An experimental field study of anther-smut disease of Silene alba caused by Ustilago violacea: genotypic variation and disease incidence.

TLDR: Variation among female genotypes in disease levels was not correlated with either flower production or phenology, suggesting that the sexes differ in their interaction with the pathogen.

Abstract: Twenty cloned genotypes of Silene alba differed greatly (0-100%) in the percentage of flowering plants that became diseased by the anther-smut fungus Ustilago violacea following natural spore dispersal in a two-year field experiment. Male genotypes with the highest percentage of disease had high rates of flower production; this trait may increase the probability of spore deposition on flowers, a common site of infection. Because of this relationship, male genotypes with the highest percentage of disease also produced the most healthy flowers in the two-year period. Flowering early in the season was also a predictor of high disease levels for male genotypes in the first year. Variation among female genotypes in disease levels was not correlated with either flower production or phenology, suggesting that the sexes differ in their interaction with the pathogen. Plants of both sexes that remained nonreproductive the first year but flowered the second year could become diseased due to infection of vegetative tissue. Disease levels of the genotypes following natural spore dispersal were not correlated with disease levels of the genotypes following inoculation of vegetative tissue. This discrepancy points out that the methodology used to investigate genetic variation in disease resistance may affect the results obtained.