Rate control for robust video transmission over burst-error wireless channels

TLDR: Simulation results demonstrate that both the video distortion at the decoder and packet loss rate can be significantly reduced when incorporating the channel information provided by the feedback channel and the a priori model into the rate control algorithm.

Abstract: We study the problem of rate control for transmission of video over burst-error wireless channels, i.e., channels such that errors tend to occur in clusters during fading periods. In particular we consider a scenario consisting of packet based transmission with automatic repeat request (ARQ) error control and a back channel. We start by showing how the delay constraints in real time video transmission can be translated into rate constraints at the encoder, where the applicable rate constraints at a given time depend on future channel rates. With the acknowledgments received through the back channel we have an estimate of the current channel state. This information, combined with an a priori model of the channel, allows us to statistically model the future channel rates. Thus the rate constraints at the encoder can be expressed in terms of the expected channel behavior. We can then formalize a rate distortion optimization problem, namely, that of assigning quantizers to each of the video blocks stored in the encoder buffer such that the quality of the received video is maximized. This requires that the rate constraints be included in the optimization, since violating a rate constraint is equivalent to violating a delay constraint and thus results in losing a video block. We formalize two possible approaches. The first one seeks to minimize the distortion for the expected rate constraints given the channel model and current observation. The second approach seeks to allocate bits so as to minimize the expected distortion for the given model. We use both dynamic programming and Lagrangian optimization approaches to solve these problems. Our simulation results demonstrate that both the video distortion at the decoder and packet loss rate can be significantly reduced when incorporating the channel information provided by the feedback channel and the a priori model into the rate control algorithm.

Full text

 !" #$ %&'()*+,+ -/.0!"
12/354768:9<;>=?8A@/B; CEDF;/3GDIHKJECMLONP9
Q
; CELONFJR9SCEL<TIUVL<T 3W9YXZ[?,CML]\^?_1LO;CML]JO@/`LOa:9SJECM\IL]; C(DSbdcdeGL<fgCEJM3hf]9SeAc!;/Ni3j;/L]LOJM3G;/NS4EXZ[?,CML]\^?
k
;[3jlLOJR?,3jCZmD<bnXDF8[CM2/LOJE;>1(9Sej35boDFJE;/3h9@p:D?BK;[NFLOeGL<?g@:1(9Sej35boDFJE;/3h9mqirFrFsiqt4vuFwixSy
U>9i?,DF8zTV{2:9S;z?M9SJE3
=KLO|nejL]CMC,4v}!9if~i9SJRTVp+9S:DFJR9SCMDiJM3GL<?
}!9<ejDBKejCED/@:1(9Sej35boDFJE;/3h9mq<yFr<yS4RF]uFx
O<S[gg<]IOOtOg/gO>Mi<IO<S/K<So]/0OgOS[¡¢:£<g¤¦¥M]O
§©¨«ª¬«®§°¯-¬
±²´³<µ¶I·¹¸»º¼S½o¾²´½¹½o²´¶¼I¶¿µ,¸"ÀA²´¸¹µÁ´µ½o½Á´²´¼<ÂO½²´½"º¼µ¾Kµ¸oÃg²´¼<ÃĺÅ<ÅSÁƲ´ÇEº·o²´¶¼IÀAÈ<²´Ç7ÈV²Æ¼O¿g¶Á´¿µ½º·o²´¾µvÉW¿º¸oÊO²´¼<ÃËÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁhÌ
Í
¶¾KÅiº¸¹µ³·o¶K¶·oÈSµ¸·¹¸»º¼S½o¾²´½¹½o²´¶¼¾µ,³<²5º<ÎOÀA²´¸oµÁ´µ½¹½!ÁƲ´¼<ÂO½A½¹ÏOÐPµ,¸Ñj¸o¶¾*Á´²´¾²´·oµ³KÒiº¼S³<ÀA²´³<·oÈÎFº¼<³Óº¸oµ%¾¶¸¹µ!ÁƲ´ÂgµÁ´Ê·o¶K½oµµ
·oÈSµ²´¸:Åiµ,¸hÑG¶g¸o¾"º¼<Çµ³<µÃg¸»º³SµA³<Ï<µ·o¶¾nÏ<Á´·¹²ÆÅFº·oÈ'ÑWº³S²Æ¼SÃiÌÔAÈ<µ,¸oµ7ÑG¶g¸oµÕµ¸o¸¹¶¸:Ç¶g¼O·o¸o¶gÁ<¾µ,Ç»ÈFº¼<²´½o¾K½EÎ,ÀAÈ<²´Ç»ÈÇEº¼ºÇ7È<²´µ¿µÒFµ·o·¹µ¸
¿O²´³<µ¶Ö]ÏFºÁ´²´·hÊnÀA²Æ·¹È·¹È<µ(ºM¿º²´Á5ºÒSÁƵÒiº¼<³<ÀA²´³<·oÈ0º¼<³¸¹µÇ¶¿µ,¸AÑG¸¹¶¾-·¹È<µ!µ¸o¸¹¶¸o½Õ³<Ï<µ·¹¶(·¹È<µÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ ³<µÃ¸7º³iº·o²´¶¼ Î]º¸oµ¿gµ¸oÊ
²´¾ÅF¶¸¹·»º¼O·Õ²Æ¼ÓÀA²´¸oµÁ´µ½¹½(¿O²´³<µ¶·¹¸»º¼S½o¾²´½¹½o²´¶¼Ó½oÊO½o·¹µ¾½MÌ×0º¼]ÊÓ¶ÑA·oÈSµnÅ<¸o¶gÅi¶g½oµ³mÀA²´¸oµ,ÁƵ,½o½Ç¶¾K¾nÏ<¼<²´ÇEº·¹²´¶¼<½A½¹Ê]½¹·oµ¾K½(º¸¹µ
Á´²´ÂµÁ´Ê·o¶Òiµ!·hÀ¶ÉhÀغMÊ½o¶·oÈiº·Øº%¸oµ,·oÏ<¸¹¼"Ç7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ ÇEº¼KÇ¶¼O¿gµÊn²´¼OÑG¶¸¹¾"º·o²´¶¼·o¶·oÈ<µ!·¹¸»º¼S½o¾²´·¹·oµ¸+ºÒi¶gÏ<··oÈ<µ!Ç7Èiº¼S¼<µÁ½¹·»º·oµÌ
ÙAµ,Çµ¼O·¸¹µ½oµEº¸oÇ7È^Èiº½nÇ¶¼S½o²´³<µ¸¹µ³^ÀAºMÊ]½¶Ñ!²´¾Å<¸¹¶¿]²´¼<Ã·¹È<µ·o¸»º¼<½o¾K²´½o½o²´¶g¼m¸oµÁ´²5ºÒ<²´Á´²´·hÊËÒOÊY¾"ºÂO²´¼<ÃÏ<½¹µ"¶ÑÚ·¹È<µKÑGµµ³<ÒFºÇ7Â
Ç7Èiº¼S¼<µÁSÑG¶¸Û¹ÇÁ´¶½¹µ³OÉhÁƶO¶gÅ<Ü!µ¸o¸¹¶¸Ç¶¼O·o¸¹¶ÁhÎg²Æ¼SÇÁ´Ï<³<²´¼<Ã!¿º¸¹²Æ¶gÏ<½ ÑG¶¸¹¾½/¶Ñ¸oµ,·o¸»º¼<½o¾K²´½o½o²´¶g¼ÌÝh¼n·¹È<²´½:ÅiºÅiµ¸ÀµAÅ<¸o¶gÅi¶g½oµÚºÕ¸7º·oµ
Ç¶g¼]·¹¸o¶gÁPºÁÆÃg¶¸¹²Æ·¹È<¾ÒFº½oµ,³¶¼K³<ÊO¼iº¾K²´Ç+Å<¸¹¶Ãg¸»º¾K¾²Þ¼<ÃAÇ¶¾nÒS²Æ¼Sµ³nÀA²´·oÈnßÏS·o¶¾º·¹²ÆÇAÙAµ,ÅiµEº·+¸¹µEàÕÏ<µ½¹·(á5ß!ÙAà!â:º½·oÈ<µÕµ¸o¸¹¶¸
Ç¶g¼]·¹¸o¶gÁi¾KµÇ7Èiº¼<²´½¹¾ËÌFãmµÑG¶¸¹¾"ºÁƲ´äµå·oÈ<µÕÇ¶¼<½¹·o¸7º²´¼O·o½²Æ¾KÅi¶g½oµ³nÒOÊ·oÈ<µA¸¹µEºÁÞÉh·o²´¾µÇ7Èiº¸7ºÇ·¹µ¸o²´½¹·o²´Ç½A¶Ñ¿O²´³<µ¶FÌãmµA½¹È<¶ÀIÈ<¶À
ÀAÈ<µ¼Äº¼ÄºÅ<ÅS¸o¶ÅS¸o²5º·¹µn¾¶O³<µÁ ÑG¶g¸·oÈ<µKÇ7Èiº¼<¼SµÁ+²´½ºM¿º²´Á5ºÒSÁƵgÎi·¹È<µ¶¿gµ¸»ºÁ´Á:¸o¶gÒ<Ï<½o·¹¼<µ½¹½(¶Ñ·oÈ<µn½¹Ê]½¹·oµ¾©ÇEº¼mÒFµ²´¾ÅS¸o¶¿µ,³
·oÈS¸o¶ÏSÃÈ¸»º·oµ!Ç¶¼O·¹¸o¶Á/º·A·¹È<µ!½o¶ÏS¸oÇµÏS½o²´¼<Ãn·oÈSµÇ7Èiº¼<¼SµÁ½¹·»º·¹µ!²Æ¼tÑG¶¸¹¾"º·¹²´¶¼Ç¶¼O¿µ,Êµ³0ÒOÊn·¹È<µßÚÙAà>ºÇ7Â]¼S¶ÀAÁƵ,³<Ãµ¾Kµ¼O·EÌ
æKç]èé%êiëì/íî ÀA²´¸oµÁ´µ½¹½¿O²´³<µ¶FÎ+¸7º·¹µ"Ç,¶¼O·o¸¹¶ÁhÎÀA²Æ¸¹µÁ´µ½o½KÁ´²Æ¼SÂ]½MÎAºÏ<·¹¶¾"º·o²´Çn¸oµ,ÅiµEº·¸oµÖOÏ<µ½¹·ËáïßÚÙAà!âÎzÑG¶¸¹Àغ¸o³Iµ¸o¸¹¶¸
Ç¶g¸o¸oµ,Ç·o²´¶¼YáGð/ñ
Í
âÎSÇ7Èiº¼<¼SµÁ¾K¶]³SµÁhÎÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁòÑGµµ³<ÒFºÇ7ÂÎ<±²´·¹µ¸oÒ<²/ºÁ´Ã¶g¸o²´·oÈS¾ËÌ
ó ô/õ
¬*÷öùøúû¯-¬
ô
ö
õ
ü
²´¿µ¼·¹È<µÒiº¼<³<ÀA²´³<·oÈÁ´²´¾²´·»º·o²´¶¼S½EÎÇ¶g¾Å<¸¹µ½o½¹²´¶¼ÀA²´ÁÆÁÒFµ¸¹µÖOÏ<²´¸oµ³¡ÑG¶¸A¿O²´³<µ¶n·¹¸»º¼<½o¾K²Æ½¹½o²´¶¼K¶¿µ¸ÕÀA²´¸oµÁ´µ½¹½Ç7Èiº¼S¼<µÁ´½EÌ
ýÕÏ<µA·o¶%·oÈ<µAµþO·¹µ¼<½o²´¿gµÏ<½¹µA¶Ñ¿º¸¹²5ºÒ<Á´µ:Á´µ¼<Ãg·oÈnµ¼O·¹¸o¶ÅOÊÇ¶O³<²´¼<Ãº¼<³nÅS¸oµ³<²´Ç·¹²´¶¼ÎgÇ¶¾KÅ<¸oµ,½o½oµ,³¿O²´³<µ¶!²´½:¾¶g¸oµ:¿OÏ<Á´¼<µ¸7ºÒ<Á´µA·¹¶
·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´½o½¹²´¶¼!µ¸o¸¹¶¸¹½zº½/Áƶg½o½¹µ½/ÇEº¼ÅS¸o¶O³<Ï<ÇµAº¸¹·o²ÞÑWºÇ·o½/Ï<¼O·o²´Ág½oÊO¼<Ç7È(²´½ ¸oµÇ¶¿gµ¸oµ,³n¶¸·¹È<µÅ<¸oµ³S²ÆÇ,·o²´¶¼Á´¶O¶Å%²Æ½ ¸oµ½¹·»º¸o·oµ,³Ì:ñ/¸o¸¹¶¸
Å<¸¹¶·oµ,Ç·o²´¶¼Y²´½·oÈOÏ<½µ,½o½oµ,¼]·¹²5ºÁÑG¶g¸(º¸o¶gÒ<Ï<½¹·(ÀA²´¸oµ,ÁƵ,½o½¿]²´³<µ,¶0·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´½o½¹²Æ¶g¼Ìnã^ÈFº·¾ºÂµ,½Úµ,¸o¸o¶g¸(ÅS¸o¶·¹µÇ·¹²Æ¶g¼ÄÇ7ÈiºÁÆÁ´µ¼SÃ²´¼<Ã
²´¼ÿºKÀA²´¸oµ,ÁƵ,½o½µ¼O¿]²´¸¹¶¼<¾Kµ¼O·²´½·oÈSµnÒ<Ï<¸o½¹·hÊ˼Fº·oÏS¸oµn¶ÑA·oÈSµnµ¸o¸¹¶¸o½MÎ/Ï<½oÏFºÁ´Á´Ê0³<Ï<µn·¹¶"¾nÏSÁÆ·¹²´Åiº·¹ÈÑWº³S²Æ¼SÃiÌ

