What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of making student grades publicly available?
Best insight from top research papers
Making student grades publicly available has potential benefits and drawbacks. On the one hand, publicly available grades can improve institutional legitimacy and ensure ongoing support for educational institutions . It can also provide more information to the reader of a transcript and produce more meaningful letter grades, which may encourage students to take courses with lower median grades . Additionally, publicly available grades can allow students to easily access their own grades and track their progress . On the other hand, making grades public can diminish or undermine institutional legitimacy . Students may be concerned about their grades being made public and may prefer to keep them private . There are also security concerns associated with publicly posting grades, as it can potentially lead to unauthorized access or breaches of confidentiality .
Answers from top 4 papers
More filters
| Papers (4) | Insight |
|---|---|
Open access•Posted Content 01 Jan 2004 2 Citations | The provided paper does not discuss the potential benefits and drawbacks of making student grades publicly available. |
| The potential benefits of making student grades publicly available include providing more information to readers of transcripts and encouraging students to take courses with lower median grades. The drawbacks are not mentioned in the paper. | |
47 Citations | The potential benefits and drawbacks of making student grades publicly available are not mentioned in the provided paper. The paper focuses on the influence of school accountability data format on public perceptions of school quality. |
01 Dec 2016 2 Citations | The potential benefits and drawbacks of making student grades publicly available are not mentioned in the provided paper. The paper focuses on privacy-preserving data publishing using Bayesian networks in the field of education. |
Related Questions
What are the potential benefits and drawbacks of using student grades as a measure of academic performance?10 answersThe use of student grades as a measure of academic performance is a deeply entrenched practice within educational systems worldwide, serving multiple purposes including rating student progress and communicating students' status in achieving learning goals. Grades are often seen as a straightforward output of the educational process, potentially influencing student performance positively by providing clear benchmarks for success. Moreover, grades can serve as important indicators and predictors of students' final academic outcomes, offering a compact representation of academic-performance trajectories.
However, the reliance on grades comes with significant drawbacks. The grading system has been criticized for creating a restrictive environment that limits innovation and divergent thinking, while also impacting students' social and psychological well-being negatively. The process of assigning grades can diminish their accuracy in reporting students' progress due to factors like effort, attendance, and improvement being considered alongside achievement, contributing to grade inflation and giving students a false impression of their abilities. Furthermore, the transformation of student performance into letter grades and the practice of curving can introduce measurement errors and non-comparability, challenging the causal identification of educational interventions' efficacy.
Empirical research has highlighted the methodological issues associated with grading, pointing out its limitations in terms of validity, reliability, and objectivity, which in turn affects the learning process and the students themselves. Additionally, the predictive power of grades on academic performance, while significant, is complex and influenced by various factors beyond the classroom, including online activity data in web-based learning systems. The practice of grade retention, based on students' grades, has also been shown to have a negative impact on student performance, questioning the efficacy of using grades as a measure for such decisions.
In conclusion, while grades can provide valuable benchmarks and serve as predictors of academic success, their use as the sole measure of academic performance is fraught with challenges that can undermine educational objectives and student well-being.
What are the negative impacts of rankings on students?5 answersRankings in education, such as school and student rankings, have been associated with various negative impacts on students. The abolition of ranking in Kenya led to negative outcomes, including decreased student commitment to academic performance and increased malpractices in national examinations. Performance ranking in Mathematics teaching can lead to a lack of balance in student engagement, where top-ranked students become powerful independent learners while low-ranked students may struggle to seek help effectively. Additionally, the use of rating and ranking systems in higher education can create competition and antagonism among students, affecting how individuals and institutions perceive themselves. Overall, rankings can narrow the curriculum, encourage unhealthy competition, and negatively influence student morale and parental involvement in academic matters.
What are the benefits and drawbacks of focusing on grades versus learnings?4 answersFocusing on grades can lead to students valuing grades more than learning, which can create a mismatch between teacher and student orientations. This emphasis on grades can result in students prioritizing achieving a good grade over actually learning the course material. Grade-oriented students may have poor study habits, high test anxiety, and lower grade point averages. On the other hand, a focus on learning can lead to students viewing college as an opportunity to acquire new information and develop positive educational attributes. Shifting the focus from grading to a solid focus on student learning can have a positive impact on student achievement. However, the pressure to achieve certain grades and the prevalence of grade-focused interactions may make it difficult to change students' fixation on grades. Overall, while grades can provide motivation and accountability, a focus on learning can lead to a more effective learning environment and positive educational outcomes.
What are the benefits and drawbacks of removing notebooks from the grading system?5 answersRemoving notebooks from the grading system has benefits and drawbacks. On the positive side, it encourages students to focus more on the learning process rather than the daily grade. It also promotes collaboration among students, as they are more likely to discuss and compare answers when using notebooks. Additionally, transitioning to computer-based writing assessments allows students to work in a format that is more familiar to them and aligns with the increasing use of technology in education. However, there are also drawbacks to removing notebooks from the grading system. Teachers may struggle to reproduce the results contained in the notebooks, especially when students rely on the non-linearity of notebooks to write and execute code cells in an arbitrary order. Furthermore, using web-based notebooks may not necessarily improve problem-solving skills and could even result in a slight decrease in these skills.
What are the criteria for making information available to the public?5 answersMaking information available to the public requires several criteria. Firstly, the information should be accessible without any restrictions, including economical, technical, social, or legal barriers, and should be available for any purpose, such as mashup and annotation. Secondly, the information should be provided in open formats and include information for reusability, as well as clear licensing conditions to avoid legal interoperability issues. Additionally, public policies should be enacted to ensure that data produced and digitalized with public funding is uploaded in an open format, thus populating institutional platforms with data. Furthermore, transparency is crucial, and communities should have access to information about development proposals, with better clarity on what information should be available. Lastly, access to information is essential for effective community input into environmental decision-making, particularly in relation to industrial waste and chemical hazards.
What are the drawbacks of being an undecided student?3 answersUndecided students face several drawbacks. They are more likely to leave college before graduation, often due to poor academic standing. Additionally, they may experience identity confusion as they navigate through the process of choosing a major or career path. These students have indicated few significant differences compared to decided students, suggesting that their indecision is a normal part of their developmental journey. It is important for academic advisors, career counselors, teachers, and administrators to understand the developmental stages of undecided students and provide appropriate support and guidance.