Showing papers in "Brain Behavior and Evolution in 2004"

Brains, innovations and evolution in birds and primates.

Abstract: Several comparative research programs have focused on the cognitive, life history and ecological traits that account for variation in brain size. We review one of these programs, a program that uses the reported frequency of behavioral innovation as an operational measure of cognition. In both birds and primates, innovation rate is positively correlated with the relative size of association areas in the brain, the hyperstriatum ventrale and neostriatum in birds and the isocortex and striatum in primates. Innovation rate is also positively correlated with the taxonomic distribution of tool use, as well as interspecific differences in learning. Some features of cognition have thus evolved in a remarkably similar way in primates and at least six phyletically-independent avian lineages. In birds, innovation rate is associated with the ability of species to deal with seasonal changes in the environment and to establish themselves in new regions, and it also appears to be related to the rate at which lineages diversify. Innovation rate provides a useful tool to quantify inter-taxon differences in cognition and to test classic hypotheses regarding the evolution of the brain.

Causes and consequences of limited attention.

Abstract: This review focuses on the evolutionary causes and consequences of limited attention, defined as the restricted rate of information processing by the brain. The available data suggest, first, that limited attention is a major cognitive constraint determining animals’ search for cryptic food, and, second, that limited attention reduces animals’ ability to detect predators while involved in challenging tasks such as searching for cryptic food. These two effects of limited attention probably decrease animal fitness. Furthermore, a simulated evolutionary study provides empirical support for the prediction that focused attention by predators selects for prey polymorphism. The neurobiological mechanisms underlying limited attention have been widely studied. A recent incorporation of that mechanistic knowledge into an ecological model suggests that limited attention is an optimal strategy that balances effective yet economical search for cryptic objects. The review concludes with a set of testable predictions aimed to expand the currently limited empirical knowledge on the evolutionary ecology of limited attention.

A strong correlation exists between the distribution of retinal ganglion cells and nose length in the dog.

Abstract: The domestic dog, Canis lupus familiaris , is a subspecies of the gray wolf, Canis lupus , with almost identical mitochondrial DNA. The dog is the most diverse spec

Sensory Systems in Amphioxus: A Window on the Ancestral Chordate Condition

Abstract: Amphioxus has an assortment of cells and organs for sensing light and mechanical stimuli. Vertebrate counterparts of these structures are not always apparent, and a strong case can be made for homology in only a few instances. For example, amphioxus has anatomically simple but plausible homologs of both the pineal and paired eyes of vertebrates. Placodal and neural crest derivatives are, however, more problematic: the evidence for an olfactory system in amphioxus is only circumstantial and, despite the variety of secondary sensory cell types that occur on the body surface in amphioxus, none are obvious homologs of vertebrate taste buds, neuromasts or acoustic hair cells. A useful perspective can nevertheless be gained by examining differences in amphioxus and vertebrate development, specifically how each specifies and positions sensory precursors, controls their proliferation, and deploys them through the body. The much larger size of vertebrate embryos and the need to cope developmentally with increased scale and cell numbers may account for some key vertebrate innovations, including placodes and neural crest. The presence or absence of specific structural adaptations, like the latter, is therefore less useful for judging homology between amphioxus and vertebrates than shared features of specific cell types. It is also clear that the duration of embryogenesis in vertebrates has been significantly extended in comparison with ancestral chordates so as to incorporate events that would originally have occurred during the post-embryonic growth period, including events of neurogenesis. Consequently, no scenario for the origin of vertebrates can be considered complete unless it deals explicitly with the whole of the life history and changes to it.

Reduction of brain and sense organs in the fossil insular bovid Myotragus.

Abstract: Our study of the fossil rupicaprine bovid Myotragus [Bate, 1909] from the Mediterranean island Majorca (Spain) provides evidence that this animal underwent significant changes (reduction) in the relative size of brain and sense organs after geographic isolation at the end of the Messinian Salinity Crisis (Miocene-Pliocene boundary, 5.2 Mya). The changes in the central nervous system of Myotragus parallel the pattern reported for domesticated animals, in which decrease in relative brain size is accompanied by a decrease in the relative size of their sense organs. We interpret the important size reduction of brain and sense organs in Myotragus as an adaptive strategy for more efficient energy use under the special environmental conditions of the insular ecosystem, characterized by absence of predation and limitation of trophic resources.