µ¸¹²´¶]³S½¶ÑAÃ¶O¶O³
Ç7Èiº¼S¼<µÁ:ÒFµÈiºM¿O²´¶¸ºÁ´·¹µ¸o¼iº·oµnÀA²´·oÈÓ³<µµ,ÅÓÑWº³<µ²´¼O·oµ¸¹¿ºÁ´½!³<Ï<¸o²´¼<ÃÀAÈ<²´Ç7ÈÓÃµ·¹·o²´¼<Ã0º¼OÊ0²´¼OÑG¶g¸o¾º·o²´¶g¼"ºÇ,¸o¶½¹½(À¶ÏSÁƳ¡¸oµÖOÏ<²´¸oµ
½oÏSÒ<½o·7º¼O·o²5ºÁÁ´µ¿gµÁ´½A¶Ñµ¸¹¸o¶g¸Ç¶g¸o¸oµ,Ç·o²´¶¼¶¿gµ¸oÈ<µMº³Ìåß½¹¶Á´Ï<·o²´¶g¼Òiº½oµ³¶¼KÏ<½o²´¼<ÃnðS¶¸oÀAº¸¹³"ñ/¸¹¸o¶g¸
Í
¶¸o¸¹µÇ·¹²Æ¶g¼máGð/ñ
Í
âAºÁ´¶g¼<µ
ÑG¶g¸[ÅS¸o¶·¹µÇ·¹²Æ¶g¼nÀ+¶gÏ<Á´³·oÈOÏ<½å¸oµÖOÏ<²´¸oµA·¹Èiº·/µ²´·¹È<µ¸:·¹È<µA¶¿µ¸¹È<µEº³n²Æ½/È<²´ÃgÈ·oÈ<¸¹¶Ï<ÃgÈ<¶ÏS·[·¹È<µA·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´½o½¹²´¶¼áï·oÈOÏ<½:Á´¶Àµ¸o²´¼<ÃÕ³iº·7º

·oÈS¸o¶ÏSÃÈ<Å<ÏS·:³<Ï<¸¹²Æ¼SÃÚ·¹È<µnÛoÃg¶O¶]³SÜ²´¼O·oµ¸¹¿ºÁ´½»â ¶¸/·¹Èiº·:·¹È<µAÇ7Èiº¼S¼<µÁ<ÒFµAµ7ÐµÇ·o²´¿gµÁ´Ê(Ï<¼OÏ<½7ºÒ<Á´µA³<ÏS¸o²´¼<Ã!·oÈ<µAÀ¶¸¹½o· ÑWº³<µAÅiµ,¸o²´¶O³<½EÌ
Ýh¼¶¼<µvÉWÀAºMÊnÇ¶¾K¾nÏ<¼<²ÞÇEº·¹²Æ¶g¼(½¹ÊO½o·oµ,¾½EÎ<ð/ñ
Í
²´½+·¹È<µ¶g¼<Á´Ê(ÅF¶½¹½o²´Ò<Á´µ!Ç»ÈS¶²´ÇµÕÑG¶¸Aµ,¸o¸o¶g¸AÇ¶¼O·¹¸o¶Á

µ¸¹¸o¶g¸o½ÈFºM¿µ·¹¶nÒiµ!³<µ,·oµÇ·¹µ³
º¼S³Ç¶g¸o¸oµ,Ç·oµ³ÓÒOÊn·oÈ<µ!¸¹µÇµ²´¿µ,¸EÌÝh¼·¹È<µ½oµ%ÇEº½¹µ½·¹È<µð[ñ
Í
¶¿µ¸¹È<µEº³"ÇMº¼Òiµ!¸¹µ³<Ï<Çµ,³0ÒOÊn²Æ¼O·¹µ¸oÁ´µEºM¿O²´¼<Ã·oÈ<µ!¿O²´³<µ¶³iº·7º·¹¶
½oÅS¸oµEº³n¶Ï<·/ÇÁ´Ï<½¹·oµ¸¹µ³µ¸¹¸o¶g¸o½:¶¿gµ¸/½oµ¿gµ¸»ºÁi³iº·»ºÕÅiºÇ»Âgµ·o½MÌ/ÔAÈ<µß½oÊO¼<Ç7È<¸¹¶¼<¶gÏ<½:Ô/¸»º¼<½hÑjµ¸+×¶O³<µ!á5ß:Ôסâ/ß³iºÅ<·»º·o²´¶¼

ºMÊµ,¸
á5ßÕß

â:½¹ÅiµÇ,²

FÇEº·¹²Æ¶g¼²Æ¼K·oÈ<µÕÝhÔ

AÉhÔ^¸oµ,Ç¶¾K¾µ¼<³Fº·o²´¶g¼(ÝÌ

iµ,¾Å<Á´¶ÊO½:·oÈSµÚÙAµ,µ³OÉ

O¶Á´¶¾K¶¼á

<Î

]â Ç¶O³<µ!Ç¶g¾nÒ<²´¼<µ³
ÀA²´·oÈ²´¼O·oµ¸¹ÁƵMºM¿]²´¼<Ã%·o¶n½oÅS¸oµEº³0¶Ï<·A·¹È<µ!Ò<Ï<¸¹½o·hÊµ¸o¸¹¶¸¹½EÌ

µ·¹·oµ¸!µ¸¹¸o¶¸A¸¹µ½o²´Á´²´µ¼<Çµ%ÀA²Æ·¹ÈÁƶÀµ¸¶¿µ¸¹È<µEº³"ÇMº¼0ÒFµºÇ7È<²´µ¿µ,³"ÒOÊ
²´¼O·oµ¸¹ÁƵMºM¿]²´¼<Ã·oÈSµÚ¿O²´³<µ¶n³Fº·»ºnº·+·¹È<µÇ¶g½o·A¶Ñåº%Á´¶¼<Ãgµ¸A³<µÁ5ºMÊOÌ
×0º¼OÊÒ<Ï<¸¹½o·hÉhµ¸¹¸o¶¸AÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ´½Aº¸¹µ½oÏSÇ»ÈK·oÈiº·ØºÚÑGµµ³<ÒFºÇ7ÂnÇ7Èiº¼<¼SµÁi²´½AºM¿º²´Á5ºÒ<Á´µ+º¼<³n·oÈSµ¸oµ,Çµ²´¿µ¸AÇMº¼½¹µ¼<³K²Æ¼tÑG¶¸¹¾"º·¹²´¶¼
ÒiºÇ»ÂK·o¶·oÈ<µ%·o¸»º¼<½o¾K²´·o·oµ,¸EÌ ÔAÈ<²´½ÑGµµ³<ÒFºÇ7ÂÇ»ÈFº¼<¼<µ,ÁÇEº¼"·¹È<µ¼ÒFµÚÏS½oµ³0·¹¶n²´¾Å<¸¹¶¿µA·oÈSµÚµ,¸o¸o¶g¸¸¹µ½o²´Á´²´µ¼<ÇµÒOÊOÎÑj¶¸Aµþ<º¾KÅ<Á´µÎ
²´¼OÑG¶g¸o¾²´¼<Ã·oÈSµn·o¸»º¼<½o¾K²´·o·oµ,¸¶ÑA·oÈSµ(ÇÏS¸o¸oµ,¼]·½o·7º·¹µn¶Ñ+·¹È<µnÇ7Èiº¼<¼SµÁ

oÌÝh¼Ó·hÀ¶ÉhÀغMÊÇ¶g¾¾nÏ<¼<²´ÇEº·o²´¶¼½¹ÊO½o·oµ,¾½ÀA²´·oÈÓº
ÑGµµ,³<ÒiºÇ7ÂmÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁhÎ ¾µ·¹È<¶O³<½!ÑG¶g¸µ¸o¸¹¶¸³Sµ·oµÇ,·o²´¶¼^º¼S³Ë¸¹µ·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´½o½¹²Æ¶g¼Î ½oÏ<Ç7Èº½ßÏS·o¶¾º·¹²ÆÇnÙAµ,ÅiµEº·¸oµMàÏSµ½o·0áïßÚÙAà!âÎ
ÇEº¼"ÒFµÏ<½¹µ³²´¼<½o·¹µEº³¶Ñ7ÎO¶¸A²´¼Ç¶g¾nÒ<²´¼iº·¹²´¶¼nÀA²´·oÈÎ<ð/ñ
Í
ÌOÝh¼·¹È<µßÚÙAàVµ,¸o¸o¶g¸Ç¶g¼O·o¸o¶gÁ½¹Ç»ÈSµ¾µÎOµ,²Æ·¹È<µ¸!ºÇ7ÂO¼<¶ÀAÁ´µ³<Ãµ,¾µ¼O·
á5ß
Í

