scispace - formally typeset
Search or ask a question

Showing papers in "arXiv: Superconductivity in 1997"


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, angle resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) was used to study the Fermi surface in underdoped high temperature superconductors and showed that different k points become gapped at different temperatures.
Abstract: The Fermi surface is a central concept in the theory of metals. Even though the optimally doped high temperature superconductors exhibit an anomalous normal state, angle resolved photoemission spectroscopy (ARPES) has revealed a large Fermi surface despite the absence of well-defined quasiparticles and the necessity of working at finite temperatures. However, the even more unusual behavior in the underdoped high temperature superconductors, which show a pseudogap above Tc, requires us to carefully re-examine this concept. Here, we present the first results on how the Fermi surface is destroyed as a function of temperature in underdoped Bi2212 using ARPES. We find the remarkable effect that different k points become gapped at different temperatures. This leads to a break up of the Fermi surface at a temperature T* into disconnected Fermi arcs which shrink with decreasing T, eventually collapsing to the point nodes of the dx2-y2 superconducting ground state below Tc. This novel behavior, where the Fermi surface does not form a continuous contour in momentum space, is unprecedented in that it occurs in the absence of long range order. Moreover, although the d-wave superconducting gap below Tc smoothly evolves into the pseudogap above Tc, the gaps at different k points are not related to one another above Tc the same way as they are below, implying an intimate, but non-trivial relation, between the two.

621 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, the authors introduce a phenomenological form for the self-energy which allows them to extract important information from angle resolved photoemission data on the high Tc superconductor Bi2212.
Abstract: We introduce a simple phenomenological form for the self-energy which allows us to extract important information from angle resolved photoemission data on the high Tc superconductor Bi2212. First, we find a rapid suppression of the single particle scattering rate below Tc for all doping levels. Second, we find that in the overdoped materials the gap Delta at all k-points on the Fermi surface has significant temperature dependence and vanishes near Tc. In contrast, in the underdoped samples such behavior is found only at k-points close to the diagonal. Near (pi,0), Delta is essentially T-independent in the underdoped samples. The filling-in of the pseudogap with increasing T is described by a broadening proportional to T-Tc, which is naturally explained by pairing correlations above Tc.

190 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, a picture of superconductivity in cuprate systems in evolution from Bose-Einstein to BCS condensation was described, combining the universal correlations between superconducting carrier density and effective mass and the pseudo-gap behavior in underdoped region.
Abstract: Combining (1) the universal correlations between $T_{c}$ and $n_{s}/m^{*}$ (superconducting carrier density / effective mass) and (2) the pseudo-gap behavior in the underdoped region, we obtain a picture to describe superconductivity in cuprate systems in evolution from Bose-Einstein to BCS condensation. Overdoped and Zn-substituted cuprate systems show signatures of reduced superfluid density in a microscopic phase separation. Scaling of $T_{c}$ to the superfluid volume density $n_{s}$ in all these cases indicate importance of Bose condensation.

101 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, the authors consider the problem of the vortex contribution to thermal properties of dirty d-wave superconductors and show that the extended quasiparticle states continue to dominate the dirty limit, but lead to a H \log H behavior at the lowest fields.
Abstract: We consider the problem of the vortex contribution to thermal properties of dirty d-wave superconductors. In the clean limit, the main contribution to the density of states in a d-wave superconductor arises from extended quasiparticle states which may be treated semiclassically, giving rise to a specific heat contribution \delta C(H)\sim H^{1/2}. We show that the extended states continue to dominate the dirty limit, but lead to a H \log H behavior at the lowest fields, H_{c1}\ltsim H\ll H_{c2}. This crossover may explain recent discrepancies in specific heat measurements at low temperatures and fields in the cuprate superconductors. We discuss the range of validity of recent predictions of scaling with H^{1/2}/T in real samples.