Brain architecture and social complexity in modern and ancient birds.

Abstract: Vertebrate brains vary tremendously in size, but differences in form are more subtle. To bring out functional contrasts that are independent of absolute size, we have normalized brain component sizes to whole brain volume. The set of such volume fractions is the cerebrotype of a species. Using this approach in mammals we previously identified specific associations between cerebrotype and behavioral specializations. Among primates, cerebrotypes are linked principally to enlargement of the cerebral cortex and are associated with increases in the complexity of social structure. Here we extend this analysis to include a second major vertebrate group, the birds. In birds the telencephalic volume fraction is strongly correlated with social complexity. This correlation accounts for almost half of the observed variation in telencephalic size, more than any other behavioral specialization examined, including the ability to learn song. A prominent exception to this pattern is owls, which are not social but still have very large forebrains. Interpolating the overall correlation for Archaeopteryx, an ancient bird, suggests that its social complexity was likely to have been on a par with modern domesticated chickens. Telencephalic volume fraction outperforms residuals-based measures of brain size at separating birds by social structure. Telencephalic volume fraction may be an anatomical substrate for social complexity, and perhaps cognitive ability, that can be generalized across a range of vertebrate brains, including dinosaurs.

Cortical orofacial motor representation in Old World monkeys, great apes, and humans. I. Quantitative analysis of cytoarchitecture.

Abstract: Social life in anthropoid primates is mediated by interindividual communication, involving movements of the orofacial muscles for the production of vocalization and gestural expression. Although phylo

Taste buds: development and evolution.

Abstract: The gustatory system in vertebrates comprises peripheral receptors (taste buds), innervated by three cranial nerves (VII, IX, and X), and a series of central neural centers and pathways. All vertebrates, with the exception of hagfishes, have taste buds. These receptors vary morphologically in different vertebrates but usually consist of at least four types of cells (dark, light, basal, and stem cells). An out-group analysis indicates that taste buds were restricted to the oropharynx, primitively, and that external taste buds, distributed over the head and, in some cases, even the trunk, evolved a number of times independently. The sensory neurons of the cranial nerves that innervate taste buds are believed to arise from epibranchial placodes, which are induced by pharyngeal endoderm, but it has never been demonstrated experimentally that these sensory neurons do, in fact, arise from these placodes. Although many details of the development of the innervation of taste buds are still unknown, it is now clear that taste buds are induced from either ecto- or endodermal epithelia, rather than arising from either placodes or neural crest. At present, there are two developmental models of taste bud induction: The neural induction model claims that peripheral nerve fibers induce taste buds, whereas the early specification model claims that oropharyngeal epithelium is specified by or during gastrulation and that taste buds arise from cell-cell interactions within the specified epithelium. There is now substantial evidence that the early specification model best describes the induction of taste buds.

Brain size scaling and body composition in mammals.

Abstract: Brain size scales with body size across large groups of animals, but exactly why this should be the case has not been resolved. It is generally assumed that body size is a general proxy for some more important or specific underlying variable, such as metabolic resources available, surface area of the body, or total muscle mass (which is more extensively innervated than is, e.g., adipose tissue). The present study tests whether brain size in mammals scales more closely with muscle mass (and other components of lean body mass) than with total fat. Felsenstein's independent comparisons method was used to control for phylogenetic effects on body composition in organ weight data taken from a previously published comparative sample of 39 species in 8 different orders of mammals, all collected and processed by the same researchers. The analysis shows that the size of the central nervous system (CNS) is more closely associated with components of fat-free weight than it is to fat weight. These results suggest a possible explanation for why metabolic resources and brain size both share the same general relationship with body size across mammals. They also suggest that some measure of lean body mass is a more appropriate scaling parameter for comparing brain size across species than is overall body weight.

