Search or ask a question

Is good modelling practices a common taught area in ecology?

Ecology (disciplines)

Process (computing)

Environmental niche modelling

Decision support system

Best insight from top research papers

Good modelling practices are crucial in ecology, yet they are not commonly taught. Despite the pressing need for transparent and robust modelling in addressing environmental challenges like climate change, the literature highlights widespread deficiencies in modelling practices, often due to inadequate documentation and lack of adherence to established standards . The implementation of ecological niche modeling and species distribution modeling tools has significantly increased over the years, emphasizing the importance of promoting good practices and providing guidance for new users . Furthermore, a proposed standard format for documenting models, known as TRACE documentation, aims to enhance transparency and coherence in ecological modelling, suggesting a strategy for improving future modelling practices . Overall, while the significance of good modelling practices is acknowledged, there is a clear need to integrate these practices more effectively into ecological education at the university level .

Answers from top 5 papers

PDF

Open Access

More filters

Papers (5)	Insight
Journal Article•DOI General Theory and Good Practices in Ecological Niche Modeling: A Basic Guide Marianna V. P. Simões, Daniel Romero-Alvarez, Claudia Nuñez-Penichet, Laura Jiménez, Marlon E. Cobos - Show less +4 more 09 Apr 2020-Biodiversity Informatics 31 Citations	Yes, good modeling practices are emphasized in ecology, particularly in ecological niche modeling (ENM) and species distribution modeling (SDM) to ensure accuracy and standardization in predictions.
Journal Article•DOI Ecological models supporting environmental decision making: a strategy for the future Amelie Schmolke, Pernille Thorbek, Donald L. DeAngelis, Volker Grimm - Show less +3 more 01 Aug 2010-Trends in Ecology and Evolution 382 Citations	Good modeling practices are recognized in ecology but often ignored. A proposed standard format, TRACE documentation, aims to enhance transparency and efficiency in ecological modeling for better decision support.
Open access Good modelling practice: expanding the ODD model description protocol for socioenvironmental agent based models Jürgen Groeneveld, Birgit Müller, F. Angermüller, Romina Drees, Gunnar Dressler, Christian Klassert, Jule Schulze, Hanna Weise, Nina Schwarz - Show less +8 more 01 Jan 2012 3 Citations	Not addressed in the paper.
Posted Content•DOI Instrumenting good modelling practice as common practice Anthony Jakeman 15 May 2023	Not addressed in the paper.
Open access The ecological relativity of modelling practices: adaptations of an study and research path to different university settings Berta Barquero 05 Apr 2018 3 Citations	Not addressed in the paper.

My columns

Related Questions

How have ecology curricula incorporated good modeling practices in the last decade?5 answersIn the last decade, ecology curricula have increasingly integrated good modeling practices to enhance ecological training and research. This incorporation involves the utilization of individually based and pattern-oriented models, allowing for the explicit representation of variability among individuals in a population and the incorporation of information obtained at different hierarchical levels of the study system. Furthermore, there has been a push towards transparent and comprehensive ecological modeling (TRACE) documentation as a standard format for documenting models and their analyses, aiming to make modeling more efficient, coherent, and transparent. These advancements in modeling strategies and documentation standards have contributed to expanding the domain of application for ecological modeling and improving the overall quality of ecological research and decision-making processes in the field of ecology.

Has there been an increase in teaching good modelling practices in ecology?4 answersYes, there has been an increase in teaching good modeling practices in ecology. Various studies have highlighted the importance of incorporating ecosystem simulation modeling into ecology curricula to enhance students' understanding and skills in this area. Additionally, the use of immersive virtual environments has been shown to support student engagement in modeling practices specific to ecosystem science, aligning with expert practices in the field. Furthermore, there is a growing emphasis on developing didactic models and modeling processes that promote actions for socio-ecojustice, reflecting a broader trend towards integrating sustainability and socio-political activism in educational activities. These advancements indicate a positive shift towards enhancing modeling practices in ecology education at both undergraduate and graduate levels.

