Problem structure and the use of base-rate information from experience.

TLDR: In this article, the use of base-rate information that is derived from experience in classifying examples of a category was investigated. But, the results reveal a consistent but complex pattern depending on the category structure and the nature of the ambiguous tests, participants use base rate information appropriately, ignore base rate, or use baserate information inappropriately (predict that the rare disease is more likely to be present).

Abstract: This article is concerned with the use of base-rate information that is derived from experience in classifying examples of a category The basic task involved simulated medical decision making in which participants learned to diagnose hypothetical diseases on the basis of symptom information Alternative diseases differed in their relative frequency or base rates of occurrence In five experiments initial learning was followed by a series of transfer tests designed to index the use of base-rate information On these tests, patterns of symptoms were presented that suggested more than one disease and were therefore ambiguous The alternative or candidate diseases on such tests could differ in their relative frequency of occurrence during learning For example, a symptom might be presented that had appeared with both a relatively common and a relatively rare disease If participants are using base-rate information appropriately (according to Bayes' theorem), then they should be more likely to predict that the common disease is present than that the rare disease is present on such ambiguous tests Current classification models differ in their predictions concerning the use of base-rate information For example, most prototype models imply an insensitivity to base-rate information, whereas many exemplar-based classification models predict appropriate use of base-rate information The results reveal a consistent but complex pattern Depending on the category structure and the nature of the ambiguous tests, participants use base-rate information appropriately, ignore base-rate information, or use base-rate information inappropriately (predict that the rare disease is more likely to be present) To our knowledge, no current categorization model predicts this pattern of results To account for these results, a new model is described incorporating the ideas of property or symptom competition and context-sensitive retrieval