71 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, an overview of phase-coherent hybrid nanostructures is presented, with particular emphasis on dc electrical conduction, including zero-bias anomalies, reentrant and long range proximity effects, Andreev interferometers and superconductivity-induced conductance suppression.
Abstract: This article is an overview of recent experimental and theoretical work on transport in phase-coherent hybrid nanostructures, with particular emphasis on dc electrical conduction. A summary of multiple scattering theory and the quasi-classical methods is presented and comparisons between the two are made. Several paradigms of phase-coherent transport are discussed, including zero-bias anomalies, reentrant and long range proximity effects, Andreev interferometers and superconductivity-induced conductance suppression.

66 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, the superconductivity of layered high-T_c materials with different internal topology was investigated and the integer-valued momentum-space topological invariant N was determined.
Abstract: Superconducting states with different internal topology are discussed for the layered high-T_c materials. If the time inversion symmetry is broken, the superconductivity is determined not only by the symmetry of the superconducting state, but also by the topology of the ground state. The latter is determined the integer-valued momentum-space topological invariant N. The current carrying boundary between domains with different N (N_2 and N_1) is considered. The current is produced by fermion zero modes, which number per one layer is 2(N_2-N_1).

66 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, tunneling conductance spectra of normal metal/insulator/triplet superconductor junctions are investigated theoretically and the existence of a residual density of states, peculiar to nonunitary states, is shown to have a significant influence on the properties of the tunneling spectra.
Abstract: Tunneling conductance spectra of normal metal/insulator/triplet superconductor junctions are investigated theoretically. As triplet paring states we select several types of symmetries that are promising candidates for the superconducting states in UPt$_{3}$ and in Sr$_{2}$RuO$_{4}$. The calculated conductance spectra are sensitive to the orientation of the junction which reflects the anisotropy of the pairing states. They show either zero-bias conductance peaks or gap-like structures depending on the orientation of the junctions. The existence of a residual density of states, peculiar to nonunitary states, is shown to have a significant influence on the properties of the conductance spectra. Present results serve as a guidefor the experimental determination of the symmetry of the pair potentials in UPt$_{3}$ and Sr$_{2}$RuO$_{4}$.

59 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors measured the self-induced magnetic field of the transport current in BSCCO and showed that most of the vortex liquid phase is affected by surface barriers resulting in a thermally activated apparent resistivity.
Abstract: A new measurement technique for investigation of vortex dynamics is introduced. The distribution of the transport current across a crystal is derived by a sensitive measurement of the self-induced magnetic field of the transport current. We are able to clearly mark where the flow of the transport current is characterized by bulk pinning, surface barrier, or a uniform current distribution. One of the novel results is that in BSCCO crystals most of the vortex liquid phase is affected by surface barriers resulting in a thermally activated apparent resistivity. As a result the standard transport measurements in BSCCO do not probe the dynamics of vortices in the bulk, but rather measure surface barrier properties.

58 citations


Posted Content
TL;DR: In this paper, a phase diagram for the pseudogap onset temperature, associated with the breakdown of the Fermi liquid state, due to strong pairing correlations, and superconducting instability, as a function of variable pairing strength, is derived.
Abstract: We derive a phase diagram for the pseudogap onset temperature $T^*$ (associated with the breakdown of the Fermi liquid state, due to strong pairing correlations) and the superconducting instability, $T_c$, as a function of variable pairing strength. Our diagrammatic approach to the BCS - Bose-Einstein cross-over problem self consistently treats the coupling between the single particle and pair propagators, and leads to a continuous evolution of these propagators into the standard $T T_c$.

39 citations


Posted Content
TL;DR: In this article, a toroidal disk was prepared using conventional ceramic technology in combination with melt-texture growth, and two solenoids were placed around the disk in order to initiate the current inside it and to rotate the disk about its central axis.
Abstract: A high-temperature YBa_2Cu_3O_{7-x} bulk ceramic superconductor with composite structure has revealed weak shielding properties against gravitational force while in a levitating state at temperatures below 70 K. A toroidal disk was prepared using conventional ceramic technology in combination with melt-texture growth. Two solenoids were placed around the disk in order to initiate the current inside it and to rotate the disk about its central axis. Samples placed over the rotating disk initially demonstrated a weight loss of 0.3-0.5%. When the rotation speed was slowly reduced by changing the current in the solenoids, the shielding effect became considerably higher and reached 1.9-2.1% at maximum.