Are researchers being trained on good modelling practices?5 answersResearchers are indeed being trained on good modelling practices, as highlighted in various research papers. The importance of good modelling practice is emphasized due to the complexity and cross-sectoral nature of the issues being addressed, such as climate change, water, energy, agriculture, and socio-economy. Recommendations for best practices in conceptualizing models, dealing with uncertainty, and validating models transparently have been outlined to support decision-making in health technology assessment. However, there are challenges in the uptake of process-based models in heritage science, with limited engagement and practical application reported in academic literature. Workshops involving experienced researchers and supervisors have been effective in helping PhD students develop a more strategic approach to their research, aiming to improve completion rates in science and engineering disciplines.

How can ecological models be used to improve STI testing?5 answersEcological models can be used to improve STI testing by considering individual, social, and health service factors that influence testing behavior. At the individual level, limited knowledge about STIs and attitudinal barriers against testing can hinder willingness to get tested. Social influences, such as social networks and peer perceptions, can both promote and inhibit STI testing. Health service factors, including the location and visibility of clinics, appointment procedures, and waiting times, can also impact access to testing. Understanding these socio-ecological factors is crucial for developing strategies to improve STI testing uptake. Factors such as improved sexual health education, preferences for different types of services, and addressing stigma associated with STIs should be considered. Integrating STI self-testing with HIV self-testing can leverage the feasibility and demand generated by HIV self-testing to expand STI testing coverage. Additionally, ensuring that all providers offer confidential and unbiased STI care is important for increasing testing rates.

What is modeling in ecology?4 answersModeling in ecology refers to the construction and analysis of mathematical models that aim to understand the complexity of ecological processes and predict how ecosystems might evolve. These models are used to estimate habitat suitability, forecast species distributions, inform decision-making in environmental protection, and assess the ecological basis of various phenomena. Ecological models can be used to study a wide range of topics, including species distribution, genetic makeup, local adaptation, gene flow, ecosystem restoration, water operations, and environmental impact assessment. They are developed through phases of conceptualization, quantification, evaluation, application, and communication, with evaluation involving techniques such as calibration, verification, validation, and review. These models are essential for understanding the mechanisms that shape the assembly and evolution of microbial communities and for studying the interactions between microbes and their environment. Overall, ecological modeling is a powerful tool that combines theory and data to improve our understanding of ecological processes and inform decision-making in various fields.

What do ecologists make models?13 answers

See what other people are reading

How does evaluation of alternatives play an important role in consumer decision making?

Evaluation of alternatives is crucial in consumer decision making as it aids in selecting the most suitable option. Various models, such as additive methods and regret aversion models, help integrate criteria-based assessments to determine the attractiveness of alternatives. High consumer involvement leads to a more selective evaluation of brands, impacting brand attitudes and awareness. In the context of product safety, Alternatives Analysis is essential to identify safer options and avoid regrettable substitutions, aligning with regulations like the Safer Consumer Products (SCP) guidelines. These assessments consider technical functions, hazards, exposure pathways, and economic impacts to ensure robust decision-making. Overall, evaluating alternatives not only guides consumer choices but also ensures compliance with safety regulations and enhances overall decision-making processes.What are the most popular types of agroforestry systems practiced by farmers globally?

The most popular types of agroforestry systems practiced by farmers globally include improved fallow, alley cropping, multifunctional trees on farms and rangelands, home gardens, windbreaks, shelterbelts, silvopastoral grazing systems, taungya farming, and shaded perennial-crop systems. These systems are valued for their ability to enhance agricultural production, increase soil fertility, mitigate climate change, alleviate food insecurity, and uplift rural livelihoods by providing diverse products like food, fuelwood, timber, and income. Agroforestry systems cover approximately 1 billion hectares worldwide and are seen as a means to diversify production, income, and services, especially in developing countries. The integration of trees with crops or pastures in agroforestry systems is crucial for achieving sustainable practices that benefit both farmers and the environment.Classroom environment and Student engagement in Davao city local?