â¶g¸(¼<µ,Ã]º·¹²´¿µ"ºÇ7Â]¼S¶ÀAÁƵ,³<Ãµ¾Kµ¼O·"á
"!
ß

ânº¸oµ½oµ,¼]·nÒFºÇ7Âm·o¶Ó·oÈ<µ·¹¸»º¼S½o¾²´·¹·oµ¸·o¶m²´¼<³<²´ÇEº·oµKÀAÈ<µ·oÈSµ¸·¹È<µÅiºÇ7Âµ,·
ÀAº½!Ç¶¸¹¸oµÇ,·oÁ´Êm¸oµÇ,µ²´¿µ³Ì
#
ÅF¶¼Ó¸oµ,Çµ²´¿O²Æ¼SÃ˺
#!
ß

·oÈSµn·o¸»º¼<½o¾K²´·o·oµ,¸dº·o·¹µ¾Å<·¹½!·o¶0¸¹µ·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´·!·oÈ<µn³iº·»ºKÏ<¼O·o²´Á/·oÈSµn³iº·7º
²´½AÇ¶¸¹¸oµÇ,·oÁ´Ê0¸oµ,Çµ²´¿µ³
$ %&
oÌ:ßÚÙAà Å<¸o¶g·o¶OÇ¶gÁƽA²´¼O·o¸¹¶O³<Ï<Çµ¿º¸o²5ºÒSÁƵ!³<µ,Á ºMÊO½A²´¼¸oµ·¹¸»º¼<½o¾K²Æ½¹½o²´¶¼KÀAÈ<µ¼0Ç7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ ÑWº³<²´¼<Ã¶]Ç,ÇÏ<¸o½MÎ
º¼S³"½¹Ï<Ç7È³<µÁ5ºMÊÇ¶gÏ<Á´³ÒFµÅ<¸¹¶Ò<Á´µ¾º·o²´ÇÑG¶g¸A³<µÁ5ºMÊgÉWÇ,¸o²´·o²´ÇEºÁ¿]²´³<µ,¶(·¹¸»º¼S½o¾²´½¹½o²´¶¼ºÅ<Å<Á´²´ÇEº·o²´¶¼Ì
ÔAÈ<µnÅ<¸¹¶Ò<Á´µ¾°¶ÑA¸»º·oµnÇ¶g¼O·o¸o¶gÁ+²´¼mºÀA²´¸oµÁ´µ½¹½(µ,¼]¿O²´¸o¶g¼<¾µ,¼]·ÕÀA²´·oÈm¿º¸¹²5ºÒ<Á´µÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ¸»º·oµÀAº½ÕÑG¶g¸o¾ºÁ´²´äµ³0²´¼
' &
oÌnÝh¼
·oÈS²Æ½ÅiºÅiµ¸Àµº³<³<¸¹µ½o½A·¹È<µ²´½¹½oÏ<µÕ¶Ñ³<µ½¹²´Ã¼<²´¼<Ã(ºd¸»º·¹µÇ¶g¼O·o¸o¶gÁ¾µÇ7Èiº¼<²´½o¾ ·oÈiº·:ÇEº¼KÀ+¶g¸oÂ²´¼º¼nßÚÙAàVµ,¼]¿O²´¸o¶g¼<¾µ,¼]·:º¼<³
ÀAÈ<²´Ç7È(ÇMº¼n¾²´¼<²´¾n²´äµ/·oÈSµA³<²´½o·o¶g¸o·¹²Æ¶g¼(ÅS¸o¶O³<Ï<Çµ,³ÒOÊ³iº·»ºÕÁ´¶½o½¹µ½:ÇEºÏ<½oµ,³ÒOÊµþOÇµ½¹½o²´¿µÕ³<µÁ5ºMÊOÌÔAÈ<µA¸»º·oµAÇ¶g¼O·o¸o¶gÁ<¾µ,Ç»ÈFº¼<²´½o¾
Ï<½¹µ½Úº¼
)(+*-,/.10,2.
<¾¶O³<µ,Á¶Ñ[·¹È<µÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ/ÒFµÈiºM¿O²´¶¸º¼S³"¸¹µÁ´²´µ½A¶¼¶ÒS½oµ¸¹¿º·o²´¶g¼<½¶Ñ[·oÈSµÇÏ<¸¹¸oµ¼O·!Ç7Èiº¼<¼SµÁ½¹·»º·¹µÀAÈ<²´Ç7È˺¸¹µ
¶ÒS·»º²´¼<µ,³Ëº·Õ·oÈ<µ·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´·o·¹µ¸AÒOÊ"¾K¶¼<²´·¹¶¸o²´¼<Ã·oÈSµ²´¼<Ç¶¾K²´¼<Ã(ß
Í
43
!
ß

½o²´Ã¼iºÁ´½EÌAÔAÈ<µ¸»º·oµÇ,¶¼O·o¸¹¶Á/Ï<¼<²´·³SÊ]¼Fº¾²´ÇEºÁ´ÁÆÊ
º³
5
7Ï<½o·¹½·¹È<µ(½¹¶Ï<¸¹Çµ¿]²´³<µ,¶Ç¶O³<²´¼<ÃK¸»º·¹µ(¸¹µ½oÅF¶¼S³<²´¼<Ã·¹¶·oÈSµ(Ç7Èiº¼<Ãµ½Õ²´¼0Ç7Èiº¼<¼SµÁ/Ç¶¼<³S²Æ·¹²´¶¼<½Õ½o¶·¹Èiº·Õ²´¼0Åiµ,¸o²´¶O³<½¶Ñ+Åi¶O¶g¸
Ç7Èiº¼S¼<µÁAÅFµ¸hÑG¶g¸o¾º¼<ÇµK·oÈ<µK½o¶gÏ<¸oÇµ¡¸»º·¹µÇEº¼ÄÒFµ¸oµ³<ÏSÇµ³ÌÄýÕÊO¼iº¾²´Ç(ÅS¸o¶Ãg¸»º¾¾²´¼<ÃK²´½Ï<½oµ,³·¹¶
6
F¼<³Ä¶gÏ<·(·¹È<µÒFµ½¹·nÒ<²´·
ºÁ´Á´¶OÇEº·¹²´¶¼ÎM²´¼n·oÈ<µA½¹µ¼<½¹µÚ¶ÑP¾K²´¼<²´¾² ä,²Æ¼SÃA·oÈ<µÕµþOÅiµÇ,·oµ³¿ºÁ´Ï<µ¶Ñ·oÈSµ³<²´½o·¹¶¸¹·o²´¶¼ÎRÑG¶¸:µMºÇ7È¿O²´³<µ¶ÕÑG¸7º¾µ²´¼<½o²´³<µA·¹È<µAµ¼<Ç,¶]³Sµ¸
Ò<ÏOÐµ¸MÌ:ã^²´·oÈK·o²´ÃÈO·¹ÁÆÊ²´¼O·oµÃg¸»º·¹µ³¸»º·oµ!Ç¶¼O·¹¸o¶Áº¼<³µ¸o¸¹¶¸AÇ¶g¼O·o¸o¶gÁÏ<¼<²´·EÎOÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁòÑGµµ³SÒiºÇ7Â"º¼<³
7(8*9,/."0,/.
OÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ ¾¶O³<µÁhÎ
Àµ+³<µ,¾¶¼S½o·o¸7º·¹µ:½o²´Ã¼S²

FÇEº¼O·²´¾KÅ<¸o¶¿gµ¾µ¼O·¹½i²´¼·¹È<µØºM¿gµ¸»ºÃµ:¿O²´³<µ¶ÕÖOÏiºÁ´²´·hÊº¼<³(º'Ç¶¸¹¸oµ½¹Åi¶g¼<³<²´¼<Ã!¸oµ,³<Ï<Ç·¹²Æ¶g¼(¶g¼(·¹È<µÅiºÇ7Âµ,·
Á´¶½¹½A¸»º·¹µ½EÌ
ÔAÈ<µAÅiºÅiµ¸å²Æ½/¶g¸oÃ]º¼<²´äµ³nº½/Ñj¶Á´Á´¶ÀA½EÌFÝh¼
:
OµÇ·¹²´¶¼

ÀµA³<µ

F¼<µA·oÈ<µA·¹²´¾²´¼<ÃAÇ¶g¼<½o·¹¸»º²´¼O·o½å³<Ï<µ·o¶·¹È<µ+Ç,¶¼<½¹·»º¼O·:µ,¼<³OÉh·o¶Éhµ¼<³
³<µÁ5ºMÊ0Ç,¶¼<½¹·o¸»º²´¼]·%Òiµ·hÀµµ¼Y·oÈ<µnµ,¼<Ç¶O³<µ¸nº¼<³Ó³<µÇ,¶]³Sµ¸EÌÔAÈ<µn½¹ÊO½o·oµ,¾ Ç,¶¼<½¹²Æ³Sµ¸oµ³ÑG¶¸!¶gÏ<¸µþOÅFµ¸o²´¾µ,¼]·¹½²´½!³<µ½oÇ,¸o²´Òiµ,³Ä²´¼

OµÇ,·o²´¶¼
6
<Ì Ýh¼Åiº¸¹·o²´ÇÏ<Á5º¸+Àµ³<µ,½oÇ¸¹²ÆÒFµ·oÈ<µÕ¿]²´³<µ,¶(µ¼SÇ¶O³<µ¸Úº¼<³·oÈ<µ!·¹¸»º¼S½o¾²´½¹½o²´¶¼n½¹Ê]½¹·oµ¾ÓÎ<º½À+µ,ÁÆÁº½+·¹È<µ!Ç¶¸¹¸oµ½¹Åi¶g¼<³<²´¼<Ã
¾¶O³<µ,ÁMÑG¶¸ Ç»ÈFº¼<¼<µ,Á]ÒFµÈiºM¿O²´¶¸MÌ
;
OµÇ,·o²´¶¼
4
ÕÅ<¸o¶¿O²´³<µ½/ºA³<µ,·»º²´Á´µ³!³<µ½¹Ç¸o²´Å<·¹²´¶¼¶Ñ<·oÈ<µ¶ÅS·o²´¾²´äEº·o²´¶¼ÑG¸7º¾KµÀ+¶g¸oÂÌFãmµ/²Æ¼O·¹¸o¶O³<Ï<Çµ
·oÈSµ:¼<¶·¹²´¶¼!¶Ñiµ,þ]ÅFµÇ·¹µ³³<²´½o·o¶g¸o·¹²Æ¶g¼!ÑG¶g¸Ã²´¿µ¼!Ç7Èiº¼<¼<µÁOÇ7Èiº¸7ºÇ·¹µ¸o²´½¹·o²´Ç½EÎOº¼S³½oÈ<¶ÀmºA½¹¶Á´Ï<·¹²Æ¶g¼!ÇEº¼ÒFµ:¶gÒ<·»º²Æ¼Sµ³·o¶A¾K²´¼<²´¾² ä,µ
·oÈSµdºM¿gµ¸»ºÃµ!µþOÅFµÇ·oµ,³0³<²´½o·¹¶¸o·¹²´¶¼Ì/ÔAÈ<µ!½¹²Æ¾nÏSÁ º·o²´¶¼%¸oµ½¹Ï<Á´·o½²´¼
<
OµÇ·¹²Æ¶g¼
6%
³<µ,¾¶¼S½o·o¸7º·¹µÚ·¹È<µº³<¿º¼O·»ºÃgµ¶Ñ[Ï<½¹²Æ¼SÃ(Ç7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ
ÑGµµ,³<ÒiºÇ7Â²´¼·¹µ¸o¾K½A¶Ñ[·¹È<µ!¸oµÇ,µ²´¿µ³ÓÖOÏiºÁ´²´·hÊ º¼<³ÅiºÇ7Âgµ·AÁ´¶½o½A¸7º·¹µÌ
=
¬
ô
?>
ô/õ
A@
¯ö
õ
ª¬*÷§
ô/õ
¬ª
ýÕÏ<µ·o¶Ó·oÈ<µ±+º¸o²5ºÒ<Á´µ