Tactile foveation in the star-nosed mole.

Abstract: Star-nosed moles have a specialized somatosensory system with 22 mechanosensory appendages surrounding the nostrils. A pair of appendages (the 11th pair on the ventral midline) acts as the tactile fov

Spatial Learning and Memory in Birds

Abstract: Behavioral ecologists, well versed in addressing functional aspects of behavior, are acknowledging more and more the attention they need also to pay to mechanistic processes. One of these is the role of cognition. Song learning and imprinting are familiar examples of behaviors for which cognition plays an important role, but attention is now turning to other behaviors and a wider diversity of species. We focus here on work that investigates the nature of spatial learning and memory in the context of behaviors such as foraging and food storing. We also briefly explore the difficulties of studying cognition in the field. The common thread to all of this work is the value of using psychological techniques as tools for assessing learning and memory abilities in order to address questions of interest to behavioral ecologists.

A new model for olfactory placode development.

Abstract: The peripheral nervous system of vertebrate animals arises primarily from the interaction of cranial neural crest and sensory placodes. Placodes are described as thickenings of ectoderm that arise thr

Cortical orofacial motor representation in Old World monkeys, great apes, and humans. II. Stereologic analysis of chemoarchitecture.

Abstract: This study presents a comparative stereologic investigation of neurofilament protein- and calcium-binding protein-immunoreactive neurons within the region of orofacial representation of primary motor cortex (Brodmann's area 4) in several catarrhine primate species (Macaca fascicularis, Papio anubis, Pongo pygmaeus, Gorilla gorilla, Pan troglodytes, and Homo sapiens). Results showed that the density of interneurons involved in vertical interlaminar processing (i.e., calbindin- and calretinin-immunoreactive neurons) as well pyramidal neurons that supply heavily-myelinated projections (i.e., neurofilament protein-immunoreactive neurons) are correlated with overall neuronal density, whereas interneurons making transcolumnar connections (i.e., parvalbumin-immunoreactive neurons) do not exhibit such a relationship. These results suggest that differential scaling rules apply to different neuronal subtypes depending on their functional role in cortical circuitry. For example, cortical columns across catarrhine species appear to involve a similar conserved network of intracolumnar inhibitory interconnections, as represented by the distribution of calbindin- and calretinin-immunoreactive neurons. The subpopulation of horizontally-oriented wide-arbor interneurons, on the other hand, increases in density relative to other interneuron subpopulations in large brains. Due to these scaling trends, the region of orofacial representation of primary motor cortex in great apes and humans is characterized by a greater proportion of neurons enriched in neurofilament protein and parvalbumin compared to the Old World monkeys examined. These modifications might contribute to the voluntary dexterous control of orofacial muscles in great ape and human communication.

Neural Constraints on the Complexity of Avian Song

Abstract: Why do birds sing? In many species, because the song attracts or retains a mate. Why do females pay attention? This paper reviews evidence that females may do so because male song can be an honest indicator of attributes of a male's brain that could contribute to his fitness or that of his young. Male songbirds learn and produce their songs using a set of brain regions collectively known as the song system. The learning has distinct auditory and motor components, and current data suggest that the neural changes that encode these forms of learning primarily occur in different subdivisions of the song system. There are positive correlations between song complexity and the volume of motor song system nucleus HVC, both between and within species. The correlations appear to arise because individual differences in volume lead to differences in capacity for learning. The differences in HVC volume are correlated with differences in the volumes of other song system components and with the volume of the forebrain. They are heritable. Thus, a complex song can be a signal to a female of immediate fitness (the male has a larger brain) and ultimate fitness (he has attractive characteristics that will be passed on to progeny).

