Beyond public health genomics: proposals from an international working group

TLDR: Issues were explored in January 2014 at the inaugural meeting of an international working group on ‘Beyond Public Health Genomics’, convening leading experts in genomics, public health, clinical sciences, systems medicine, law and bioethics, from many disciplines and countries.

Abstract: Advances in genomics have crucial implications for public health, offering new ways of differentiating individuals and groups within populations that go beyond the measures normally used by public health professionals, such as gender, age, socio-economic status, physiological measurements or clinical biomarkers.1 While public health has traditionally been concerned with interventions at a population level, genomic medicine seems to promote a vision for health care that encourages individualism rather than collectivism.2 This tension is apparent in weighing up its consequences. Thus, it may bring benefits in stratifying individuals according to genetic risk, enabling better targeting of preventive and therapeutic interventions. But it may also have harmful consequences undermining the imperative to tackle social and environmental determinants of disease and the collective provision of health care potentially leading to overdiagnosis/overtreatment; it may fragment the risk pooling that underpins social solidarity; and it may increase the probability of stigmatization and discrimination. Consequently, the public health community, with its commitment to equity, must take the opportunity to engage with genomic knowledge, ensuring that it advances the population’s health. These issues were explored in January 2014 at the inaugural meeting of an international working group on ‘Beyond Public Health Genomics’, convening leading experts in genomics, public health, clinical sciences, systems medicine, law and bioethics, from many disciplines and countries, at the Universita Cattolica del Sacro Cuore in Rome. Its goal, inspired by the 2005 Bellagio statement on public health genomics, defined as the ‘responsible and effective translation of genome-based discovery into population health,3 was to generate high value-based proposals to foster the evidence base for implementing genomic discoveries in public health policy and practice, and to ensure necessary action while accounting for the challenge of needing to fund these workstreams in the current environment of diminishing resources. The contribution of genomics to …