In Davao City, Philippines, research indicates a significant focus on student engagement and the classroom environment. Studies show that students in Davao City exhibit high motivation for learning and engage in various interactions, with effective teaching playing a mediating role in enhancing student engagement. Additionally, the classroom environment is highlighted as a crucial factor in moderating teacher creativity and academic stability among Filipino students in the region. Furthermore, findings from Mindanao, a province in the Philippines, suggest that teachers in the region, while skilled at creating supportive learning environments, may need improvement in areas such as setting positive behavioral expectations and promoting critical thinking among students. These insights underscore the importance of the classroom environment in fostering student engagement and academic success in Davao City.What is traffic prediction?

Traffic prediction is a multifaceted approach aimed at forecasting traffic flow and conditions to alleviate congestion, improve traffic management, and support the development of autonomous vehicles. It encompasses analyzing various factors that influence traffic, such as accidents, traffic signals, road repairs, and rallies, to provide accurate and timely information for drivers, passengers, and traffic management systems. The evolution of traffic prediction has been significantly driven by the exponential growth of traffic data and the shift towards big data concepts in transportation, highlighting the need for sophisticated models to handle real-world applications. Machine learning, genetic algorithms, soft computing, and deep learning are among the primary technologies employed to analyze the vast amounts of data generated within transportation systems. These technologies aim to reduce complexity and improve the accuracy of traffic predictions by leveraging historical and real-time data. Additionally, traffic prediction models utilize various data types, including GPS probe data from vehicles, to understand and predict traffic patterns more effectively. Recent advancements have introduced novel methods like the graph convolutional neural network with a spectral adjacency matrix (GCN-Spectral), which considers both temporal patterns and spatial relationships among roads to enhance traffic condition predictions. Furthermore, the integration of image processing algorithms for traffic sign recognition plays a crucial role in the training of autonomous vehicles, indicating the broad applicability of traffic prediction technologies. The field of traffic prediction is continuously evolving, with ongoing research focused on addressing open challenges and exploring new opportunities in AI-based traffic prediction methods. This includes the development of multivariate traffic time series modeling and the exploration of statistical models and machine learning-based forecasting methods to improve the performance of intelligent transportation systems. The ultimate goal of traffic prediction is to enhance traffic flow, reduce congestion, and support the future of mobility by providing advanced forecasting tools and methodologies.What are hairline cracks in buildings?

Hairline cracks in buildings are fine, shallow cracks that develop on surfaces like cement plaster due to factors such as shrinkage, poor quality of materials, and inadequate curing. These cracks, which can be microscopic, pose a threat to a building's structural integrity. Hairline cracks can also occur on insulating coats of cable cores due to factors like UV exposure, leading to deterioration and potential insulation issues. In injection-molded components like PET, hairline cracks can affect fracture modes, with their depth and location influencing the material's toughness and notch sensitivity. Detection of hairline cracks in structures like pipelines is crucial, with techniques like Magnetic Flux Leakage used to visualize and interpret signals for crack detection and characterization.How can technology helps teacher in planning for instruction?

Technology can support teachers in planning for instruction through various models and tools. For instance, the Technology Integration Planning Cycle (TIPC) aids teachers in evaluating digital tools' contributions to meeting learning goals. Additionally, the Instrumental Orchestration model helps prospective mathematics teachers develop their teaching practices by integrating dynamic mathematics software into their instruction. Moreover, the Teacher Action Planner (TAP) leverages natural language processing methods to analyze student explanations and provide teachers with customized instructional recommendations based on student progress, aligning with educational standards. These tools and models not only assist in structuring lesson plans but also enhance teachers' ability to incorporate technology effectively into their teaching practices, ultimately improving the quality of instruction.How far does chatbots afftects brand trust?

