scispace - formally typeset
Open AccessJournal Article

Antifragile: Things That Gain from Disorder

Chris Arney
- 01 Oct 2013 - 
- Vol. 47, Iss: 3, pp 238
Reads0
Chats0
TLDR
Antifragile as discussed by the authors is a book about the structure and behavior of dynamic systems, where the author classifies systems by the nonlinearity (convexity and concavity) of their utility or health functions as either ant-fragile or fragile.
Abstract
ANTIFRAGILE: THINGS THAT GAIN FROM DISORDER Nassim Nicholas Taleb Random House, New York, 2012, 519 pp. ISBN: 978-1-4000-6782-4Antifragile is a book about the structure and behavior of dynamic systems. To a mathematician, this is mainstream mathematics. However, Taleb, writing for a general audience, seems to try to hide the formal mathematics and obscure its usefulness by his focus on a more literary, historical, and philosophical presentation. Yet, in the end, enough mathematical evidence and explanation of Taleb's antifragile theory as well as examples make this book worthy of consideration. Taleb's theory is simple enough. He classifies systems by the nonlinearity (convexity and concavity) of their utility or health functions as either antifragile or fragile. While never producing a precise measure for this property for systems or entities, he does give myriad interesting examples of his theory in systems, items, and concepts from biology, human nature, natural science, information science, social science, business, literature, politics, and philosophy. Taleb's reason for inventing the term "antifragile" is interesting: "Half of life - the interesting half of life - we don't have a name for." (p. 33)It's a shame that Taleb does not take a more mathematical and scientific approach to his fragility concept, because many excellent points could be made and insights developed that could help to understand his examples. Taleb uses the word "antifragile" to describe systems that are the opposite of fragile, and therefore, usually, a property to celebrate, advocate, design and use to one's benefit. Systems and items that improve or gain from disorder and stress are antifragile to that disorder or stress. The nonlinearity of antifragility can come from many properties of the system: redundancy, complexity, volatility, randomness, and asymmetry, the author's interesting examples come from all areas of life. Some that are rich in flavor and insight include health, medicine, love, banking, traffic, research, decision making, education, ethics, government, religion, smoking, technology, and weightlifting. The author is careful to contrast the antifragility property with related but different concepts of robustness and resilience.This book contains seven sections (called books), a glossary, a bibliography, and two appendices. The first and most insightful table is a five-page Table of Triads - a classification of dozens of elements by their range of fragility (fragility on one end, antifragile on the other, and robustness in the middle - thus the term triad). For example, directed research is fragile, opportunistic research is robust, and stochastic tinkering is antifragile. Corporate employment is fragile, the dental profession is robust, and taxi driving can be considered antifragile. Bureaucrats are fragile and entrepreneurs are antifragile. In literature, e-readers are fragile, books are robust, and oral tradition is antifragile. Mother Nature is Taleb's prime example of antifragility - living things like "a certain measure of randomness and disorder", (p. …

read more

Citations
More filters
Journal ArticleDOI

Examining Rock Engineering Knowledge through a Philosophical Lens

TL;DR: In this article , a conceptual model of engineering knowledge that combines experience (practical knowledge) and a priori knowledge (knowledge that is not based on experience) is proposed to explain the challenges we face in rock engineering design at a time when digitalisation includes the introduction of machine algorithms that are supposed to learn from conditions of limited information.

Heinrich’s Local Rationality: Shouldn’t ‘New View’ Thinkers Ask Why Things Made Sense To Him?

Carsten Busch
TL;DR: In this article, the authors explore how "new view" thinkers/authors discuss Heinrich and whether they apply the approaches they advocate to Heinrich's work, and they show that most of them take a position and discuss things from that point of view and rarely do they seek deep explanations or explore alternatives.
Journal ArticleDOI

Covid-19, globalización, complejidad e incertidumbre: algunas reflexiones sobre gestión empresarial en tiempos de crisis y más allá

TL;DR: In this article, the authors examine caracteristicas de crisis economica, tanto en sus diferencias como en sus similitu-des con crisis anteriores, and aventurar algunas de las consecuencias esperables de la misma, se abordan sugerencias en el ambito empresarial, to parasuperar sus efectos inmediatos como para afrontar la supervivencia empresarian a mas largo plazo.
Journal ArticleDOI

Right to Place: A Political Theory of Animal Rights in Harmony with Environmental and Ecological Principles

TL;DR: The right to place theory as discussed by the authors advocates human noninterference in wildlife communities, opposing even humanitarian interventions, which carry the risk of unintended consequences, based on the non-generalist nature of many species and the potential for abuse via human encroachment.
Journal Article

Separate but Equal on College Campuses: A Case of "'Déjà Vu' All over Again".

TL;DR: The authors argue that segregation of racial and ethnic groups on university and college campuses generally appear to exacerbate racial tensions and reinforce in-group and out-group interactions and biases, and that multicultural integration builds trust, reduces outgroup biases, increases friendships across race and ethnic lines, and advances racial reconciliation.