Keeping Sensory Cells and Evolving Neurons to Connect Them to the Brain: Molecular Conservation and Novelties in Vertebrate Ear Development

Abstract: The evolution of the mechanosensory cellular module and the molecular details that regulate its development has included morphological modifications of these cells as well as the formation of larger assemblies of mechanosensory cell aggregates among metazoans. This has resulted in a wide diversity of mechanosensory organs. The wide morphological diversity of organs, including the associated morphological modifications of the mechanosensory cells, suggests parallel evolution of these modules and their associated organs. This morphological diversity is in stark contrast to the molecular conservation of developmental modules across phyla. These molecular data suggest that the evolution of mechanosensory transduction might have preceded that of distinct cellular differentiation. However, once a molecular network governing development of specialized cells involved in mechanosensory transduction evolved, that molecular network was preserved across phyla. Present data suggest that at least the common ancestor of triploblastic organisms, perhaps even the common diploblastic ancestor of bilaterian metazoans, had molecular and cellular specializations for mechanosensation. It is argued that the evolution of multicellular organs dedicated to specific aspects of mechanosensation, such as gravity and sound perception, are evolutionary transformations that build on this conserved molecular network for cellular specialization, but reflect distinct morphological solutions. We propose that the sensory neurons, connecting the craniate ear with the brain, are a derived feature of craniates, and possibly chordates, that came about through diversification of the lineage forming mechanosensory cells during development. This evolutionarily late event suggests a heterochronic shift, so that sensory neurons develop in mammals prior to mechanosensory hair cells. However, sensory neuron development is connected to hair cell development, likely in a clonal relationship. The theme of cellular conservation is reiterated in two examples of chordate otic diversification: the evolution of the horizontal canal system and the evolution of the basilar papilla/cochlea. It is suggested that here again, cellular multiplication and formation of a special epithelium predates the functional transformation to an ‘organ’ system for horizontal angular acceleration and sound pressure reception, respectively. Overall, evolution of the vertebrate ear needs to be understood as an interplay between and utilization of two gene networks or modules. One is at the level of the molecularly and developmentally conserved mechanosensory cellular module. The other is an increased complexity in the morphology of both adult mechanosensory cells and organs by the addition of end-stage and novel features and associated gene networks to detect specific aspects of mechanosensory stimuli.

Lateral Line Receptors: Where Do They Come from Developmentally and Where Is Our Research Going?

Abstract: The lateral line system is composed of both mechanoreceptors, which exhibit little variation in structure between taxonomic groups, and electroreceptors, which exhibit considerably more variation. Cathodally sensitive ampullary electroreceptors are the primitive condition and are found in agnathans, chondrichthyans, and most osteichthyans. Aquatic amphibians also have ampullary electroreceptors for at least part of their life cycle. The more recently evolved anodally sensitive ampullary electroreceptors and tuberous electroreceptors are only found in four groups of teleost fishes. The basic ontogenetic unit of lateral line development is the dorsolateral placode. Primitively, there are six pairs of placodes, which pass through sequential stages of development into lateral line receptors. There is no question about the origin of primitive mechanoreceptors or electroreceptors, however, we do not have a good understanding of the origin of teleost mechanoreceptors and their ampullary or tuberous electroreceptors; do they come exclusively from dorsolateral placodes or from neural crest or even general ectoderm? A second intriguing lateral line question is how certain teleost fish groups evolved tuberous electroreceptors. Electroreception appears to have re-evolved at least twice in teleosts after being lost during the neopterygian radiation. It has been suggested that the development of tuberous electroreceptors might be due to changes in placodal patterning or a change in the general ectoderm that placodes arise from. Unfortunately, our understanding of lateral line origins in fishes is very sketchy, and, if we are to answer such an evolutionary question, we first need more complete information about lateral line development in a variety of fishes, which can then be combined with gene expression data to better interpret lateral line receptor development.

Bigger Brains or Bigger Nuclei? Regulating the Size of Auditory Structures in Birds

Abstract: Increases in the size of the neuronal structures that mediate specific behaviors are believed to be related to enhanced computational performance. It is not clear, however, what developmental and evol

The claustrum is not missing from all monotreme brains.

Abstract: Many authors have reported that the claustrum, which comprises the insular claustrum and the endopiriform nucleus, is missing from the monotreme forebrain. We used Nissl and myelin staining in conjunc

The distribution and morphological characteristics of catecholaminergic cells in the diencephalon and midbrain of the bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus).

