Four widely used in vitro assays for genetic toxicity were evaluated for their ability to predict the carcinogenicity of selected chemicals in rodents. These assays were mutagenesis in Salmonella and mouse lymphoma cells and chromosome aberrations and sister chromatid exchanges in Chinese hamster ovary cells. Seventy-three chemicals recently tested in 2-year carcinogenicity studies conducted by the National Cancer Institute and the National Toxicology Program were used in this evaluation. Test results from the four in vitro assays did not show significant differences in individual concordance with the rodent carcinogenicity results; the concordance of each assay was approximately 60 percent. Within the limits of this study there was no evidence of complementarity among the four assays, and no battery of tests constructed from these assays improved substantially on the overall performance of the Salmonella assay. The in vitro assays which represented a range of three cell types and four end points did show substantial agreement among themselves, indicating that chemicals positive in one in vitro assay tended to be positive in the other in vitro assays.

https://science.sciencemag.org/content/sci/236/4804/933.full.pdf

Prediction of chemical carcinogenicity in rodents from in vitro genetic toxicity assays.

D. B. Owen: Handbook of Statistical Tables. London: Pergamon Press; Reading, Massachusetts: Addison‐Wesley, 1962. Pp. xii+580. 70s.

Handbook of Statistical Tables.

Results from the testing of 108 coded chemicals in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells for the induction of chromosome aberrations and sister chromatid exchanges (SCEs) are presented. All chemicals were tested with and without exogenous metabolic activation, using protocols designed to allow testing up to toxic doses. Cell harvest times could also be extended if chemical-induced cell cycle delay was seen. Chromosome aberrations were induced by 43 of the chemicals, and 66 induced SCEs; 37 of the chemicals were positive for both endpoints.

Chromosome aberrations and sister chromatid exchanges in chinese hamster ovary cells: Evaluations of 108 chemicals

Trehalose: a review of properties, history of use and human tolerance, and results of multiple safety studies

Mammalian in vivo cytogenetic assays. Analysis of chromosome aberrations in bone marrow cells.

A major problem of cytogenetics testing in mammalian cells is lack of agreement of results among laboratories. Our objective was to develop a sensitive in vitro test protocol that was applicable to large-scale chemical screening and yielded comparable results in two laboratories. We used sister chromatid exchange (SCE) and chromosome aberration (CAb) tests in Chinese hamster ovary (CHO) cells. The initial protocol used standard cell densities, medium, batch of rat liver S9 for metabolic activation; positive, negative, and solvent controls; staining and scoring techniques; and fixation times. Treatment without S9 was for 8-12 hr (CAb) or 26 hr (SCE), and with S9 for 2 hr in serum-free medium. Bromodeoxyuridine (BrdUrd) (10 microM) was added to SCE cultures only, 2 hr after addition of the test chemical. Doses were based on the 50% toxicity level in a preliminary test of cell survival 24 hr after treatment. One hundred cells (CAb) or 50 cells (SCE) were scored from each control and from five dose levels. Five clastogens were tested in the first two-laboratory comparison: mitomycin-C, triethylenemelamine, N-methyl-N'-nitro-N-nitrosoguanidine, cyclophosphamide, and benzo(alpha)pyrene. There was quite good agreement between laboratories. Seventeen compounds were then tested "blind" in the two laboratories. As testing proceeded, some discrepancies occurred between the laboratories, and the protocol was modified in attempts to improve the resolution of marginal responses and make dose selection more consistent. The preliminary test for cell survival was omitted. A 10(5) dose range in a half-log series was tested, and cells were scored at the highest dose at which sufficient mitotic cells were obtained, and at the next two lower doses. By delaying fixation times, SCE and CAb were scored at doses that inhibited cell cycle progression. This protocol gave comparable results in the two laboratories in many cases and by testing up to a maximum dose, limited by solubility and/or toxicity, should detect a high proportion of clastogens and SCE inducers.

Development of a standard protocol for in vitro cytogenetic testing with Chinese hamster ovary cells: Comparison of results for 22 compounds in two laboratories

It is a widely held view that objective statistical criteria are needed for the evaluation of genetic toxicity assays. This paper presents statistical methods for the analysis of data from in vitro sister chromatid exchange (SCE) and chromosome aberration tests that use Chinese hamster ovary cells. For SCEs, an extensive study of solvent control results demonstrated that there is a substantial interday component of variability in the data, and that a Poisson sampling model is applicable to data generated via the protocol of Galloway et al [1985]. Consequently, a trend test for evidence of a dose response is proposed for such SCE data. As an illustration of this statistical method, analysis of data previously considered to be negative [Gulati et al, 1985] indicates that di(2-ethyl-hexyl) phthalate induces a weak, but reproducible, SCE dose response in CHO cells. Monte Carlo methods are used to show that the trend test is more sensitive than four other statistical procedures considered for the analysis of Poisson-distributed SCEs. A similar trend test for dose response in proportions is proposed for chromosome aberration data, where the percent of cells with chromosome aberrations is the response of interest. Sensitivity (or power) studies indicate that three doses and a control with 50 cells/dose point is a reasonable design for an in vitro SCE study that uses the Galloway et al protocol. For in vitro chromosome aberrations, however, three doses and a control with 100 cells/dose point appears to produce too insensitive an assay; an increase to 200 cells/dose point in the Galloway et al protocol seems worthy of serious consideration.

B. H. Margolin

Papers

Development of a standard protocol for in vitro cytogenetic testing with Chinese hamster ovary cells: Comparison of results for 22 compounds in two laboratories

Statistical analyses for in vitro cytogenetic assays using Chinese hamster ovary cells