2.25;
p-ASALa, 0.75) was added to the base formulation to prepare Sample B.
The above ingredients were mixed on a two-roll mill (Guang-dong Zhanjiang Rubber and Plastic
Machinery Factory, China). The curing characteristics were determined by a discoscillating rheometer
(Beijing Huanfeng Mechanical Factory, China). Then the compounds were cured in a 25T hot
compression mold (Shanghai Rubber Machinery Factory, China) at 143℃for t90 to gain NR
composites.
Experimental Methods
NR samples were thermally aged at the center of an air-circulated cabinet oven at 80 °C and
atmospheric pressure. The mechanical properties were measured according to Chinese standard GB/T
528-2009. The X-ray photoelectron spectroscopy (XPS) measurements were made on an Escalab
250Xi X-ray photoelectron spectrometer (Thermo Fisher Scientific Inc., USA) equipped with
monochromatic Al Kα radiation source as the excitation. The analyses of overlapping peak resolving
were made by XPSPEAK41 software. The non-isothermal thermogravimetric (TG) measurements at
different heating rates (5 K/min, 10 K/min, 20 K/min, and 30 K/min) were performed on a
Thermo Gravimetric Analyzer (TGA)/Differential Scanning Calorimetry (DSC) calorimeter
(Mettler-Toledo Co., Switzerland). The samples were heated under an air flow of 50 mL/min.
Simulation Details
All the theoretical computation results were performed using the DMol
3
module of the Materials
Studio® suite of software[6]. Geometry optimizations for all the structures were simulated using
Perdew-Burke-Ernzerhof function, all electron type of core treatment, and a triple numerical atomic
orbital augmented by additional polarization functions basis set. The free energy for a dissociation
energy at 298 K (
△
G
298 K
) was calculated as follows[3]:
298.15 298.15 298.15 298.15
K K K K
A H AH
G G G G
(1)
Where G
A
298.15K
and G
H
298.15K
are the energies of two free radicals generated by the hemolysis of
the covalent bond at 298.15 K, and G
AH
298.15K
is the energy of the compound AH at 298.15 K.
Results and Discussion
Mechanical Properties
Fig. 1 The changing trends of retained ratios of tensile strength and elongation at break for the two NR
samples.
Fig. 1 shows the changing trends of mechanical properties for the two NR samples. During 120 h
188
Advances in Engineering Research, volume 103
of thermal-oxidative exposure, the retained ratios of tensile strength and elongation at break for the
two NR samples both decrease as time goes by. Besides, the rate of mechanical properties reduction
for Sample A is faster than that for Sample B, indicating that the addition of p-ASALa improves the
antioxidant effect for NR.
Chemical Surface Characterization
The chemical surface characterization of two NR samples are quantitatively analyzed by XPS
measurements. After aging at 353 K for 144 h, the mole ratio of oxygen atom to carbon atom
(n(O)/n(C)) for Sample A changes from 0.180 to 0.231; and (n(O)/n(C)) for Sample B changes from
0.167 to 0.190.The detailed XPS C
1s
core-level spectra are shown in Fig. 2. Four types of carbon
atoms, including C-C and C-H (284.8 eV), C-O (286.1 eV), C=O (287.8 eV), and O=C-O (289.1 eV),
exist in two NR samples. The fractions (the area for the peak of a certain carbon atom divided by the
total area) of these four types of carbon atoms are shown in Table 1. After aging at 353 K for 144h, the
fractions of oxygenic carbon atoms in Sample B are all lower than those in Sample A, indicating that
p-ASALa shows good antioxidant effect in improving the thermal-oxidative stability of NR by
delaying the generation of thermal-oxidative aging products, e.g., ketone, ether, and ester.
Fig. 2 XPS C1s core-level spectra of two NR samples after aging at 353 K for 144h: (a) Sample A; (b)
Sample B.
Tab. 1 XPS analyses for the surface characterizations of two NR samples after aging at 353 K for 144h.
Sample C-C, C-H C-O C=O O-C=O
A 0.745 0.182 0.035 0.038
B 0.775 0.163 0.030 0.032
Kinetic Analysis
The non-isothermal, isoconversional Flynn-Wall-Ozawa (FWO) method analyzed by TGA curves
heating at different rates was proposed to determine the kinetic parameters of the thermo-oxidative
degradation of NR. This method is based on the Doyle[7] approximation for heterogeneous chemical
reactions:
aa
A E E
log log( ) 2.315 0.4567
R G( ) RT
(2)
Where β is the heating rate, A is a pre-exponential factor, E
a
is the activation energy, R is the gas
constant, α is the fractional mass loss, and G(α) is a conversional function. For a certain α, G(α) is
fixed. Therefore, E
a
can be estimated from the slope of the straight line obtained by plotting logβ vs
T
-1
.