39 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the internal field distribution in the vortex state of YBa2Cu3O6.60 is shown to be a sensitive measure of both the magnetic penetration depth and the vortex-core radius.
Abstract: The internal field distribution in the vortex state of YBa2Cu3O6.60 is shown to be a sensitive measure of both the magnetic penetration depth and the vortex-core radius. The temperature dependence of the vortex core radius is found to be weaker than in the conventional superconductor NbSe2 and much weaker than theoretical predictions for an isolated vortex. The effective vortex-core radius decreases sharply with increasing H, whereas the penetration depth is found to be much stronger than in NbSe2.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, the equilibrium structure, energy bands, phonon dispersions, and s-and d-channel electron-phonon interactions (EPIs) were calculated for the infinite-layer superconductor CaCuO2 doped with 0.24 holes per CuO2.
Abstract: The equilibrium structure, energy bands, phonon dispersions, and s- and d-channel electron-phonon interactions (EPIs) are calculated for the infinite-layer superconductor CaCuO2 doped with 0.24 holes per CuO2. The LDA and the linear-response full-potential LMTO method were used. In the equilibrium structure, oxygen is found to buckle slightly out of the plane and, as a result, the characters of the energy bands near EF are found to be similar to those of other optimally doped HTSCs. For the EPI we find lambda(s)=0.4, in accord with previous LDA calculations for YBa2Cu3O7. This supports the common belief that the EPI mechanism alone is insufficient to explain HTSC. Lambda(x^2-y^2) is found to be positive and nearly as large as lambda(s). This is surprising and indicates that the EPI could enhance some other d-wave pairing mechanism. Like in YBa2Cu3O7, the buckling modes contribute significantly to the EPI, although these contributions are proportional to the static buckling and would vanish for flat planes. These numerical results can be understood from a generic tight-binding model originally derived from the LDA bands of YBa2Cu3O7. In the future, the role of anharmonicity of the buckling-modes and the influence of the spin-fluctuations should be investigated.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors studied the possible occurrence of an equilibrium thermodynamic phase with a spontaneously broken time-reversal symmetry in a model ceramic superconductor with anisotropic pairing symmetry.
Abstract: Possible occurrence of an equilibrium thermodynamic phase with a spontaneously broken time-reversal symmetry is studied in a model ceramic superconductor with anisotropic pairing symmetry. It is shown by Monte Carlo simulations that such a ``chiral-glass'' phase is truly stable even under the influence of screening. Existence of frustration in zero external field, arising from the d-wave pairing symmetry of high-T_c superconductors, is essential to realize this phase. Via a finite-size scaling analysis, critical exponents associated with the chiral-glass transition are estimated to be u _CG=1.3\pm 0.2 and \eta _CG=-0.2\pm 0.2. These values turn out to be close to those of the Ising spin glass. Phase diagram of the model is constructed and the implications to experiments are discussed.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the ARPES results on the superconducting and pseudo gaps in Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+x were reviewed, and it was shown that optimally and overdoped samples exhibit a d-wave gap, which closes at the same temperature, Tc, for all k points.
Abstract: In this paper, we review some of our ARPES results on the superconducting and pseudo gaps in Bi2Sr2CaCu2O8+x. We find that optimally and overdoped samples exhibit a d-wave gap, which closes at the same temperature, Tc, for all k points. In underdoped samples, a leading edge gap is found up to a temperature T* > Tc. We find that T* scales with the maximum low temperature gap, increasing as the doping is reduced. The momentum dependence of the pseudogap is similar to that of the superconducting gap; however, the pseudogap closes at different temperatures for different k points.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, it was shown that the inclusion of effects beyond the polaron limit in the electron-phonon interaction naturally leads to an isotope effect for the effective mass of the charge carriers.
Abstract: We show that the inclusion of effects beyond Migdal's limit in the electron-phonon interaction naturally leads to an isotope effect for the effective mass $m^{*}$ of the charge carriers even much before reaching the polaron limit. This is the situation already considered in our approach to nonadiabatic superconductivity. Such a result provides a scenario different from the polaronic one for the interpretation of the recently observed isotope effect on $m^{*}$ in YBa$_{2}$Cu$_{3}$O$_{6+x}$ and La$_{2-x}$Sr$_{x}$CuO$_{4}$.

