PURPOSE: The aim of this study was to design and evaluate in the laboratory a new intraocular lens (IOL) intended to provide superior ocular optical quality by reducing spherical aberration. METHODS: Corneal topography measurements were performed on 71 cataract patients using an Orbscan I. The measured corneal surface shapes were used to determine the wavefront aberration of each cornea. A model cornea was then designed to reproduce the measured average spherical aberration. This model cornea was used to design IOLs having a fixed amount of negative spherical aberration that partially compensates for the average positive spherical aberration of the cornea. Theoretical and physical eye models were used to assess the expected improvement in optical quality of an eye implanted with this lens. RESULTS: Measurements of optical quality provided evidence that if this modified prolate IOL was centered within 0.4 mm and tilted less than 7 degrees, it would exceed the optical performance of a conventional spherical IOL. This improvement occurred without an apparent loss in depth of focus. CONCLUSION: A new IOL with a prolate anterior surface, designed to partially compensate for the average spherical aberration of the cornea, is intended to improve the ocular optical quality of pseudophakic patients. [J Refract Surg 2002;18: 683-691] T

A new intraocular lens design to reduce spherical aberration of pseudophakic eyes.

We studied the age dependence of the relative contributions of the aberrations of the cornea and the internal ocular surfaces to the total aberrations of the eye. We measured the wave-front aberration of the eye with a Hartmann-Shack sensor and the aberrations of the anterior corneal surface from the elevation data provided by a corneal topography system. The aberrations of the internal surfaces were obtained by direct subtraction of the ocular and corneal wave-front data. Measurements were obtained for normal healthy subjects with ages ranging from 20 to 70 years. The magnitude of the RMS wave-front aberration (excluding defocus and astigmatism) of the eye increases more than threefold within the age range considered. However, the aberrations of the anterior corneal surface increase only slightly with age. In most of the younger subjects, total ocular aberrations are lower than corneal aberrations, while in the older subjects the reverse condition occurs. Astigmatism, coma, and spherical aberration of the cornea are larger than in the complete eye in younger subjects, whereas the contrary is true for the older subjects. The internal ocular surfaces compensate, at least in part, for the aberrations associated with the cornea in most younger subjects, but this compensation is not present in the older subjects. These results suggest that the degradation of the ocular optics with age can be explained largely by the loss of the balance between the aberrations of the corneal and the internal surfaces.

Contribution of the cornea and internal surfaces to the change of ocular aberrations with age

We have applied research on the visual psychophysics of reading to low vision assessment. Research on different aspects of the reading process found that reading rate rather than reading comprehension is more sensitive to variations in a subject’s visual functioning or the stimulus properties of print. The research identified four different visual factors that significantly affect reading rate: (1) acuity reserve [print size relative to acuity threshold], (2) contrast reserve [print contrast relative to contrast threshold], (3) field of view [number of letters visible], and (4) in cases of maculopathy, central scotoma size. Our research indicates that fluent reading rates can be attained with a restricted field of view, as little as four characters. However, attainment of fluent reading levels requires that print size and contrast should be several times threshold and the diameter of a central scotoma should be less than 22°. Although important clinical studies are lacking, we derived specific visual requirements for different reading rates from published experimental research to provide a starting point and to illustrate how visual requirements could be derived, even with poor correlations. Research has made significant progress toward the development of a comprehensive low vision assessment that will allow the practitioner to identify visual impediments to reading, other than reduced visual acuity. Having more fully characterized a visual impairment, the practitioner may tailor devices or interventions to the individual’s needs and capabilities.

Visual requirements for reading

PURPOSE To investigate the relations between age and the optical aberrations of the whole eye The eye’s optical quality, as measured by the modulation transfer function (MTF), degrades with age, but the MTF does not provide a means to assess the contributions of individual aberrations, such as coma, spherical aberration, and other higher order aberrations to changes in optical quality The method used in this study provides measures of individual aberrations and overall optical quality METHODS Wave aberrations in 38 subjects were measured psychophysically using a spatially resolved refractometer Data were fit with Zernike polynomials up to the seventh order to provide estimates of 35 individual aberration terms MTFs and root mean square (RMS) wavefront errors were calculated Subjects ranged in age from 229 to 645 years, with spherical equivalent corrections ranging from 105 to 260 D RESULTS Overall RMS wavefront error (excluding tilts, astigmatism, and defocus) was significantly positively correlated with age (r 5 033, P 5 0042) RMS error for the highest order aberrations measured (fifth through seventh order) showed a strong positive correlation with age (r 5 057, P 5 00002) Image quality, as quantified by the MTF, also degraded with age CONCLUSIONS Wave aberrations of the eye increase with age This increase is consistent with the loss of contrast sensitivity with age observed by other investigators (Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2001;42:1390 ‐1395)

http://www.vision.csic.es/Publications/Articles/Age-related%20changes%20in%20monochromatic%20wave%20aberrations%20of%20the%20human%20eye.pdf

Age-related changes in monochromatic wave aberrations of the human eye.

Change in shape of the aging human crystalline lens with accommodation

We measured the contrast sensitivity (CS) of a group of older subjects through natural pupils and compared the results with those from a group of younger subjects. We also measured each subject’s monochromatic ocular wave-front aberrations using a crossed-cylinder aberroscope and calculated their modulation transfer functions (MTF’s) and root-mean-squared (RMS) wave-front aberrations for fixed pupil diameters of 4 mm and 6 mm and for a natural pupil diameter. The CS at a natural pupil diameter and the MTF computed for a fixed pupil diameter were found to be significantly poorer for the older group than for the younger group. However, the older group showed very similar MTF’s and significantly smaller RMS wave-front aberrations compared with the younger group at their natural pupil diameters, owing to the effects of age-related miosis. These results suggest that although monochromatic ocular wave-front aberrations for a given pupil size increase with age, the reduction in CS with age is not due to this increase.