²´·Ùº·¹µËáï±

AÙâ%¼iº·¹Ï<¸oµ¶Ñ!Ç¶¾KÅ<¸oµ,½o½oµ,³¿O²´³<µ¶FÎ:Ò<ÏtÐPµ¸¹½º·n·¹È<µµ¼<Ç¶O³<µ¸º¼<³I³<µÇ¶O³<µ,¸"º¸¹µ
¸oµ,Ö]ÏS²Æ¸¹µ³0·¹¶n½o¾¶O¶g·oÈ¶gÏ<··¹È<µ!Ò<²´·A¸»º·oµ¿º¸o²5º·¹²Æ¶g¼<½½o¶n·oÈFº·Úº±
B
ØÙVµ,¼<Ç¶O³<µ¸!ÇEº¼"ÒFµÏ<½¹µ³0¶¿gµ¸ÚºÇ¶g¼<½o·7º¼O·A¸»º·oµÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁhÌ

ÏOÐPµ,¸o²´¼<Ãn³iº·»º%¸oµ½¹Ï<Á´·o½²´¼K³<µÁ5ºMÊ]Ì
C
º¸oÃgµ¸+ÒSÏOÐPµ,¸o½¸¹µ½oÏSÁÆ·A²´¼KÁƶg¼<Ãµ,¸+³<µ,Á ºMÊO½AÒ<ÏS·ØºÁƽ¹¶ ºÁ´ÁƶÀIÁ´¶Àµ¸+¶¿gµ¸»ºÁ´Ái³<²´½¹·o¶¸¹·o²´¶¼K·o¶Òiµ
ºÇ7È<²´µ¿gµ³ÒOÊ(Å<¸¹¶ÅFµ¸ÒS²Æ· É ºÁ´ÁƶOÇEº·o²´¶¼ÒFµ·hÀ+µ,µ¼·oÈ<µ!¿O²´³<µ¶%ÑG¸»º¾µ½:²´¼K·oÈ<µ!Ò<ÏOÐµ¸MÌ:Ýh¼"º%¿O²´³<µ¶Ç¶¾K¾nÏ<¼<² ÇMº·o²´¶g¼<½/½oÊO½o·¹µ¾ËÎg·oÈ<µ
µ¼<³tÉW·¹¶Éhµ¼<³0³<µ,Á ºMÊOÎ
DE
ÎOÒiµ·hÀµµ¼¡·oÈ<µ¿O²´³<µ¶²´¼<Å<Ï<·º¼<³¶Ï<·¹Å<Ï<·AÇ¶g¼<½o²´½¹·o½¶Ñ[·¹È<¸oµµ%¾"º
/5
7¶g¸:Ç¶g¾ÅF¶¼<µ¼O·¹½

DEGF'HIKJ
ájñ/¼<Ç¶O³<µ,¸ÚÒSÏOÐPµ,¸A³<µÁ5ºMÊ<â
-LMHIN
á
Í
Èiº¼<¼SµÁÅ<¸¹¶ÅiºÃ]º·o²´¶¼n³<µ,Á ºMÊ<â
-L$HIKO
gáGýÕµÇ¶O³<µ¸!Ò<ÏtÐPµ¸A³SµÁ5ºMÊtâ
2P
á

Mâ
ãmµº½¹½oÏ<¾Kµn·oÈiº·(¿O²´³<µ¶¡µ¼<Ç¶O³<²´¼<Ãmº¼<³m³SµÇ¶O³<²´¼<ÃÓ³<µÁ5ºMÊO½(º¸¹µÇ¶g¼<½o·7º¼O· º¼<³mÀµ¶¼SÁÆÊÓ·»ºÂµn²´¼O·o¶ËºÇÇ¶gÏ<¼O·(·¹È<µ¿º¸o²5ºÒ<Á´µ
µÁ´µ¾Kµ¼O·o½²´¼Ó·oÈ<µn¶¿gµ¸»ºÁÆÁå³<µÁ5ºMÊÄáGð ²´Ã
M
MâÌnÝh¼m¸¹µEºÁÞÉh·o²´¾µ¿O²´³<µ¶¡·o¸»º¼<½o¾K²´½o½o²´¶g¼ÎÒF¶·oÈmµ,¼<Ç¶O³<µ¸nº¼<³m³SµÇ¶O³<µ¸nº¸¹µº·o·7ºÇ7È<µ³
·o¶Ó½oÊO¼<Ç7È<¸¹¶¼<¶gÏ<½n²´¼<Å<Ï<·nº¼S³¶gÏ<·oÅSÏ<·(³Sµ¿O²ÆÇ,µ½EÌYÝjÑÚ¼<¶¡ÑG¸7º¾µ,½ º¸oµ³S¸o¶ÅSÅiµ³Vº··oÈ<µµ¼<Ç,¶]³Sµ¸EÎ²´¼Ä¶g¸o³<µ¸n·¹¶ËÅS¸oµ½¹µ¸o¿gµ0·oÈ<µ

Video
encoder
Encoder
buffer
Video
decoder
Video input
Decoder
buffer
Channel
Video output
δt
δt
δt
e
c
d
Transmitting unit
Receving unit
Delay:
ð ²´ÃÏ<¸¹µ


ýÕµÁ5ºMÊnÇ¶¾KÅi¶g¼<µ¼O·o½¶Ñ+º%Ç¶¾K¾nÏ<¼<²´ÇEº·o²´¶¼½oÊO½o·¹µ¾ËÌ
Ç¶g¸o¸oµ,Ç·³<²´½oÅSÁ ºMÊO²´¼<Ã½oµÖOÏ<µ,¼<Çµn¶Ñ·oÈ<µ¿O²´³<µ¶FÎF·oÈ<µµ¼<³OÉh·o¶ÉWµ,¼<³0³<µÁ5ºMÊÒFµ·hÀ+µ,µ¼Ë·¹È<µ½oÊO¼<Ç7È<¸o¶g¼<¶ÏS½Ú³Sµ¿O²ÆÇ,µ½EÎ
;DE
V²´¼Äá

MâÎFÈiº½
·o¶¡ÒiµnÇ¶g¼<½o·7º¼O·EÌ±Õ²´³<µ¶³iº·7º·oÈFº·(º¸o¸o²´¿gµ½Á5º·¹µ¸·oÈSµ¼Ä·¹È<µn½oÇ7È<µ³SÏ<Á´µ³Ä³<²´½¹Å<Á5ºMÊ0·o²´¾µ²´½!Ç¶¼<½¹²´³<µ¸oµ,³Á´¶g½o·EÌ_ÔAÈ<µÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ
Å<¸¹¶ÅiºÃ]º·¹²´¶¼³<µÁ5ºMÊ]ÎgÀAÈ<²´Ç7ÈnÇ¶¸¹¸oµ½¹Åi¶g¼<³<½A·¹¶·oÈ<µÕ½o²´Ã¼FºÁF·o¸»º¼<½o¾K²´½o½o²´¶g¼(·¹²Æ¾Kµ:Ñj¸o¶¾·¹È<µ·¹¸»º¼S½o¾²´·¹·oµ¸:·¹¶·oÈSµ¸oµ,Çµ²´¿µ¸MÎ<ÇEº¼nÒiµ
Ç¶g¼<½o²´³<µ¸¹µ³0º½:Ç,¶¼<½¹·»º¼O·²´¼n¾"º¼OÊ!ÀA²´¸oµÁ´µ½¹½AÇ7Èiº¼<¼SµÁ´½EÌ/ÝjÑ·oÈSµ¸oµÕ²Æ½¼<µ·hÀ¶¸¹ÂO²Æ¼SÃ²´¼]¿g¶Á´¿µ,³ º¼<³n·oÈ<µÕ³<µÁ5ºMÊ²Æ½å¿º¸o²5ºÒ<Á´µ+ÀµÇEº¼
º½¹½oÏ<¾Kµ·oÈFº·
HIN
!²´½·¹È<µ¾"ºþO²´¾Ï<¾¸»º·¹µÌÕÔAÈ<²´½ÀA²´Á´Á¶¼SÁÆÊK¸oµ½¹Ï<Á´·!²Æ¼¡¶¿µ¸¹³<²´¾µ¼<½¹²´¶¼<²´¼<Ã¶Ñ+·¹È<µµ¼SÇ¶O³<µ¸
3
³<µÇ¶O³<µ,¸nÒ<ÏOÐµ¸o½
º¼S³0ÀA²´ÁÆÁ¼S¶·ÚºRÐPµ,Ç··¹È<µ(¶¿gµ¸»ºÁ´ÁFÑG¶¸¹¾nÏ<Á5º·o²´¶g¼
6

&
oÌ:ÔAÈ<µ¸¹µ7ÑG¶g¸oµ·oÈ<µ½oÏ<¾¶Ñ
HIKJ
Úº¼<³
6HIKO
%Èiº½Õ·o¶nÒFµ(Ç,¶¼<½¹·»º¼O·Õ²Æ¼má

EâÌ'ÔAÈ<²´½
ºÁ´½¹¶¾µMº¼<½Õ·oÈiº·Ú·¹È<µ¼]ÏS¾nÒiµ¸Õ¶Ñ+¿O²´³<µ¶_ÑG¸»º¾µ½Õ½o·¹¶¸oµ,³Ë²´¼Ó·oÈ<µµ¼<Ç¶O³<µ,¸(º¼<³Ó³<µÇ,¶]³Sµ¸Ò<ÏOÐµ¸¹½Èiº½!·¹¶ÒFµ(Ç¶g¼<½o·7º¼O·EÌ%ãmµ
¼<¶ÀV³<µ½¹Ç¸o²´ÒFµnÈ<¶À·¹È<²´½³<µ,Á ºMÊKÇ¶¼S½o·o¸7º²´¼O·!·o¸»º¼<½oÁ5º·oµ½Õ²Æ¼O·¹¶ºnÇ¶g¼<½o·¹¸»º²´¼O·¶g¼·oÈ<µ¸»º·oµ½!·oÈFº·AÇEº¼0ÒiµÏ<½¹µ³0Ñj¶¸AµEºǻȡ¿]²´³<µ,¶
ÑG¸7º¾µgÌ
Ýh¼(¶gÏ<¸:³<²´½¹ÇÏ<½o½¹²´¶¼Î·¹È<µA¿O²´³<µ¶!½oµÖOÏ<µ,¼<Çµ²´½/½oÏSÒi³<²´¿O²´³<µ³n²´¼O·o¶

.