Chatbots significantly impact brand trust by influencing user self-disclosure, privacy concerns, and the formation of consumer attitudes towards a brand. Research shows that users prefer chatbots in platforms like Telegram and Viber. Privacy concerns negatively affect user self-disclosure, highlighting the importance of building trust through easing privacy concerns. The design of a chatbot's personality plays a crucial role in generating a human interaction, showcasing brand values, and fostering trust and closeness with users. Personalizing chatbots with consumer characteristics like gender enhances trust and perceived closeness between customers and the brand, ultimately increasing upselling potential. Therefore, companies should carefully consider the design, functionality, and personality of chatbots to enhance brand trust and user experience.How do these experiences differ between students who excel in research and those who struggle?

Students who excel in research tend to have rewarding research experiences, leading to skill development and higher satisfaction levels. On the other hand, students who struggle in research often face challenges such as difficulties in the writing process, high stress, and emotional struggles, with supervisors sometimes taking on a significant role in the final product. Additionally, high-achieving students are less likely to label their struggles as failures compared to lower-achieving students, indicating a difference in how they perceive and react to setbacks. These contrasting experiences highlight the importance of individual differences in research experiences and their impact on skill development, satisfaction, and coping mechanisms among students in academic settings.What is definition of vsm method in lean?

Value Stream Mapping (VSM) is a lean manufacturing tool designed to visualize the entire production process, representing both material and information flows, with the primary goal of identifying waste and opportunities for improvement. It serves as a critical analytical tool for transforming the production environment into a lean operational state by highlighting inefficiencies and facilitating the elimination of waste. VSM is not only applicable in manufacturing but extends its utility to designing sustainable supply chains by assessing performance through realistic indicators, thereby supporting the lean-driven sustainability approach. This method's adaptability allows it to address the dynamic nature of manufacturing processes by incorporating simulation and multiple-attribute decision-making (MADM) to prioritize improvement initiatives and evaluate multiple performance metrics. The application of VSM has evolved to include an extended version (X-VSM), which increases the level of detail in process representation and supports process simulation for strategic management decisions regarding waste reduction. Moreover, VSM, combined with simulation models, has proven effective in designing lean service systems, validating the lean concepts' implementation in various sectors beyond traditional manufacturing. Despite its proven efficacy, the implementation of VSM in complex production environments poses challenges, necessitating a tailored approach to effectively leverage its benefits. Recent advancements have seen the integration of VSM with simulation approaches, such as ARENA, to optimize manufacturing processes, significantly reducing cycle times and improving ecological parameters. This integration underscores VSM's capability as a diagnostic and planning tool, providing a lean perspective to identify opportunities for implementing various lean projects or tools. However, the method's future sustainability is contingent upon its adaptation to the ongoing digitalization, addressing its current limitations and enhancing its flexibility. Lastly, VSM's role in lean manufacturing philosophy is underscored by its effectiveness in identifying wastes at each production stage, facilitating the selection and prioritization of lean tools for waste elimination and process flow enhancement.What should be understood about people analysis in the training needs numerator?

People analysis in the training needs numerator involves understanding the importance of identifying training needs within organizations to enhance employee skills and adaptability to changing environments. This process requires a systematic approach to assess current competencies and future requirements, aligning training programs with strategic objectives. Utilizing People Analytics (PA) can aid in creating personalized training programs for employees, ensuring effectiveness and profitability of investments in training initiatives. Globalization and technological advancements necessitate continuous skill development to maintain competitiveness, highlighting the significance of training needs analysis in addressing evolving market demands and organizational structures. Overall, a comprehensive understanding of people analysis in the training needs numerator is crucial for organizations to optimize their human resources and achieve sustainable development goals.What does triangulation mean?

Triangulation in research refers to the strategic use of multiple datasets, methodologies, theories, and investigators to address a research question effectively. It enhances the credibility, validity, and completeness of research findings. By combining different methods or observers, triangulation helps overcome biases and offers a more balanced explanation of complex human behavior. In high-tech service markets, triangulation techniques are crucial for overcoming research constraints and ensuring the validity and credibility of outputs. This methodological approach allows researchers to confront information from various angles, minimizing bias resulting from a single analytical perspective in qualitative studies. Triangulation is a critical and knowledge-generating procedure that validates data, enriches research, and provides a more robust foundation for drawing conclusions in both qualitative and quantitative studies.