Which oversampling method performs the best?
Best insight from top research papers
The oversampling methods proposed in the research papers show promising results in addressing the class imbalance issue in various domains. Among these methods, the outlier detectable generative adversarial network (OD-GAN), the preprocessing method based on SeqGAN, the oversampling method OS-CCD, and the WASSKIL method have demonstrated effectiveness in improving classification performance on imbalanced datasets. Additionally, an oversampling method for string data has been proposed, showing better results than existing methods. Each method introduces unique approaches to tackle the imbalanced dataset problem, with experiments showcasing their superiority over traditional oversampling techniques. However, the specific performance comparison across these methods is not directly provided in the contexts, making it challenging to definitively determine which oversampling method performs the best.
Answers from top 5 papers
More filters
| Papers (5) | Insight |
|---|---|
| The oversampling method presented in the paper outperforms state-of-the-art methods, especially for highly imbalanced problems, while also being faster. | |
34 Citations | The Oversampling method using Outlier Detectable Generative Adversarial Network (OD-GAN) outperforms other methods for imbalanced datasets with outliers, as shown in the study. |
11 Jul 2020 | WASSKIL outperforms MAHAKIL in fault detection for industrial plants, showing superior performance in handling class imbalance using Wasserstein distance for oversampling. |
01 Dec 2019 7 Citations | The oversampling method based on SeqGAN outperforms other methods, showing the best performance in improving text classifier results for imbalanced text classification. |
| OS-CCD outperforms six classical oversampling methods in accuracy, F1-score, AUC, and ROC based on experiments on twelve benchmark datasets. |
Related Questions
How is BERT augmentation compared to other oversampling methods?5 answersBERT augmentation has been shown to outperform other oversampling methods in text classification tasks. Research indicates that BERT augmentation, particularly when combined with BERT fine-tuning, significantly improves the detection of minority classes, especially in scenarios with small dataset sizes and high class imbalances. The performance boost provided by BERT augmentation is most pronounced when dealing with limited data (e.g., 500 training documents) and high imbalance ratios (e.g., 9:1), showcasing F1 score increases of 15.6% to 40.4% compared to base models. In contrast, as dataset sizes increase or imbalance ratios decrease, the advantage of BERT augmentation diminishes. Overall, BERT augmentation combined with fine-tuning emerges as a promising solution for enhancing the performance of deep learning models in small-sized, highly imbalanced text classification tasks.
What can oversampling problem cause?4 answersOversampling problems can lead to issues such as intra-class imbalance, overlooking crucial boundary samples, and creating high similarity between old and new samples. Additionally, traditional oversampling methods like SMOTE may introduce biased artificial data by not considering the entirety of the minority class dataset. On the other hand, oversampling techniques that focus solely on the minority class, like cGAN, may neglect the majority class, impacting the classification boundary, especially in the presence of outliers. Furthermore, the imbalance in datasets can result in suboptimal classifiers for recognizing the minority class, prompting the need for innovative solutions like reinforcement learning-based oversampling methods that directly generate targeted samples based on downstream classifiers and measurements.
What upsampling techniques are commonly used in segmented medical images? Exclude AI approaches?5 answersVarious upsampling techniques are commonly employed in segmented medical images. Nearest neighbor interpolation is highlighted as a practical method for upsampling in convolutional neural networks, achieving high pixel accuracy and fast training times. Additionally, an adaptive upsampling operator utilizing content-based feature extraction is proposed in a functional discretization Bayesian neural network, enhancing segmentation network performance. Furthermore, a novel multi-path upsampling convolution network, MU-Net, is introduced to retain high-level information in medical image segmentation, improving segmentation performance while significantly reducing computational complexity. These techniques showcase the importance of efficient and accurate upsampling methods in enhancing the quality of segmented medical images.
What are the advantages and disadvantages of different upsampling techniques in segmented medical images?4 answersDifferent upsampling techniques in segmented medical images offer various advantages and disadvantages. Upsampling methods like Bayesian neural networks (BNNs) with functional discretization using Gaussian processes (GPs) provide a stochastic viewpoint, allowing uncertainty depiction. On the other hand, the U-Net-based approaches, while widely used, may lose high-level information due to consecutive operations, impacting segmentation accuracy. Additionally, a dual-encoder segmentation network incorporating HarDNet68 and Transformer branch enhances local and global feature extraction, improving segmentation effectiveness and accuracy. These techniques aim to address challenges in medical image segmentation, such as noise reduction, accurate diagnosis, and improved treatment processes, showcasing the continuous evolution and innovation in the field of medical image analysis.
What is an effective sample size for oversampling?4 answersThe effective sample size for oversampling is a measure of efficiency in the technique. It is used to determine the appropriate size of the oversampled dataset. The determination of the effective sample size is crucial in achieving a balance between the classes and avoiding overfitting. Previous studies have focused on determining the oversampling size based on the size of the minority class, but this approach may not consider the difficulty of classification in the dataset. A proposed method takes into account the absolute imbalance and the classification complexity to determine the oversampling size. Another approach involves using the kernel density estimation technique to adaptively assign the number of synthetic samples to each cluster in the minority class, ensuring diversity in the generated samples. Different measures, such as the Euclidean distance and perplexity, can also be used to calculate the effective sample size.
How does SMOTE oversampling affect the performance of machine learning models?4 answersSMOTE oversampling affects the performance of machine learning models by balancing imbalanced datasets, reducing bias, and enhancing accuracy. SMOTE generates synthetic data patterns by performing linear interpolation between minority class samples and their nearest neighbors. However, the generated patterns may not conform to the original minority class distribution. The performance of SMOTE oversampling varies depending on the model and the data. In some cases, oversampling may lead to a decrease in performance for the majority class. However, for real data, the best performance across all models is achieved when oversampling is used. The F1-score is consistently increased with oversampling. The combination of SVM and SMOTE has been found to be better than ADASYN in terms of performance metrics such as recall, precision, and F1 score.