0

0

ÎÀAÈ<²´Ç7È(¾ºMÊÇ¶g¼<½o²´½¹·:¶Ñ½oµ¿gµ¸»ºÁi¾ºÇ¸¹¶Ò<Á´¶OÇ7ÂO½EÎ
ºnÃg¸o¶gÏ<Å0¶Ñ:Ò<Á´¶OÇ7ÂO½ á
ü


Øâ'¶¸!ºÑG¸7º¾µgÌAßÇ¶g¼O¿µ¼<²´µ¼O·!Ç7È<¶²´Çµ%¶Ñ+¿O²´³<µ¶KÒ<Á´¶]Ç7ÂK½o²´äµ²Æ½Õ·oÈiº·ÀAÈ<µ,¸oµn·oÈSµ ºM¿gµ¸»ºÃµ¼OÏ<¾nÒFµ¸
¶ÑÒ<²´·o½!Ï<½oµ,³Ë²´¼Óµ¼<Ç¶O³<²´¼<Ãº¿O²´³<µ¶KÒ<Á´¶OÇ»Â0ºÅ<Å<¸o¶þO²´¾"º·oµÁ´ÊKµÖOÏiºÁ´½¶g¸!²Æ½!½¹¾"ºÁ´Á´µ¸A·¹Èiº¼0·¹È<µn½o²´äµ¶ÑAºn·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´·o·¹µ³ÓÅiºÇ7Âµ,·
áGº½o½¹Ï<¾µ³nÈSµ¸oµ!·o¶ÒFµ

iþOµ³iâ,Ì/ÔAÈ<µ!·o²´¾µ²´¼<³<µþn²´½:ÖOÏiº¼O·o²´äµ³º¼<³º!·o²´¾µÏ<¼<²´·²´½:·oÈ<µ!·¹²Æ¾Kµ+²´¼O·oµ,¸o¿ºÁF¶Ñ³S²Æ½¹Å<Á5ºMÊO²Æ¼SÃdºd¿]²´³<µ,¶
Ò<Á´¶OÇ7ÂPÎ ¶¸!µÖOÏ<²´¿ºÁƵ,¼]·¹Á´Ê0·oÈ<µn·¹²´¾µ²´¼O·oµ¸¹¿ºÁ:¶ÑØ·¹¸»º¼<½o¾K²Æ·¹·o²´¼<ÃºÅiºÇ7Âgµ·EÌýÕµ

F¼<µ
D

º½·¹È<µnÇ¶g¼<½o·7º¼O·¼OÏ<¾nÒFµ¸!¶ÑA¿]²´³<µ,¶
Ò<Á´¶OÇ7Â]½²´¼·¹È<µµ¼SÇ¶O³<µ¸Úº¼<³³SµÇ¶O³<µ¸AÒ<ÏtÐPµ¸MÌ:ã^ÈS²ÆÁ´µA·¹È<µ!¼]ÏS¾nÒiµ¸å¶Ñ[ÒSÁƶOÇ7ÂO½+²´¼<½¹²´³<µÒF¶·¹È·oÈSµ·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´·o·¹²´¼<Ã(º¼S³¸oµ,Çµ²´¿O²Æ¼SÃ
Ò<ÏOÐµ¸!²´½!Ç¶¼<½¹·»º¼]·MÎF·oÈ<µ¼OÏ<¾nÒiµ,¸¶ÑÒ<Á´¶]Ç7ÂO½²´¼0·¹È<µµ¼<Ç¶O³<µ¸%Ò<ÏOÐµ¸!²Æ½!¿º¸o²5ºÒ<Á´µº¼S³ËºÁ´ÀAºMÊ]½A½¹¾"ºÁÆÁ´µ¸A·¹Èiº¼
D

mÌýÕµ¼S¶·oµ
Ò<Á´¶OÇ7Â

º½A·¹È<µÁ5º½¹·AÒ<Á´¶]Ç7ÂK¶Ñ:·oÈ<¶g½oµÀAÈS²ÆÇ7È0º¸¹µ!·o¸»º¼<½o¾K²´·o·oµ,³"ÒOÊK·oÈ<µÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ/º·A·¹²Æ¾Kµ

Î<º¼<³Ò<Á´¶OÇ7Â

º½Õ·oÈ<µ%¶¼<µ!ÀAÈ<²´Ç7È
5
7Ï<½¹·+º¸¹¸o²´¿µ,³º·:·¹È<µAµ¼<Ç¶O³<µ,¸+Ò<ÏtÐPµ¸Aº·å·o²´¾µ

Ì Ýh·:²´½:Åi¶g½o½¹²ÆÒSÁƵA·¹Èiº·å¼<¶·:ºÁ´Á<·¹È<µA³iº·»º!¶ÑPÒ<Á´¶OÇ7Â

%²´½:·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´·o·¹µ³nº·:·¹²Æ¾Kµ

Î
ÒFµÇEºÏS½oµ·oÈ<µ¸¹µÖOÏ<²´¸oµ³¡¼]ÏS¾nÒiµ¸¹½A¶Ñ/Ò<²´·o½A·o¶nµ,¼<Ç¶O³<µ³<²ÞÐPµ¸¹µ¼O·¿O²´³<µ¶nÒ<Á´¶OÇ7ÂO½º¸oµ!³<²ÞÐµ¸oµ,¼]·MÌAýµ,¼<¶·¹µ

Gá

Sâº½A·¹È<µ¼OÏ<¾nÒFµ¸
¶Ñ:Ò<²´·¹½AÒiµÁ´¶g¼<Ã²´¼<Ãn·¹¶nÒ<Á´¶]Ç7Â

·¹Èiº·º¸oµ½¹·o²´Á´Á²´¼·¹È<µµ¼SÇ¶O³<µ¸!Ò<ÏOÐµ¸EÌ'ßÁ´½o¶n³<µ,¼<¶·¹µ

á

jâº½A·¹È<µ¼OÏ<¾nÒFµ¸A¶Ñ:Ò<²´·¹½A·oÈiº·Úº¸¹µ
Ï<½¹µ³ÒOÊÒ<Á´¶]Ç7Â

oÌ/ÔAÈSµAÇ¶¼O·oµ,¼]·¶Ñ·¹È<µAµ¼<Ç,¶]³Sµ¸AÒ<ÏOÐµ¸·oÈ<µ¼KÇ¶¼S½o²´½o·¹½+¶Ñ
!

á
"
<â
$#%
á

L 
Mâ
$#%
á

L6
gâ
$#
P PP
%#
á
"
iâòÒ<²´·o½¶Ñ³iº·7º
ÑG¸¹¶¾*Ò<Á´¶]Ç7ÂO½
&'#%
L 
#
PP P
%#%
Ì/ÔAÈSµÚÒSÏOÐPµ,¸ÚÇ,¶¼O·oµ¼O·!º·A·o²´¾Kµ

K²´½A³<µÅ<²´Ç·¹µ³Ë²´¼0ð ²´Ã

SÌ:ß¿O²´³<µ¶nÒSÁƶOÇ7Â²´½AÇ¶g¼<½o²´³<µ,¸oµ³ÓÁ´¶½o·A²ÞÑ
º¼OÊ¶Ñ·oÈ<µÅiºÇ7Âgµ·o½!ÀAÈ<²´Ç7ÈËÇMº¸o¸¹Ê0³iº·»ºÑj¸o¶¾·¹Èiº·!Ò<Á´¶OÇ7ÂÇEº¼<¼S¶·!Òiµ³<µÁ´²´¿µ,¸oµ³Ó·o¶K·oÈ<µ¸oµÇ,µ²´¿]²´¼<Ãµ¼S³ËÒOÊ0·¹È<µ(½¹Ç7È<µ³<Ï<Á´µ³
³<²´½oÅSÁ ºMÊ·¹²Æ¾KµÌAÔAÈ<²´½!³<µÁ5ºMÊÇ¶g¼<½o·¹¸»º²´¼O·!ÇEº¼¡Òiµn·¹¸»º¼S½oÁ5º·¹µ³Ë²´¼O·o¶ºKÇ¶g¼<½o·¹¸»º²Æ¼O·!¶¼¡·oÈ<µ¼OÏ<¾nÒiµ,¸¶ÑÒ<²´·o½!·oÈiº·ÇEº¼ËÒFµÏ<½oµ³
ÑG¶g¸(µ¼SÇ¶O³<²´¼<ÃË·¹È<¶½¹µÒ<Á´¶]Ç7ÂO½ÀAÈ<²´Ç»ÈIº¸¹µ½o·¹²´ÁÆÁ½o·¹¶¸¹µ³I²Æ¼Y·oÈ<µKµ¼<Ç¶O³<µ,¸Ò<ÏOÐµ¸MÌÄÝh¼Y·oÈ<µKµþ<º¾ÅSÁƵn³SµÅ<²´Ç·oµ,³²´¼Ið²´Ã
7
SÎ/·oÈ<µ
µ¼<³tÉW·¹¶Éhµ¼<³0³<µ,Á ºMÊ
:D

®Ç¶¼S½o·o¸7º²´¼<½Õ·oÈ<µ!¿ºÁ´Ï<µ,½A¶Ñ
(
há

Sâ
$#%
(á
"
L 
Eâ
#
PPP
#%
á

FâÌ
τ+1
τ
Channel
τ-1
τ+2
ν
Transmitting buffer
Receiving buffer
τ
C(ν)
Video
input
R(τ+1)
R(τ+2)
R(τ+3)
R(υ)
R’(τ)
R(τ)-R’(τ)
R(τ-1)
...
...
R(υ-∆N)
υ-∆N
Video
block
Video
output
τ+3
ð ²´ÃÏ<¸¹µ
4

Ô[¸7º¼<½¹¾²´·o·¹²´¼<ÃÒ<ÏOÐµ¸ÕÇ¶¼O·oµ,¼]·
Í
¶¼<½¹²´³<µ¸!Ò<Á´¶OÇ»Â
)
ÎFÀAÈ<²´Ç7È˺¸o¸o²´¿gµ³ÿº··¹È<µ(µ,¼<Ç¶O³<µ¸ÒSÏOÐPµ,¸dº··¹²Æ¾Kµ

ÌßÕÁ´Á[·¹È<µ³iº·7ºnÀAÈ<²´Ç7È0Ç¶g¸o¸oµ,½oÅF¶¼<³<½%·o¶ÒSÁƶOÇ7Â
)
½oÈS¶Ï<Á´³0ÒFµnÇEº¸¹¸o²´µ³Ó¶Ï<·!¶Ñ+·oÈ<µ³<µÇ,¶]³Sµ¸Ò<ÏOÐµ¸ÒOÊ·oÈSµnÇ»ÈFº¼<¼<µ,Á[ÒFµ7ÑG¶g¸oµn·¹²Æ¾Kµ

4LGD

mÎF¶·¹È<µ¸¹ÀA²Æ½¹µn·oÈ<µ¾"ºþO²Æ¾Ï<¾³<µÁ5ºMÊ
ÑG¶g¸(Ò<Á´¶OÇ7Â
*
ÀA²´ÁÆÁåÒiµµþOÇµµ,³<µ³ÌYÝh¼Ä·¹È<µµþ<º¾Å<Á´µn³<µÅS²ÆÇ,·oµ³I²´¼Äð ²ÆÃ

<Î/·¹È<²´½(·¹²´¾²´¼<ÃÇ,¶¼<½¹·o¸»º²´¼]·¶¼YÒ<Á´¶OÇ»Â
+
Ó¾KµEº¼S½·oÈ<µ
ÇÏ<¾nÏSÁ º·o²´¿µÕÒ<²´·o½Õ¶Ñ:³iº·7ºn·¹Èiº·!º¸oµ%·o¸»º¼<½o¾K²´·o·oµ,³"ÒOÊ·oÈSµ(Ç7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ/²´¼·oÈ<µ·¹²´¾µ!Åiµ,¸o²´¶O³
,
4L 
#
L'
-#
P PP
.#%
4L'D