Abstract: The present study describes the distribution and cellular morphology of catecholaminergic neurons in the diencephalon and midbrain of the bottlenose dolphin (Tursiops truncatus). Tyrosine hydroxylase immunohistochemistry was used to visualize these putatively dopaminergic neurons. The standard A1-A17, C1-C3, nomenclature is used for expediency; however, the neuroanatomical names of the various nuclei have also been given. Dolphins exhibit certain tyrosine hydroxylase immunoreactive (TH-ir) catecholaminergic neuronal groups in the midbrain (A8, A9, A10) and diencephalon (A11, A12, A14), however, no neuronal clusters clearly corresponding to the A13 and A15 groups could be identified. The subdivisions of these neuronal groups are in general agreement with those of other mammals, but there is a high degree of species specificity. First, three TH-ir neuronal groups not identified in other species were found: in the ventral lateral peri-aqueductal gray matter, posterior dorsal hypothalamus, and rostral mesencephalic raphe. Second, the normal components of the substantia nigra (A9 or pars compacta, A9 lateral or pars lateralis, A9 ventral or pars reticulata) were extremely cell sparse, but there was a substantial expansion of the A9 medial and A10 lateral subdivisions forming an impressive 'ventral wing' in the posterior substantia nigra. The findings of this and previous studies suggest a distinct evolutionary trend occurring in the neuromodulatory systems in mammals. The results are discussed in relation to motor control, thermoregulation, unihemispheric sleep, and dolphin cognition.

Transitive behavior in hippocampal-lesioned pigeons.

Abstract: The hippocampus of birds and mammals is critical for the learning of map-like memory representations of environmental space. It has been suggested that the hippocampus of rats also participates in non

Eyes: variety, development and evolution.

Abstract: The selective advantages of using light as a source of information are reflected in the diverse types of extant eyes. The physical properties of light restrict how it can be collected and processed, r

Evidence for a novel gonadotropin-releasing hormone in hypothalamic and forebrain areas in songbirds.

Abstract: One or more of three distinct forms of gonadotropin-releasing hormones (GnRHs), has been found in all vertebrates studied. Birds are known to contain two types of GnRH, chicken GnRH-I and -II (cGnRH-I and -II), but to date nobody has investigated the possibility of the presence of lamprey GnRH-III in birds. Thus, our objective was to investigate the presence and distribution of immunoreactive lamprey (ir-lamprey) GnRH-III in hypothalamic and forebrain areas in house sparrows (Passer domesticus) and Gambel's white-crowned sparrows (Zonotrichia leucophrys gambelii). In addition to its distribution in the CNS, we investigated whether or not exogenous lamprey GnRH-III peptide could elicit luteinizing hormone (LH) release in vivo. This study presents two novel findings: 1) The widespread presence in the central nervous system of an immunoreactive third GnRH in birds that is clearly hypophysiotropic and has gonadotropin-releasing capabilities. Intravenous injection of 100 ng lamprey-GnRH-III peptide elicited a rapid rise in circulating luteinizing hormone as compared to controls. This third GnRH, ir-lamprey GnRH-III, likely has multiple functions, as suggested by its widespread distribution. 2) Ir-lamprey GnRH-III is present in abundance in telencephalic areas, including the hippocampal formation and the song control system. In no vertebrate has a GnRH been localized in these 'higher' control regions before. The fact that ir-lamprey-GnRH-III is present in auditory processing areas (higher vocal center, or HVc, area X, caudomedial neostriatum) and song-producing areas (HVc, robust nucleus of the neostriatum, or RA) suggests a direct way in which auditory processing and song production can affect circulating gonadotropins.

Development of the lateral line system in the shovelnose sturgeon.