189
Advances in Engineering Research, volume 103
Fig. 3 Plots of E
a
versus specified α determined by FWO method.
Fig. 3 shows that each curve has two maximal points, dividing the thermal-oxidative degradation
of NR into three stages[5]. In the first stage, E
a
increases with α until α reaches 10%, corresponding to
the initiation of the chain. In the second stage, when α is from 10% to 15%, E
a
decreases with α
because of the autocatalytic oxidation process during thermo-oxidative degradation. In the final stage,
at α higher than 15%, E
a
increases with α again, reaches a maximum at α of nearly 40%, and then
decreases with α. This final stage is associated with the decomposition of thermo-oxidative products
and the intensification of the thermo-oxidative degradation process. Furthermore, the values of E
a
required for thermal-oxidative degradation at every specified α of Sample B are higher than those of
Sample A, indicating that p-ASALa has better antioxidant effect than antioxidant IPPD in NR.
Different Function Mechanisms of Two Kinds of Antioxidants
By decreasing the concentrations of the active free radicals by preferential reaction relative to
NR[8], the antioxidants IPPD and p-ASALa lower the rate of NR oxidation. However, their function
mechanisms and efficiencies are different.
Tab. 2 The
△
G
298.15K
values of C-H bonds in NR at positions (a), (b), (c) and (d); and N-H bonds in
antioxidant IPPD at positions (e) and (f).
Position
△G
298.15K
[9]
exp
(kJ/mol) △G
298.15K sim
(kJ/mol)
(a) 322.61 345.81
(b) — 435.97
(c) 351.48 424.65
(d) 335.58 354.34
(e) — 304.86
(f) — 324.22
The position (a), (b) and (c) of C-H bonds and the position (d) and (e) of antioxidant IPPD are as
above (blue sphere represents H atom, grey sphere represents C atom, and pink sphere represents N
atom)
The principal mechanism of the thermo-oxidative aging of NR involves an autocatalytic, free
190
Advances in Engineering Research, volume 103
radical chain reaction. The first step is the initiation of the chain. As a typical amine antioxidant,
antioxidant IPPD has an active hydrogen atom (H) in imino group(e). With the less
△
G
298.15K
value at
position (e) than the
△
G
298.15K
value at position (a) of NR, antioxidant IPPD can function as a
labile-hydrogen doner to compete effectively with NR chains for reactions with propagating peroxy
radicals. The main reactions in which the antioxidant IPPD is involved are shown in Scheme 1.
Scheme 1 The function mechanism of antioxidant IPPD (R represents alkyl).
According to Scheme 1, we can conclude that the 1 mole antioxidant IPPDs (molecular
weight=226) contain 2 mole labile hydrogens, each of which can scavenge 1 mole peroxy radicals to
terminate 1 mole free radical chain reactions.
The existence of two primary amine groups of p-ASALa shows the similar reason as
labile-hydrogen doners in protecting NR against autoxidation. It means that 1 mole p-ASALas contain
4 mole labile hydrogens and can terminate 4 mole free radical chain reactions. Besides, with the
electron shell structure of 5d16s2, La has a full empty 4f orbit and a long atom radius, resulting in
strong coordination abilities and large coordination numbers, which exceed 6, normally are 7, 8, 9,
and 10. Therefore, the same mass of p-ASALa (molecular weight=519) is able to scavenge more
peroxy radicals and has better antioxidant effect than antioxidant IPPD to improve the
thermal-oxidative stability of NR.
Summary
After thermal-oxidative exposure, NR sample B with mixed antioxidants composed of antioxidant
IPPD and lanthanum (La) complex exhibited better mechanical properties and lower increases of
three types of carbon-oxygen groups than Sample A with pure antioxidant IPPD. In the
thermal-oxidative degradation process, the activation energy of Sample B at every specified fractional
mass loss was higher than that of Sample A. The results indicated that p-ASALa had better
antioxidant effect than antioxidant IPPD in NR.
The theoretical calculation results showed that 1 mole antioxidant IPPDs could doner 2 mole labile
hydrogens. By effectively competing with hydrogen at position (a) in NR chain, 1 mole antioxidant
IPPDs could scavenge two peroxy radicals to terminate two free radical chain reactions. Except for
the two primary amine groups which could doner 4 mole labile hydrogens, p-ASALa had strong
coordination abilities and large coordination numbers, resulting in the high efficiency of p-ASALa in
enhancing the thermal-oxidative stability of NR.
Acknowledgements
The financial supports from the National Natural Science Foundation of China under Grant No.
51473012 and the Major Research plan from the Ministry of Science and Technology of China under
Grant No. 2014BAE14B01 are gratefully acknowledged.
191
Advances in Engineering Research, volume 103