ù½oÈ<¶gÏ<Á´³
ÒFµÁ5º¸oÃgµ¸·¹Èiº¼
/&
já

<â'·o¶KÅ<¸oµ¿gµ¼O·Úº¼]Ê³iº·»º¶ÑzÒSÁƶOÇ7Â
)
_ÑG¸o¶g¾ ÒFµ²´¼<Ã¶¿gµ¸hÉh³<µÁ5ºMÊgµ³²Æ¼¡·oÈ<µµ,¼<Ç¶O³<µ¸!Ò<ÏOÐµ¸MÌÚýÕµ

i¼Sµ
0
ná
1
Sâ
º½!·¹È<µº¾K¶Ï<¼O·A¶ÑA³iº·»ºK·oÈiº·!²Æ½!·¹¸»º¼S½o¾²´·¹·oµ³ÓÒOÊ0Ç7Èiº¼<¼SµÁ+º·!·¹²Æ¾Kµ
1
ÌÔAÈ<µÇ¶¼S³<²´·o²´¶¼Ó·o¶Å<¸¹µ¿µ¼O·ÒSÁƶOÇ7Â
,
ÑG¸o¶g¾Òiµ,²Æ¼SÃ

τ+1
τ
Channel
τ-1
τ+2
ν
Transmitting buffer
Receiving buffer
τ
C(ν)
Video
input
R(τ+1)
R(τ+2)
R(τ+3)
R(υ)
R’(τ)
R(τ)-R’(τ)
R(τ-1)
...
...
R(υ-∆N)
υ-∆N
Video
block
Video
output
τ+3
R(τ+1)+R’(τ) ≤ ∑ C(k)
R(τ+2)+R(τ+1)+R’(τ) ≤ ∑ C(k)
R(τ+3)+R(τ+2)+R(τ+1)+R’(τ) ≤ ∑ C(k)
υ+1
υ+1
υ+1
τ+1+∆N
τ+3+∆N
τ+2+∆N
R(υ)+...+R(τ+3)+R(τ+2)+R(τ+1)+R’(τ) ≤ ∑ C(k)
υ+1
υ+∆N
...
R’(τ) ≤ ∑ C(k)
υ+1
τ+∆N
ð ²´ÃÏS¸oµ
4

Í
¶g¼<½o·¹¸»º²´¼O·A¶¼·¹È<µ!¿ºÁ´Ï<µ¶Ñ:Ò<²´·hÉh¸»º·¹µ½
&
á

jâåÑG¶¸AµMºÇ7ÈÒ<Á´¶]Ç7ÂK²Æ¼S½o²´³<µ!·oÈ<µ!µ¼SÇ¶O³<µ¸!Ò<ÏOÐµ¸º·A·¹²´¾µ

¶¿µ,¸hÉh³<µÁ5ºMÊµ³²´¼·¹È<µµ¼SÇ¶O³<µ¸ÒSÏOÐPµ,¸·oÈOÏ<½AÇMº¼Òiµ%ÀA¸o²´·o·¹µ¼0º½



á

Sâ





0
ná
1
Sâ á

gâ

²´ÂgµÀA²´½oµÕÑG¶¸AÒSÁƶOÇ7Â

+LG
!·o¶nÒFµÇ¶g¸o¸¹µÇ·oÁ´Ê0¸¹µÇµ²´¿gµ³ÎF²´·o½A³iº·»ºnº¼S³0·oÈiº·A¶Ñ:·oÈSµÚÅS¸oµ¿O²´¶Ï<½ÕÒ<Á´¶OÇ»ÂO½A½¹È<¶Ï<Á´³0ÒFµ!·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´·o·¹µ³
ÒOÊ·¹²Æ¾Kµ
&
L L$D

mÌ/ÔAÈ<²´½AÇ¶g¼<³<²´·o²´¶¼KÇEº¼ÒFµ!ÀA¸o²´·o·¹µ¼Ëº½


á

L 
Eâ
-L


á
"
<â





0
_á
1
<â á

gâ
Ýh¼0Ãgµ¼<µ¸7ºÁhÎ<·¹È<µÇ¶g¼<³<²´·o²´¶¼KÑG¶g¸·¹È<µ³iº·»º¶Ñ:Ò<Á´¶OÇ7Â

¹Î

'#
PPP
#%

]ÎO·o¶KÒiµ%³<µÁ´²´¿µ¸¹µ³0·o¶n·¹È<µ¸oµÇµ,²Æ¿gµ¸!ÀA²´·oÈ<¶gÏ<·A¿O²Æ¶gÁ5º·o²´¼<Ã
·oÈSµÚ³SµÁ5ºMÊÇ¶g¼<½o·¹¸»º²´¼O·A²´½A·oÈOÏ<½







(á

â
L
+

á

<â






0
ná
1
<â á
1
Oâ
ðS¸o¶¾ á
1
]â,Î·oÈ<µ0Ç,¶¼<½¹·o¸»º²´¼]·¹½n¶¼

há

<â
#
á

L 
Mâ
$#
P PP
.#%
á

Fâ(º·n·o²´¾µ

Iº¸oµ½¹Ï<¾¾º¸o²´äµ,³Ä²´¼ð ²´ÃiÌ

SÌ

[ºÇ7Âµ·KÁƶg½o½nÇEº¼
ÒFµºM¿¶²´³<µ,³ËÒOÊÓÂµµÅS²Æ¼SÃiÎ ·oÈ<¸¹¶Ï<ÃgÈm¸»º·¹µnÇ¶¼O·¹¸o¶ÁhÎ ·oÈ<µnµ,¼<Ç¶O³<²´¼<Ã0¸7º·oµ,½(ÀA²´·oÈS²Æ¼Ó·oÈSµnÒi¶gÏ<¼<³<½³Sµ

i¼<µ³YÒOÊÄá
1
OâÌKã^È<²´Á´µ(·¹È<²´½
À¶Ï<Á´³0ÒFµ(µMº½oÊ¡·o¶"ºÇ7È<²´µ¿µ²ÞÑ
0
_á
1
<âÕÀµ¸oµÂO¼<¶ÀA¼ÎF²´¼0¶Ï<¸!ÇEº½oµ·oÈ<µÇ7Èiº¼S¼<µÁ:¸7º·oµ,½Ú³SµÅiµ,¼<³m¶¼0·¹È<µÇ»ÈFº¼<¼<µ,Á:½o·7º·oµÀAÈ<²´Ç7È
¿º¸¹²´µ½+¸7º¼<³S¶¾Á´ÊOÌFãmµÀA²´Á´Á<½oÈ<¶À ·oÈiº·+¸7º·oµ!Ç¶g¼O·o¸o¶gÁÇEº¼KÒiµ!ºÁ´½o¶%ÑG¶g¸o¾nÏ<Á5º·¹µ³ÀA²Æ·¹È"º!ÅS¸o¶ÒFºÒ<²´Á´²´½o·o²´ÇA¾K¶]³SµÁi¶Ñ·oÈ<µ!Ç7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ
ÒFµÈiºM¿O²´¶¸A²´¼

Oµ,Ç·o²´¶¼
<
FÌ/ãmµ

F¸o½o·A³Sµ½oÇ¸¹²´Òiµ·oÈ<µ!ÀA²´¸oµ,ÁƵ,½o½½¹ÊO½o·oµ,¾À+µº¸¹µ!Ç¶¼<½¹²´³<µ¸o²´¼<ÃFÌ

ª

ª¬
!
>
ø
"
ª0¯*
ô
$#
¬
ô
ö
õ
%'&)( *,+.-0/213/24651'-0/278$46-9-6/51'-6/27
ÔAÈ<µ½o¶gÏ<¸oÇµ¿O²´³<µ¶0µ,¼<Ç¶O³<µ¸nÏ<½¹µ³I²´¼Ä¶ÏS¸½o²´¾nÏ<Á5º·¹²´¶¼0ÀAº½
;:
(Ì
 
oÎ/º¿O²Æ³Sµ¶ËÇ,¶¾ÅS¸oµ½¹½o²´¶¼m½¹·»º¼S³iº¸¹³Ä·»º¸oÃgµ·oµ³^º·
Á´¶À>Ò<²´·hÉh¸»º·oµ·o¸»º¼<½o¾K²´½o½o²´¶g¼ ºÅ<Å<Á´²´ÇEº·¹²´¶¼<½MÌ!ß½o²´¾KÅ<Á´µÀغMÊ·¹¶¿O²´½oÏiºÁƲ´äµ¶ÏS¸½oÊO½¹·oµ¾ á5½¹µµð ²´ÃiÌ

]â'²Æ½!·¹¶"º½¹½oÏ<¾Kµ(·¹Èiº·Õ·oÈ<µ
½»º¾µA¿O²´³<µ¶³Fº·»º%Ç¶O³<µ³KÀA²´·oÈn³<²ÞÐµ¸oµ¼O·AÖOÏiº¼]·¹²´äEº·¹²Æ¶g¼n½o·¹µÅ<½A²´½:½o·¹¶¸¹µ³²Æ¼n½¹µÅiº¸»º·¹µ!Ò<ÏOÐµ¸o½áï¼<¶·¹µ·oÈFº·¶¼<Á´ÊÖ]ÏFº¼O·o²´äEº·o²´¶¼
³<²ÞÐµ¸o½7âÌnÔAÈ<µ¸»º·oµnÇ¶g¼O·o¸o¶gÁ:Ï<¼<²´·!·oÈSµ¼mÇ7È<¶O¶½oµ,½·oÈ<µnÅS¸o¶ÅFµ¸ÒS²Æ· ÉW½¹·o¸¹µEº¾®ÑG¸o¶g¾³<²ÞÐPµ¸¹µ¼O·Ò<ÏOÐµ¸¹½(Òiº½oµ³m¶g¼Ë·¹È<µ%ÑGµµ³<ÒFºÇ7Â

Ç7Èiº¼S¼<µÁ:Ç¶g¼<³<²´·o²´¶g¼ º¼<³Ó·oÈ<µnÙÉoý>¸¹µÁ5º·o²´¶g¼<½¶Ñ+·oÈ<¶g½oµ¿O²Æ³Sµ¶Ò<Á´¶OÇ7ÂO½ÚÀAÈS²ÆÇ7È˺¸oµ½o·¹¶¸oµ,³Ë²´¼0·¹È<µ½oµnÒSÏOÐPµ,¸o½EÌ

¼<Á´Ê"·¹È<µ³iº·7º
ÑG¸¹¶¾·oÈ<µÕÇ7È<¶½¹µ¼Ò<ÏtÐPµ¸A²´½:·¹¸»º¼<½o¾K²Æ·¹·oµ³nÒOÊ·oÈ<µÕÇ7Èiº¼<¼SµÁhÎ<º¼<³n·¹È<µ³iº·»ºÕÑj¸o¶¾¶g·oÈ<µ¸Ò<ÏOÐµ¸¹½º¸oµÕ³<²´½oÇEº¸o³<µ,³Ì