Abstract: The lateral line systems of aquatic amphibians and all chondrichthyan and osteichthyan fish present a similar array of mechanoreceptors. However, electroreceptors, the second major component of the la

A Pallial Visual Area in the Telencephalon of the Bony Fish Polypterus

Abstract: The dorsal (P2) and lateral (P3) pallial zones of bichirs receive a substantial projection from nucleus medianus of the posterior tuberculum. Although nucleus medianus does not receive a direct retinal input, its close proximity to ascending tectal efferents suggests that it might receive a tectal input and form a segment of a retinotectal-tubercular pathway to the pallium. In order to test this possibility, evoked responses to light flashes were electrophysiologically recorded and tectal efferents were experimentally determined in bichirs. These experiments suggest that a single visual field exists across the dorsal and lateral pallial zones and that this field is mediated by nucleus medianus, which does receive a direct tectal projection. This visual pathway appears to be uniquely derived and not homologous to any other known pathway in tetrapods. Furthermore, these results support the contention that the P2 and P3 pallial zones in bichirs are subdivisions of a single pallial zone.

Retinal Morphology and Electrophysiology of Two Caprimulgiformes Birds: The Cave-Living and Nocturnal Oilbird (Steatornis caripensis), and the Crepuscularly and Nocturnally Foraging Common Pauraque (Nyctidromus albicollis)

Abstract: Oilbirds (Steatornis caripensis) breed in the total darkness of caves and forage at night on fruits. Common pauraques (Nyctidromus albicollis) are crepuscular and

A possible stimulatory effect of FMRFamide on neural nitric oxide production in the central nervous system of Helix lucorum L.

Abstract: The anatomical and functional relationship between neurons expressing nitric oxide (NO) synthase and molluscan cardioexcitatory (FMRFamide)-like neuropeptides was studied in the central ganglia of <

Afferent connections of the corpus cerebelli in holocentrid teleosts.

Abstract: The holocentrid corpus cerebelli (CC) is composed of the dorsal (CCd) and ventral (CCv) lobes. In the present study, afferent connections of the CCd and CCv in holocentrid teleosts (Sargocentron rubrum and S. diadema) were examined by means of tract-tracing methods. Tracer injections into either lobe of the CC labeled neurons in the ipsilateral area pretectalis pars anterior et posterior, nucleus paracommissuralis (NPC), nucleus accessorius opticus and nucleus tegmentocerebellaris. Labeled neurons were also present in the bilateral nucleus lateralis valvulae (NLV), nucleus raphes, nucleus reticularis lateralis and inferior reticular formation, and in the contralateral inferior olive. Injections into the CCd labeled only a few neurons in the area pretectalis pars anterior et posterior, nucleus accessorius opticus and nucleus tegmentocerebellaris, whereas many labeled cells were seen in these nuclei after CCv injections. Injections into the CCv also revealed afferent connections that were not observed after CCd injections. The CCv injections labeled additional neurons in the ipsilateral torus longitudinalis and nucleus subeminentialis and in the bilateral nucleus subvalvularis and nucleus of the commissure of Wallenberg. These differences in afferent connections suggest functional differences between the CCd and CCv. After injections into the CCd, labeled neurons in the NPC were restricted to a medial portion of the nucleus. On the other hand, after injections into the CCv, labeled neurons were found throughout the NPC. Labeled neurons in the NLV were mainly located in its rostral portion following CCd injections, whereas labeled neurons were mainly distributed in the medial portion following CCv injections. These observations suggest topographical organizations of the NPC-CC and NLV-CC projections.

Oxytocin and vasopressin immunoreactivity within the forebrain and limbic-related areas in the mustached bat, Pteronotus parnellii.

Abstract: The nonapeptides, oxytocin and arginine vasopressin, play an important role in mammalian social and reproductive behavior. Using immunocytochemical procedures, we identified oxytocin-immunoreactive ne

Social Status Interacts with Badge Size and Neuroendocrine Physiology to Influence Sexual Behavior in Male House Sparrows (Passer domesticus)

Abstract: Reproduction results from a complex interplay among multiple factors including social stimuli, hormones, the brain, and an individual’s physical characteristics. Male house sparrows (Passer d

Fiber type composition of the muscle responsible for throat fan extension in green anole lizards.

Abstract: Throat fan (dewlap) extension is sexually dimorphic in green anole lizards (Anolis carolinensis) . Males have larger dewlaps which they display more frequently than females. Correlat