Posted Content
TL;DR: In this paper, effective dynamical theories for metals and BCS superconductors were derived based on the effective action formalism for both the metallic regime and the superconducting regime.
Abstract: We derive effective dynamical theories for metals and BCS superconductors, based on the effective action formalism. Both the metallic regime $T\gtrsim T_{C}$ and the superconducting regime $T\ll T_{C}$ are studied in the clean and dirty limit. Furthermore, we consider the effect of particle-hole asymmetry in the band structure. Using gauge invariance, the electrodynamics of the problem is formulated in a transparent way. The effective actions are useful starting points for treating dynamical problems involving BCS superconductors.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, it was shown that Chern-Simons term is induced in 2+1 and 3+1 dimensional rotating superfluid and plays important roles in its dynamics, which is equivalent to Hall conductance.
Abstract: We show in this paper that Abelian Chern-Simons term is induced in 2+1 and 3+1 dimensional rotating superfluid $^{3}$He-A and plays important roles in its dynamics. Because U(1) symmetry is spontaneously broken in $^{3}$He-A, Goldstone mode appears and contributes to induced Chern-Simons term. We found that the coefficient of Chern-Simons term, which is equivalent to Hall conductance, depends on an infra-red cut off of the Goldstone mode, and that the orbital angular momentum of $^{3}$He-A in a cylinder geometry is derived from Chern-Simons term.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the presence of a quantum critical point due to formation of incommensurate charge density waves accounts for the basic features of the high temperature superconducting cuprates, both in the normal and in the supercondensing states.
Abstract: A scenario is presented, in which the presence of a quantum critical point due to formation of incommensurate charge density waves accounts for the basic features of the high temperature superconducting cuprates, both in the normal and in the superconducting states. Specifically, the singular interaction arising close to this charge-driven quantum critical point gives rise to the non-Fermi liquid behavior universally found at optimal doping. This interaction is also responsible for d-wave Cooper pair formation with a superconducting critical temperature strongly dependent on doping in the overdoped region and with a plateau in the optimally doped region. In the underdoped region a temperature dependent pairing potential favors local pair formation without superconducting coherence, with a peculiar temperature dependence of the pseudogap and a non-trivial relation between the pairing temperature and the gap itself. This last property is in good qualitative agreement with so far unexplained features of the experiments.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, a current-biased 0-pi-0 Josephson junction made by high-T_c superconductors was studied, and the magnetic flux carried by the vortices was calculated using the sine-Gordon equation.
Abstract: We study a current-biased 0-\pi-0 Josephson junction made by high-T_c superconductors, theoretically. When a length of the \pi junction is large enough, this junction contains a vortex-antivortex pair at both ends of the \pi junction. Magnetic flux carried by the vortices is calculated using the sine-Gordon equation. The result shows that the magnetic flux of the vortices is suppressed to zero as the distance between the vortices is reduced. By applying an external current, the orientation of the vortices is reversed, and a voltage pulse is generated. The current needed for this transition and generated pulse energy are calculated. Macroscopic quantum tunneling (MQT) in this transition is also studied. The tunneling rate has been evaluated by an effective Hamiltonian with one degree of freedom.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors present experimental evidence for a dramatic suppression of the phononic thermal conductivity of rare earth and Sr doped La_2CuO_4, which correlates with the occurrence of superconductivity.
Abstract: We present experimental evidence for a dramatic suppression of the phononic thermal conductivity of rare earth and Sr doped La_2CuO_4. Remarkably, this suppression correlates with the occurrence of superconductivity. Conventional models for the phonon heat transport fail to explain these results. In contrast, a straightforward explanation is possible in terms of static and dynamic stripe correlations of holes and spins.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, the structure of the topological excitations, charges and vortices, which are shown to be dual to each other, is investigated in the presence of external magnetic fields and offset charges.
Abstract: Various properties of mesoscopic two-dimensional Josephson junction arrays are reviewed. Particular attention is paid to structure of the topological excitations, charges and vortices, which are shown to be dual to each other. This duality persists in the presence of external magnetic fields and offset charges, which influence vortices and charges in an equivalent way. A double-layer junction array is also considered, where an even further reaching duality is discovered.

