What is the concept of a "borderless world" in anthropology?
Best insight from top research papers
The concept of a "borderless world" in anthropology is multifaceted, reflecting a range of interpretations and implications for understanding social, cultural, and political dynamics. Initially gaining prominence in the aftermath of the Cold War, the idea of a borderless world was intertwined with the ideologies of globalization and the anticipation of a new era of unbounded human interaction and exchange. This vision was not merely about the physical dismantling of borders but also about challenging the underlying social relations of production and power. Anthropological perspectives on a borderless world often emphasize the lived experiences of individuals and communities navigating these invisible yet profoundly impactful boundaries. The focus on movement as a means of understanding social spaces reveals how people's lives are shaped by the fluidity and constraints of borders, whether they are moving across nomadic landscapes or navigating the complexities of urban environments. This approach challenges static interpretations of space and place, urging a consideration of the human dimension in conditions of conflict, upheaval, and remapping. The ambiguity of borders as both physical and imagined constructs is central to their anthropological examination. Borders are seen as products of human practice and imagination, with their transformation being a critical step towards addressing the violent and oppressive nature of border practices. This perspective is enriched by the analysis of "imagined" and "phantom" borders, which persist in the collective memory and everyday symbolic manifestations of communities, influencing local regionalism and separatist tendencies. Moreover, the deterritorialization of culture and the shift from viewing societies as bounded systems to recognizing the intensive mobility enabled by modern transportation and communication technologies highlight the changing context of anthropological research. This evolving landscape underscores the importance of rethinking borders in the age of networks, where the idea of a borderless world represents both a conceptual challenge and a transformative potential. In summary, the concept of a "borderless world" in anthropology encapsulates a critical examination of borders as multifaceted phenomena that shape human experiences, social relations, and cultural dynamics, reflecting a complex interplay between physical realities and imagined landscapes.
Answers from top 10 papers
More filters
| Papers (10) | Insight |
|---|---|
01 Jan 2018 | A "borderless world" in anthropology explores freedom, border ambiguity, and various perspectives on borders as labor market regulators, birth privilege enforcers, and mechanisms of oppression, requiring careful transformation. |
08 Jun 2014 8 Citations | A "borderless world" in anthropology explores freedom, border ambiguity, and various perspectives on borders as labor market regulators, birth privilege enforcers, and mechanisms of oppression, requiring careful transformation. |
25 Oct 2018 4 Citations | A "borderless world" in anthropology explores freedom, border ambiguity, and various perspectives on borders as labor market regulators, birth privilege enforcers, and mechanisms of oppression, requiring careful transformation. |
| A "borderless world" in anthropology explores freedom, border ambiguity, and various perspectives on borders as labor market regulators, birth privilege enforcers, and mechanisms of oppression, requiring careful transformation. | |
| A "borderless world" in anthropology explores freedom, border ambiguity, and various perspectives on borders as labor market regulators, birth privilege enforcers, and mechanisms of oppression, requiring careful transformation. | |
| A "borderless world" in anthropology explores freedom, border ambiguity, and various perspectives on borders as labor market regulators, birth privilege enforcers, and mechanisms of oppression, requiring careful transformation. | |
| A "borderless world" in anthropology explores freedom, border ambiguity, and various perspectives on borders as labor market regulators, birth privilege enforcers, and mechanisms of oppression, requiring careful transformation. | |
2 Citations | The concept of a "borderless world" in anthropology emerged post-Cold War, emphasizing global interconnectedness and mobility, sparking scholarly debates on ethics and moralities of such fluid mobilities. |
3 Citations | The concept of a "borderless world" in anthropology is linked to globalization, emphasizing ethical considerations, moralities, and mobilities, particularly since the early 1990s. |
| The concept of a "borderless world" in anthropology advocates for the abolition of borders to transform social relations, disrupting the capital-labor power dynamic for a more equitable society. |
Related Questions
What is musical borderland concept?5 answersThe concept of musical borderlands refers to the intersection between song and speech, emphasizing the fluidity and interconnectedness of musical and linguistic expressions. It involves the study of vocal expressions that blur the lines between traditional definitions of song and speech, incorporating elements from ethnomusicology, prosody, syntax, and semantics. In the context of African hip hop music, the notion of musical borderlands highlights the dynamic relationships between material production, social practices, and cultural content, fostering new socialities and trans-local solidarities. Additionally, in the realm of music psychology, interdisciplinary research explores the connections between scientific and humanistic approaches to music studies, aiming to deepen our understanding of musical life and enhance collaboration across different disciplines.
How has the study of borderlands evolved over time within anthropology?10 answersThe study of borderlands within anthropology has undergone significant evolution, reflecting broader shifts in focus and methodology over time. Initially, borderlands were primarily understood in physical terms, as demarcated by natural features like rivers and mountains, but this perspective has expanded to encompass the complex socio-political and cultural dimensions of these regions. The early historiographic studies, notably those by Herbert Eugene Bolton on the Spanish borderlands in America, laid the groundwork by exploring colonial frontiers, thereby setting a precedent for the multifaceted examination of borderlands.
Over the decades, the scope of borderland studies has broadened, influenced by seminal works such as Anzaldua's "Borderlands/La Frontera," which highlighted the lived experiences of individuals at the margins, including issues of gender, race, class, and cultural identity. This shift towards examining the human aspect of borderlands has propelled researchers to adopt more nuanced, interdisciplinary approaches. Anthropologists and historians have increasingly employed a borderlands perspective to investigate interactions, power dynamics, and identity formation between emerging or expanding state societies, moving beyond the simplistic early focus on geographical demarcations.