Ò]¿O²´¶ÏS½oÁ´Ê]Îgº
½o²´¾K²ÆÁ5º¸¸oµ,½oÏ<Á´·ÇEº¼KÒiµ!ºÇ7È<²´µ¿µ,³nÀA²Æ·¹Èº!Á5ºMÊµ¸¹µ³¿O²´³<µ¶%Ç¶O³<µ¸EÎOÀAÈSµ¸oµ!·oÈSµ·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´·o·¹µ³n¿O²´³<µ¶ÖOÏiºÁƲ´·hÊÇMº¼nÒFµÚº³
5
7Ï<½o·¹µ³ÒOÊ
³<µÇ,²Æ³S²Æ¼SÃ(·¹È<µ¼OÏ<¾nÒFµ¸:¶ÑÁ ºMÊgµ¸o½·o¶ÒFµ·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´·o·¹µ³Ì/Ýh¼n¶gÏ<¸+½¹²´¾nÏ<Á5º·o²´¶g¼<½/ÀAÈ<µ¼"ºd¿]²´³<µ,¶(Ò<Á´¶OÇ7Â(²´½Á´¶½o·MÎ³SÏ<µ!·o¶(º%¿O²Æ¶gÁ5º·o²´¶g¼
¶Ñ/·oÈ<µ!³<µ,Á ºMÊÇ¶g¼<½o·¹¸»º²´¼O·EÎSÀ+µÕ¸oµÅSÁ ºÇµ²´·:ÒOÊ²´·¹½+Ç¶g¸o¸¹µ½oÅF¶¼<³S²Æ¼SÃý
Í
¿ºÁ´Ï<µÚº·+·¹È<µ!³<µÇ¶O³<µ,¸µ¼<³ Ì/ãmµÚº½¹½oÏ<¾Kµ·¹Èiº··oÈ<µý
Í
¿ºÁ´Ï<µÕ¶Ñ:º¿O²´³<µ¶nÒ<Á´¶OÇ7ÂO½+ÇEº¼Òiµ!·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´·o·¹µ³¸¹µÁ´²5ºÒ<Á´ÊnÒOÊnÏ<½o²´¼<Ãð/ñ
Í
ÀA²´·oÈKÈ<²´ÃÈÅS¸o¶·¹µÇ·¹²Æ¶g¼ÇEºÅiºÒ<²´Á´²Æ·hÊOÌ
-!
Õ¶·oµ!·¹Èiº·A·¹È<²´½
º½¹½oÏ<¾KÅ<·o²´¶g¼"²´½Õ½o¶¾KµÀAÈiº·AÅiµ½¹½o²´¾²´½¹·o²´Ç!½o²´¼<Çµ²´·À¶Ï<Á´³ÒiµÅF¶½o½¹²´Ò<Á´µ²´¼0Ãµ¼Sµ¸»ºÁ[·¹¶¸¹µÅ<Á5ºÇµÁ´¶½¹·Ò<Á´¶OÇ7Â]½ÕÒOÊ"ÒSÁƶOÇ7ÂO½²´¼·oÈ<µ
½»º¾µÕÅi¶g½o²´·o²´¶¼K²´¼"·¹È<µ!Å<¸oµ,¿]²´¶gÏ<½ÑG¸»º¾µÎg·oÈOÏ<½!ºÇ7È<²´µ¿O²´¼<ÃÒiµ·¹·oµ¸Õµ¸o¸¹¶¸ÕÇ¶¼<Ç,µEºÁ´¾µ,¼]·MÌ
Transmitter
Quantizer #N
Quantizer #2
Quantizer #1
Rate-Control Unit
Receiver
ACK
Wireless
Channel
Channel
Feedback
Rate-Distortion
Video
Input
Buffer
Buffer
Video
Output
Discard
Discard
decoder
Buffer
Buffer
a priori
channel
model
DCT
ð ²´ÃÏ<¸¹µ



OÊO½o·oµ,¾Ò<Á´¶]Ç7Ân³<²5ºÃ¸»º¾ËÌ
%'&
 
.+)4

8$46- -01

4

.+.4

7 8$4

5/2+

/27

ÔAÈ<µ!½oÊO½o·¹µ¾*Ï<¼<³<µ¸Ç¶g¼<½o²´³<µ¸7º·¹²Æ¶g¼²´½Åiº·¹·oµ¸¹¼<µ³ËºRÑG·oµ¸

%
½¹·»º¼<³iº¸¹³Å<¸¹¶ÅF¶½¹µ³KÑG¶¸³<²´Ã²´·»ºÁ<ÀA²´¸oµÁ´µ½¹½AÇ¶¾K¾nÏ<¼<²´ÇEºRÉ
·o²´¶g¼ÌÔAÈS²Æ½/½¹Ê]½¹·oµ¾²´½:ºAÀA²´³<µ7ÉhÒiº¼<³
Í
ý!×ßI½¹Å<¸oµEº³n½oÅFµÇ·¹¸oÏ<¾-½¹ÊO½o·oµ,¾ ÀA²´·¹È(Å<¸¹¶OÇµ½o½¹²´¼<ÃÃ]º²´¼¶Ñ
 
º¼S³(Ç7È<²´Å¸»º·¹µA¶Ñ

P
×Ç7È<²´Å<½
3
½EÎO¸¹µ½oÏSÁÆ·¹²´¼<Ã(²´¼º!³Fº·»º%¸»º·oµ

 P

Ò<²´·o½
3
½EÌ/ÔAÈSµÚÅFºÇ7Âµ·¹½Øº¸oµÕ¶Ñ
%
%¾½oµ,ÇA¶¸
 
!ÒOÊO·oµ½³<Ï<¸7º·¹²Æ¶g¼n¶Ñ/ÀAÈ<²´Ç»È
 
AÒOÊO·oµ½
²´½A·oÈ<µ%ÅiºMÊOÁƶOº³Ì/ßÕ½Úº¸¹µ½oÏ<Á´·!·oÈSµ²´¼OÑG¶¸¹¾"º·o²´¶¼·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´½o½¹²Æ¶g¼¸7º·oµ%²Æ½
% P

ÒS²Æ·¹½
3
½EÌAÝh¼Ãµ,¼<µ¸»ºÁhÎiºÀA²´¸oµÁ´µ½¹½!ÁƲ´¼<ÂnÇ,¶¼<½¹²Æ½¹·o½
¶Ñ/·hÀ+¶¸»º³<²´¶(Á´²´¼<ÂO½EÎg¼iº¾µÁ´ÊÏ<Å<Á´²´¼<Ân¶¸¸oµ¿gµ¸o½¹µ(Á´²´¼<Âá5¾K¶Ò<²´Á´µ7Éh·o¶ÉhÒiº½oµEâ:º¼<³³<¶ÀA¼<Á´²´¼<Â¶¸åÑG¶¸¹Àغ¸o³Á´²Æ¼SÂ"áïÒiº½¹µ7ÉW·¹¶Éh¾¶gÒ<²´ÁƵMâÌ

µÇEºÏS½oµn¶Ñ·oÈ<µnº½¹Ê]¾K¾µ·¹¸oÊn²´¼0·¹È<µ(²´¼OÑj¶¸o¾º·¹²Æ¶g¼ºM¿º²´Á5ºÒ<Á´µ!º··¹È<µÒiº½¹µ º¼<³0·oÈSµ(¾K¶Ò<²´Á´µÚº¼<³ËºÁ´½¹¶·oÈSµ³<²ÞÐPµ,¸oµ¼O·ÅF¶À+µ,¸
Ç¶g¼<½o·¹¸»º²´¼O·o½º¼<³ÈSµ¼<ÇµÅS¸o¶OÇµ½¹½o²´¼<ÃÅF¶Àµ¸EÎO·¹È<µ!³<µ½o²´Ãg¼"¶Ñ[·¹È<µ½oµ%·hÀ+¶Á´²´¼<ÂO½ÈiºM¿µÕ³<²ÞÐPµ¸¹µ¼O·¸¹µÖOÏ<²´¸oµ¾Kµ¼O·o½EÌ

¼·oÈSµÚÏSÅ<Á´²Æ¼SÂ
·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´·o·¹µ¸EÎF·¹È<µnÏ<½oµ,¸³iº·7ºn²´½
B
i¸o½¹·!½oÅ<¸¹µEº³mÏ<½¹²´¼<Ã"º



nÇ¶g¼O¿¶Á´Ï<·¹²´¶¼iºÁµ¼<Ç¶O³<µ¸MÌÔAÈ<µnµ¼<Ç¶O³<µ,³mÒ<²´·o½º¸¹µ(·¹È<µ¼¡ÑGÏ<¸o·¹È<µ¸
½oÅS¸oµEº³"ÏS½o²´¼<Ã
:
É º¸oÊ¶¸¹·oÈ<¶gÃ¶¼FºÁ½o²´Ãg¼iºÁ´²´¼<ÃÕÑG¶Á´Á´¶Àµ³nÒOÊ½oÊO¾nÒF¶Á<²´¼O·oµ,¸oÁ´µEºM¿O²´¼<à º¼<³"à




C!
>½¹Å<¸oµEº³<²´¼<ÃiÌ/ÔAÈSµÚ¸¹µÇµ²´¿gµ¸
µ¾KÅ<Á´¶Ê]½AÒF¶·¹Èÿº¼O·oµ¼<¼Fºº¼S³Ë¾nÏ<Á´·¹²ÆÅFº·oÈK³<²´¿µ¸¹½o²´·hÊÀAÈ<µ¸¹µº¼OÏ<¾nÒFµ¸A¶Ñ+Ç¶¸¹¸oµÁ5º·o¶¸¹½á5µMºÇ7ÈËÇ,¶¸o¸¹µÁ5º·¹¶¸!Ç¶¸¹¸oµ½¹Åi¶g¼<³<½·o¶º
Åiº·oÈiâº¸oµº½o½¹²´Ã¼<µ³Y·o¶0µMºÇ7Èĺ¼O·oµ,¼<¼iº<Ì¡ßÑWº½o·ÇÁ´¶g½oµ³YÁƶO¶gÅËÅF¶À+µ,¸(Ç¶g¼O·o¸o¶gÁ+²´½ÏS½oµ³Y·o¶0Ç¶g¾nÒiº·ÙÕºMÊ]Á´µ²´ÃgÈ0ÑWº³<²´¼<ÃiÌ

¼
·oÈSµ(³<¶ÀA¼SÁƲ´¼<Â·¹¸»º¼S½o¾²´·¹·oµ¸MÎiÏS½oµ¸²´¼OÑj¶¸o¾º·¹²Æ¶g¼²´½!µ¼<Ç¶O³<µ,³mÏ<½o²´¼<Ã0ºnÈFºÁÞÑ5Éh¸»º·¹µÇ¶g¼]¿g¶Á´Ï<·¹²Æ¶g¼iºÁ µ¼<Ç¶O³<µ,¸ º¼<³0·oÈSµnµ¼<Ç¶O³<µ³
Ò<²´·o½º¸oµà



½oÅ<¸¹µEº³Iº¼<³Ó·o¸7º¼<½¹¾²´·o·¹µ³ÓÏ<½o²´¼<Ã
<



¾¶O³<Ï<Á5º·¹²´¶¼Ì
4
OÅFº·o²5ºÁ[³S²Æ¿gµ¸o½¹²´·hÊË·¹È<¸o¶gÏ<ÃÈÓ·oÈ<µnÏS½oµn¶ÑA³<²ÞÐµ¸oµ¼O·
º¼O·¹µ¼<¼iº½á

²´¼¶gÏ<¸AÇEº½¹µEâA²´½AÏ<½¹µ³0·¹¶(Ç¶g¾nÒiº·åÑWº³<²´¼<ÃiÌßÕÁ´½o¶iÎS·oÈ<µ!½¹²ÆÃg¼iºÁ·¹¸»º¼<½o¾K²Æ½¹½o²´¶¼n²´½AÅ<²´Á´¶·Aº½¹½o²´½o·¹µ³Ì