Posted Content
TL;DR: The existence of vortex condensates in the self-dual Maxwell-Chern-Simons-Higgs system on a flat torus is proved by the super-sub solution method under the assumption that the total vortex number in a given periodic domain is not too large as discussed by the authors.
Abstract: The existence of vortex condensates in the self-dual Maxwell-Chern-Simons-Higgs System on a flat torus is proved by the super-sub solution method under the assumption that the total vortex number in a given periodic domain is not too large. We also study the limiting behaviors of the solutions as the Chern-Simons coupling constant goes to some limits. In the Abelian-Higgs limit we find that our solutions strongly converges to the corresponding vortex condensates of the Abelian-Higgs system, while in the Chern-Simons limit the solutions strongly converges to the corresponding vortex condensates of Chern-Simons system.

Posted Content
TL;DR: In this paper, it is argued that the penetration depth and the correlation length at the critical point of the 3D superconductor diverge with the same critical exponents, as follows from the general scaling arguments and from independent calculations in both Ginzburg-Landau and its dual theory.
Abstract: It is argued that the penetration depth and the correlation length at the critical point of the 3D superconductor diverge with the same critical exponents, as follows from the general scaling arguments and from the independent calculations in both Ginzburg-Landau and its dual theory. The incorrect prediction of Kiometzis, Kleinert and Schakel (KKS) that this is is not so, is the result of the faulty treatment of the dual theory, in which two, instead of one, coupling constants are tuned to reach the critical point. The recent paper by the present author criticized by KKS in cond-mat/9702159 differs on this point from KKS, and consequently finds the expected relation between the divergence of the two lengths in the critical region.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, it is shown that one can obtain quantitatively accurate values for the superconducting critical temperature within a Hamiltonian framework using similarity renormalization or using flow equations for Hamiltonians.
Abstract: It is shown that one can obtain quantitatively accurate values for the superconducting critical temperature within a Hamiltonian framework. This is possible if one uses a renormalized Hamiltonian that contains an attractive electron-electron interaction and renormalized single particle energies. It can be obtained by similarity renormalization or using flow equations for Hamiltonians. We calculate the critical temperature as a function of the coupling using the standard BCS-theory. For small coupling we rederive the McMillan formula for Tc. We compare our results with Eliashberg theory and with experimental data from various materials. The theoretical results agree with the experimental data within 10%. Renormalization theory of Hamiltonians provides a promising way to investigate electron-phonon interactions in strongly correlated systems.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, the effects of a short mean free path on the properties of a well defined superfluid Fermi liquid with anisotropic pairing were studied. But the authors focused on aerogel.
Abstract: Superfluid $^3$He confined in aerogel offers a unique chance to study the effects of a short mean free path on the properties of a well defined superfluid Fermi liquid with anisotropic pairing. Transport coefficients and collective excitations, e.g. longitudinal sound, are expected to react sensitively to a short mean free path and to offer the possibility for testing recently developed models for quasiparticle scattering at aerogel strands. Sound experiments, together with a theoretical analysis based on Fermi liquid theory for systems with short mean free paths, should give valuable insights into the interaction between superfluid $^3$He and aerogel.

Posted Content
TL;DR: In this article, the authors present an analytic construction of the quasiparticle spectrum in this regime, based on the high-field expansion, and show that the spectrum is gapless and is separated from the familiar low-field regime by a quantum level-crossing transition.
Abstract: At high magnetic fields and low temperatures, numerous extreme type-II superconductors exhibit Landau quantization of electronic motion. We present an analytic construction of the quasiparticle spectrum in this regime, based on the high-field expansion. The spectrum is gapless and is separated from the familiar low-field regime by a quantum level-crossing transition. Such low energy excitations should lead to observable effects in thermodynamics and transport.