Effect of aging on the monochromatic aberrations of the human eye.

The spherical aberration of the crystalline lens of the human eye.

Background. Autorefractors are increasingly used in myopia research because they are convenient tools to investigate aspects of the accommodation response. The degree to which the autorefractor measures are affected by ocular aberrations has been highlighted by studies that have shown changes in aberration levels through different parts of the pupil and with accommodation. We have compared accommodative accuracy as measured with a Shin-Nippon SRW 5000 autorefractor with wavefront error as measured with a Hartmann-Shack wavefront sensor to investigate how factors such as accommodation demand, ocular aberrations, and pupil size can influence autorefractor measures. Methods. Accommodation stimulus-response curves were determined (using negative lenses) for 30 young healthy subjects (20 myopic [−0.75 to −6.00 D] and 10 emmetropic). Accommodation levels ranged from 0 to 4 D in 1 D steps. Wavefront aberrations were also determined for the same accommodation levels using a Hartmann-Shack wavefront sensor for both the subjects’ natural pupil sizes and for a 2.9-mm pupil. Results. For all subjects, there was a consistent increase in negative spherical aberration with increases in accommodative stimulus. However, there was no consistent change in paraxial spherocylindrical refractive correction with accommodation stimulus. For the emmetropic subjects, accommodation error as measured with the autorefractor was statistically similar to the total spherocylindrical correction for the eye as estimated by the Hartmann-Shack wavefront sensor, but only for a 2.9-mm pupil (the pupil size utilized by the autorefractor). For the myopic subjects, accommodation error as measured with the autorefractor was statistically similar to the higher-order aberrations, but only when measured for a natural pupil size. Conclusions. The relationship between the accommodation accuracy as measured with the autorefractor and the total wavefront aberration as measured with a Hartmann-Shack wavefront sensor is largely influenced by the higher-order (fourth and above) aberration levels. For the emmetropic subjects, the errors measured by the two methods agree when adjusted to measure at similar pupil sizes. For the myopic subjects with similar pupil sizes, however, the Hartmann-Shack wavefront sensor underestimates the accommodation error at higher accommodation levels (2 to 4 D) compared with the autorefractor.

Wavefront aberration and its relationship to the accommodative stimulus-response function in myopic subjects.

PURPOSE: Aspheric intraocular lenses (IOLs) are designed to correct spherical aberration in pseudophakic eyes. We predict the benefit from correcting spherical aberration based on simulations and aberrometry of pseudophakic eyes implanted with spherical IOLs. METHODS: Ray tracing was performed through a model eye with an equi-biconvex spherical IOL and with a spherical aberration-correcting aspheric IOL. The IOLs were increasingly tilted and/or displaced, and the resulting transverse aberrations of 169 rays were transformed into Zemike coefficients for different pupil sizes. The benefit from correcting spherical aberration at individual mesopic pupils was investigated by canceling C 0 4 in the sets of Zernike coefficients for 41 eyes implanted with a spherical IOL. RESULTS: Both the model eye and the real eye data predict that age-related miosis reduces spherical aberration in the eye implanted with a spherical IOL to approximately 1/3 of the spherical aberration at a 6-mm pupil. A reduction of similar magneitude occurs when spherical aberration-induced non-paraxial defocus is corrected by a spectacle lens. For natural mesopic pupils, canceling the Zernike C 0 4 coefficient improved the objective image quality at a rate similar to changing defocus by 0.05 diopters. Average decentration and tilt levels diminish the lead of aspheric IOLs over spherical IOLs, depending on the direction of decentration. CONCLUSIONS: the benefit from correcting spherical aberration in a pseudophakic eye is limited for some or all of the following reasons: wearing glasses, age-related miosis, tilt and decentration of IOL, small contribution of spherical aberration to all aberrations, and intersubject variability.

Limitations of correcting spherical aberration with aspheric intraocular lenses.

Following aberroscopy, aspheric front surface soft contact lenses (SCLs) were custom-made to correct spherical refractive error and ocular spherical aberration (SA) of 18 myopic and five hypermetropic subjects (age, 20.5 +/- 5 yr). On-eye residual aberrations, logMAR visual acuity, and contrast sensitivity were compared with the best-correcting spectacle lens, an equally powered standard SCL, and an SCL designed to be aberration free in air. Custom-made and spherical SCLs reduced SA (p < 0.001; p < 0.05) but did not change total root-mean-square (rms) wave-front aberration (WFA). Aberration-free SCLs increased SA (p < 0.05), coma (p < 0.05), and total rms WFA. Visual acuity remained unchanged with any of the SCL types compared with the spectacle lens correction. Contrast sensitivity at 6 cycles/degree improved with the custom-made SCLs (p < 0.05). Increased coma with aspheric lens designs and uncorrected astigmatism limit the small possible visual benefit from correcting ocular SA with SCLs.

Michael J. Cox

Papers

Effect of aging on the monochromatic aberrations of the human eye.

The spherical aberration of the crystalline lens of the human eye.

Wavefront aberration and its relationship to the accommodative stimulus-response function in myopic subjects.

Limitations of correcting spherical aberration with aspheric intraocular lenses.

Correcting ocular spherical aberration with soft contact lenses.