½o²´¼<Ãn·¹È<µ!Å<²´Á´¶·
½o²´Ãg¼iºÁ¸¹µÇµ²´¿µ,³ÿº·A·oÈ<µ¸¹µÇµ²´¿gµ¸EÎF¾"ºþO²Æ¾ºMÁ<¸»º·o²´¶nÇ¶g¾nÒ<²´¼<²´¼<Ã¶Ñ/³<²ÞÐPµ,¸oµ¼O·ÅFº·oÈS½²´½ºÇ7È<²´µ¿gµ³ÌÔAÈ<µ!Ç¶¾nÒS²Æ¼Sµ¸+²´½'ÑG¶Á´Á´¶À+µ,³
ÒOÊn³<µ7Éh²´¼]·¹µ¸oÁ´µEºM¿gµÚº¼<³½¹¶ÑG·³<µÇ²´½¹²Æ¶g¼±Õ²Æ·¹µ¸oÒS²³<µÇ¶O³<µ¸MÌ

+µÇMºÏ<½¹µ¶Ñ·¹È<µÕÑWº½¹·+ÅF¶À+µ,¸+Ç¶g¼O·o¸o¶gÁÏ<½oµ,³Ñj¶¸:·¹È<µ!Ï<Å<Á´²´¼<Â(Ç7Èiº¼<¼<µÁhÎ
·oÈSµÒ<²´·!µ¸o¸¹¶¸Ò<Ï<¸¹½o·o½n·¹µ¼<³Y·o¶ÒiµK¶Ñ½¹È<¶¸¹·oµ¸³<Ï<¸7º·o²´¶g¼Ì"ðS¶¸ºÃ²´¿µ,¼
7
Añ:ÙÎ ·oÈSµ¸oµº¸oµK¾¶g¸oµÅiºÇ7Âµ,·o½²Æ¼mµ,¸o¸o¶g¸Ñj¶¸!·oÈ<µ
Ï<Å<Á´²´¼<ÂÇ7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ

d·¹È<µ¸¹µÚº¸¹µÎgÈ<¶À+µ,¿µ¸MÎÑGµ,À+µ¸åÒ<²´·o½/²´¼(µ¸¹¸o¶g¸:²´¼(µEºÇ7Ènµ¸o¸¹¶¼<µ¶gÏ<½oÁ´Ê¸oµÇ,µ²´¿µ³KÅiºÇ7Âµ,·EÌ/ÔAÈ<µA³<¶ÀA¼SÁƲ´¼<Â!Ç7Èiº¼<¼<µÁ
Èiº½!ÑGµÀµ¸!ÑG¸7º¾Kµ½²´¼Óµ¸o¸¹¶¸Ò<Ï<·EÎ ³<Ï<µn·¹¶·oÈ<µnÒ<ÏS¸o½o·hÊÓ¼iº·oÏ<¸¹µn¶ÑA·oÈ<µnµ¸¹¸o¶g¸o½EÎ/·¹È<µnÅiºÇ»Âgµ·µ¸¹¸o¶g¸(Ò<ÏS¸o½o·¹½·oµ,¼<³Ä·¹¶"ÒFµn¾¶g¸oµ
ÅFµ¸o½¹²Æ½¹·oµ¼O·º¼S³È<µ¼SÇµ(¶Ñ[Á´¶¼SÃµ¸A³<ÏS¸»º·¹²´¶¼Ì ãmµ!¸oµ7ÑGµ,¸·o¶
<
ÑG¶g¸A¾¶g¸oµA³<µ·7º²´Á´½EÌ

Frequently asked questions

Q1. What are the contributions mentioned in the paper "·1è<μ òio1⁄4<3<àa2 ́3<·oè á ́2 ́3⁄4 2 ́·»o·o2 ́¶ 1⁄4s1⁄2eî†ç ¶g3⁄4 å< ̧1μ 1⁄2o1⁄212 ́¶ 1⁄4 àa2 ́áæá òfμ ̧1μ öoï<2 ́ ̧oμ 3¡ñg¶ ̧a¿o2 ́3<μ ¶n·1 ̧»o1⁄4<1⁄2o3⁄4k2æ1⁄211⁄2o2 ́¶ 1⁄4k¶†¿ μ ̧õàa2 ́ ̧oμ á ́μ 1⁄211⁄2 ç7èio†1⁄4s1⁄4<μ á ́1⁄2eì ýõï<μa·o¶%·oè<μaμ þo·1μ 1⁄4<1⁄2o2 ́¿gμ ï<1⁄21μa¶†ñ ¿ o† ̧125o†ò<á ́μ:á ́μ 1⁄4<ãg·oènμ 1⁄4o·1 ̧o¶ åoê ç ¶o3<2 ́1⁄4<ã o†1⁄4<3nås ̧oμ 3<2 ́ç ·12 ́¶ 1⁄4 îgç ¶ 3⁄4kå< ̧oμ,1⁄2o1⁄2oμ,3 ¿o2 ́3<μ ¶!2 ́1⁄2:3⁄4 ¶g ̧oμ:¿oï<á ́1⁄4<μ ̧7o†ò<á ́μa·1¶ ·o ̧7o†1⁄4<1⁄213⁄4 2 ́1⁄2o1⁄212 ́¶ 1⁄4!μ ̧o ̧1¶ ̧11⁄2zo1⁄2/áæ¶g1⁄2o1⁄21μ 1⁄2/çeo†1⁄4 ås ̧o¶o3<ï<ç μao† ̧1·o2þñwoç ·o1⁄2/ï<1⁄4o·o2 ́ág1⁄2oêo1⁄4<ç7è(2 ́1⁄2 ̧oμ ç ¶†¿gμ ̧oμ,3n¶ ̧ ·1è<μ å< ̧oμ 3s2æç,·o2 ́¶ 1⁄4 á ́¶o¶ å%2æ1⁄2 ̧oμ 1⁄21·»o ̧o·oμ,3 ì:ñ/ ̧o ̧1¶ ̧ å< ̧1¶ ·oμ,ç ·o2 ́¶ 1⁄4y2 ́1⁄2 ·oèoï<1⁄2 μ,1⁄2o1⁄2oμ,1⁄4]·125o†á ñg¶g ̧(o ̧o¶gò<ï<1⁄21·(àa2 ́ ̧oμ,áæμ,1⁄2o1⁄2 ¿]2 ́3<μ,¶0·o ̧7o†1⁄4<1⁄213⁄4 2 ́1⁄2o1⁄212æ¶g1⁄4 ìnã^èfo†· 3⁄4 o†â μ,1⁄2úμ, ̧o ̧o¶g ̧(ås ̧o¶ ·1μ ç ·12æ¶g1⁄4äç7èioáæá ́μ 1⁄4sã 2 ́1⁄4<ã 2 ́1⁄4ÿokàa2 ́ ̧oμ,áæμ,1⁄2o1⁄2 μ 1⁄4o¿]2 ́ ̧1¶ 1⁄4<3⁄4kμ 1⁄4o· 2 ́1⁄2 ·oèsμnò<ï< ̧o1⁄21·hêë1⁄4fo†·oïs ̧oμn¶†ña·oèsμnμ ̧o ̧1¶ ̧o1⁄2mî/ï<1⁄2oïfo†á ́á ́ê03<ï<μn·1¶"3⁄4nÏSÁÆ·12 ́Åio†·1È ÑWo†3S2Æ1⁄4SÃiÌ μ ̧12 ́¶]3S1⁄2 ¶†ÑAà ¶O¶O3 Ç7Èio†1⁄4S1⁄4<μ Á:ÒFμ ÈioM¿O2 ́¶ ̧ o†Á ́·1μ ̧o1⁄4io·oμnÀA2 ́·oÈÓ3<μ μ,ÅÓÑWo†3<μ 2 ́1⁄4O·oμ ̧1¿ o†Á ́1⁄2!3<Ï< ̧o2 ́1⁄4<à ÀAÈ<2 ́Ç7ÈÓÃ μ ·1·o2 ́1⁄4<Ã0o†1⁄4OÊ02 ́1⁄4OÑG¶g ̧o3⁄4 o†·o2 ́¶g1⁄4"O†ç, ̧o¶ 1⁄211⁄2(à ¶ ïsáæ3¡ ̧oμ öoï<2 ́ ̧oμ" ?

In this paper, the authors proposed a method to improve the quality of the data collected by the data collection system. 

Q2. há â+( - ( $ ( 5 '&*)?

E F á â "$ á gâ" . há <â+( - ( ( $ ( 5 '&*) + + !8 0+ 8 .1'5 8 +.1 4 *,+ /27 0+ 8 -, 1 7 +ÔAÈ<µA± ²´·¹µ ¸oÒ<²Fº Á´Ã ¶g¸o²´·oÈ<¾ÓÎEºØÑG¶ ¸¹¾ ¶ ÑF³<µ ·oµ,¸o¾ ²´¼<²´½¹·o²´Ç+³SÊ] 

Q3. ?

¼S½o¾ ²´·¹·oµ ¸MÎiÏS½oµ ¸ ²´¼OÑj¶ ¸o¾ º ·¹²Æ¶g¼ ²´½!µ ¼<Ç ¶O³<µ,³mÏ<½o²´¼<Ã0ºnÈFº ÁÞÑ5Éh¸»º ·¹µ Ç ¶g¼]¿g¶ Á´Ï<·¹²Æ¶g¼iº Á µ ¼<Ç ¶O³<µ,¸ º ¼<³0·oÈSµnµ ¼<Ç ¶O³<µ ³ Ò<²´·o½ º ¸oµ à ½oÅ<¸¹µEº ³Iº ¼<³Ó·o¸7º ¼<½¹¾ ²´·o·¹µ ³ÓÏ<½o²´¼<Ã< ¾ ¶O³<Ï<Á5º ·¹²´¶ ¼ Ì4 OÅFº ·o²5º Á[³S²Æ¿gµ ¸o½¹²´·hÊË·¹È<¸o¶gÏ<à ÈÓ·oÈ<µnÏS½oµn¶ ÑA³<²ÞÐ µ ¸oµ ¼O· º ¼O·¹µ ¼<¼iº ½ á ²´¼ ¶gÏ<¸AÇEº ½¹µEâA²´½AÏ<½¹µ ³0·¹¶(Ç ¶g¾nÒiº ·åÑWº ³<²´¼<ÃiÌ ßÕÁ´½o¶iÎS·oÈ<µ!½¹²ÆÃg¼iº Á ·¹¸»º ¼<½o¾K²Æ½¹½o²´¶ ¼n²´½AÅ<²´Á´¶ ·Aº ½¹½o²´½o·¹µ ³ Ì ½o²´¼<Ãn·¹È<µ!Å<²´Á´¶ · ½o²´Ãg¼iº Á ¸¹µ Ç µ ²´¿ µ,³ÿº ·A·oÈ<µ ¸¹µ Ç µ ²´¿gµ ¸EÎF¾"º þO²Æ¾ ºMÁ<¸»º ·o²´¶nÇ ¶g¾nÒ<²´¼<²´¼<à ¶ Ñ/³<²ÞÐPµ,¸oµ ¼O· ÅFº ·oÈS½ ²´½ º Ç7È<²´µ ¿gµ ³ Ì ÔAÈ<µ!