Recent research has emphasized the unique educational and social identity opportunities presented by borderlands, recognizing these regions as spaces of linguistic growth, literacy, and interpersonal conflict. This reflects a broader understanding of borderlands not just as lines on a map, but as dynamic spaces of cultural exchange and transformation. Moreover, the anthropological focus has expanded to include the complexities and ambiguities of political borders, examining border economies, cross-border trade, and the administration and security of borders.
Contemporary studies also explore the relational features of borderlands, examining community emergence, the role of "outsidedness," and the temporal dimensions of borderland experiences. This evolution signifies a move towards a more interactive and collaborative research approach, incorporating multi-sited curatorial and anthropological research to tease out the manifold aspects of borderlands. Thus, the study of borderlands within anthropology has evolved from a focus on physical demarcations to a rich, interdisciplinary exploration of the spaces where cultures meet, conflict, and blend.
What were the key developments in the study of borders during the early years of anthropology?10 answersThe study of borders within the field of anthropology has undergone significant developments since its inception, particularly marked by a shift from a focus on border determinations to a more nuanced understanding of border practices and their socio-spatial implications. In the early years, anthropological interest in borders was primarily concerned with the issues of border determinations, especially in the context of the early 20th century, as seen in studies around Turkish political borders which began to emerge in the early 1990s. This period was characterized by an emphasis on the geopolitical and territorial aspects of borders, reflecting broader disciplinary trends within anthropology and related fields.
However, as the field evolved, there was a notable shift towards examining the everyday lives and practices of those living in border regions. This is exemplified by the work on the Slovenian-Hungarian border, which aimed to provide a grounded understanding of how border regimes have changed and how these changes have informed the border region in diverse ways. Such studies marked a departure from earlier approaches by focusing on the lived experiences of border actors and their own border practices, thereby enriching the anthropological inquiry into borders.
Moreover, the early anthropological focus on border determinations expanded to include considerations of border economies, cross-border trade, and the maintenance of border security. This broader perspective helped to illuminate the complexities, marginalities, and ambiguities of political borders, moving beyond a simplistic view of borders as mere lines on a map.
The developments in the study of borders within anthropology also reflect a growing recognition of the importance of materiality and the role of boundaries as assemblages of actants that take on agencies beyond notions of territory. This conceptual shift has been instrumental in framing borders not just as physical demarcations but as dynamic entities that shape and are shaped by social relations and practices.
In summary, the early years of anthropology's engagement with the study of borders were marked by a focus on border determinations and geopolitical considerations, which gradually evolved to encompass a more nuanced understanding of borders as lived spaces and practices. This evolution reflects broader shifts within the field towards a more complex and relational understanding of borders.
How have borders been defined and conceptualized in anthropological research?10 answersIn anthropological research, borders have been defined and conceptualized through a variety of lenses, reflecting the complexity and multifaceted nature of boundaries. Fauzie Sarjono and Endang Rudiatin emphasize the importance of understanding borders from the perspective of borderlanders, incorporating variables such as culture, ethnicity, identity, and socio-political segregation, advocating for a qualitative, ethnographic approach with a constructivist lens. Mark W. Hauser discusses the renaissance in anthropological archaeology's focus on boundaries, highlighting the role of materiality and the work of boundaries as assemblages of actants beyond mere territorial lines. Chiara Brambilla calls for a continued dialogue between critical border studies and anthropology to advance research on borders and the border-migration nexus, positioning borders as a significant "laboratory" for anthropological inquiry.
Yuliia Buiskykh introduces the concepts of "imagined" and "phantom" borders, which persist in the human experience and cultural memory beyond their physical manifestations, influencing local communities and societal dynamics. Stephen Campbell, through the review of ethnographies, underscores the violent structuring logics of borders, shaping global population movements and socio-spatial differentiation. Monika Winarnita, Sharyn Graham Davies, and Nicholas Herriman explore how fashion and thresholds at borders reflect broader societal changes in morality and gender, using Indonesia as a case study.
Martha Liliana Arévalo Peña presents a migrant-centric view of borders, exploring the real, symbolic, and imaginary aspects of borders through the territorialization processes experienced by migrants. Isabel G. Gamero Cabrera critiques early anthropological approaches to borders for their isolated view of culture and highlights newer approaches that recognize the complexity of boundary spaces and transnational networks. Lastly, two monographs provide a comprehensive introduction to the anthropology of borders, presenting case studies that illustrate the dynamic nature of border regimes and practices in a Slovenian border region, emphasizing the evolving relationship between border actors and border changes.
Together, these perspectives illustrate the diverse and evolving anthropological conceptualizations of borders, ranging from physical and material aspects to symbolic, imagined, and experienced dimensions, highlighting the interdisciplinary nature of border studies.
How does the concept of borderland-mestizaje feminism challenge traditional notions of identity and tribalism?4 answersThe concept of borderland-mestizaje feminism challenges traditional notions of identity and tribalism by advocating for a decolonized understanding of the world and promoting the visibility of marginalized voices. Borderland spaces, such as Zimbabwe's borderlands, have seen the growth of community archives as a form of counter-archiving and documenting the stories of marginalized ethnic indigenous groups. These community archives serve as a way for the marginalized to tell their stories, which are often side-lined by those in power. Through the use of multilingualism and hybrid linguistic practices, borderland poets explore the mestizo identities and challenge the dominant narratives. Transnational feminist practice in borderland spaces aims to detach from Euro-centric structures and ground itself locally, challenging traditional power dynamics. Overall, the concept of borderland-mestizaje feminism disrupts traditional notions of identity and tribalism by centering marginalized voices, challenging dominant narratives, and advocating for decolonization.
Are borders necessary in today's globalized world?7 answers