Posted Content
TL;DR: In this article, it was shown that the critical temperature of clean systems T 0 depends linearly on the E-P coupling constant λ and the isotope effect λ is small.
Abstract: Impurities with the pronounced forward scattering (FS impurities) change analytical properties of the quasiparticle Green's function substantially compared to the isotropic scattering. By assuming that the superconducting pairing is due to the forward E-P scattering (FEP pairing) it is shown that the critical temperature of clean systems T_{c0} depends linearly on the E-P coupling constant \lambda and the isotope effect \alpha is small. The FS impurities make \alpha =1/2 in the dirty limit and affect in the same way the s- and d-wave FEP pairing. The FS impurities are pair-weakening in both pairing channels. The usual isotropic impurity scattering is pair-weakening for the s-wave and pair-breaking for the d-wave FEP pairing.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this paper, the experimental current-voltage characteristics of long, discrete, one-dimensional Josephson junction arrays with open boundaries and in an external magnetic field were investigated. And the authors used a multi-mode extension of the harmonic balance analysis, and estimate the resonance frequencies, the AC voltage amplitudes, and the theoretical limit on the output power on the first two steps.
Abstract: New resonance steps are found in the experimental current-voltage characteristics of long, discrete, one-dimensional Josephson junction arrays with open boundaries and in an external magnetic field. The junctions are underdamped, connected in parallel, and DC biased. Numerical simulations based on the discrete sine-Gordon model are carried out, and show that the solutions on the steps are periodic trains of fluxons, phase-locked by a finite amplitude radiation. Power spectra of the voltages consist of a small number of harmonic peaks, which may be exploited for possible oscillator applications. The steps form a family that can be numbered by the harmonic content of the radiation, the first member corresponding to the Eck step. Discreteness of the arrays is shown to be essential for appearance of the higher order steps. We use a multi-mode extension of the harmonic balance analysis, and estimate the resonance frequencies, the AC voltage amplitudes, and the theoretical limit on the output power on the first two steps.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, it was shown that the symmetry breaking by replacing Ca partially by Y enhances the coupling by an order of magnitude, while the superconducting $T_c$ drops to about two third of its original value.
Abstract: It is argued that the origin of the buckling of the CuO$_{2}$ planes in certain cuprates as well as the strong electron-phonon coupling of the $B_{1g}$ phonon is due to the electric field across the planes induced by atoms with different valence above and below. The magnitude of the electric field is deduced from new Raman results on YBa$_{2}$Cu$_{3}$O$_{6+x}$ and Bi$_{2}$Sr$_{2}$(Ca$_{1-x}$Y$_{x}$)Cu$_{2}$O$_{8}$ with different O and Y doping, respectively. In the latter case it is shown that the symmetry breaking by replacing Ca partially by Y enhances the coupling by an order of magnitude, while the superconducting $T_c$ drops to about two third of its original value.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In this article, a composite operator method has been used to determine the dynamics in a self-consistent way by using of symmetry requirements, as the ones coming from the Pauli principle.
Abstract: The addition to the Hubbard Hamiltonian of a t' diagonal hopping term, which is considered to be material dependent for high-Tc cuprate superconductors, is generally suggested to obtain a model capable to describe the physics of high-Tc cuprate materials. In this line of thinking, the two-dimensional t-t'-U model has been studied by means of the Composite Operator Method, which allows to determine the dynamics in a fully self-consistent way by use of symmetry requirements, as the ones coming from the Pauli principle. At first, some local quantities have been calculated to be compared with quantum Monte Carlo data. Then, the structure of the energy bands, the shape of the Fermi surface and the position of the van Hove singularity have been computed as functions of the model parameters and studied by the light of the available experimental data. The results of our study show that there exists two sets of parameters that allows the model to describe the relevant features of 1-layer compounds NCCO and LSCO. On the other hand, for the 2-layer compound YBCO is not possible to find a reasonable set of parameters which could reproduce the position of the van Hove singularity as predicted by ARPES experiments. Hence, it results questionable the existence of an unique model that could properly describe the variety of cuprate superconductors, as the t-t'-U model was thought to be.