Q2. How can the authors interpret the results of the response surface models?
One of the main advantages of polynomial response surface models is their simplicity; they are easily fitted using least-squares methods, and they are very easy to interpret, as coefficient values can indicate the significance of a parameter (as long as input variables are normalised prior to use).
Q3. What is the first monitoring system installed at the Tamar Bridge?
The first is a Structural Monitoring System (SMS) installed by Fugro Structural Monitoring, which is used to monitor cable loads, structural and environmental temperatures and wind speed and profile.
Q4. How can a simple response surface model predict the change in the first modal frequency?
It was found that a simple response surface model with input parameters based on the estimated traffic loading, temperature and deck acceleration (in turn dependent on the wind speed and direction) can predict the change in the first modal frequency to a good degree of accuracy.
Q5. What was the effect of wind speed on the response of a long span bridge?
The response of a long span bridge to high and low wind speeds was investigated in [6], where it was concluded that the modal frequencies decreased with increased response amplitude levels directly caused by increased wind speed.
Q6. How does the frequency of the second mode change with temperature?
For the frequency that appears most sensitive to temperature (the second, which corresponds to the first lateral symmetric mode), the frequency decreases by approximately 4.5% over a 20°C change in temperature.
Q7. What is the way to predict the modal frequency of a bridge?
If the simple models used above in an attempt to better understand the bridge’s normal condition are capable of predicting the modal frequency change to a good and most importantly consistent degree, their prediction errors would be a good candidate for a damage indicator that is not affected by environmental and operational conditions.
Q8. What are the two feature parameters for each of the vertical and horizontal deck acceleration measurements?
Two feature parameters for each of the vertical and horizontal deck acceleration measurements are included; one where only acceleration values occurring when high wind speeds hitting the deck side on are recorded (zero at all other times), the other for acceleration values occurring in all other wind conditions.
Q9. What other approaches have been explored for similar problems?
Alternative approaches such as neural networks and support-vector machines have previously been explored in the literature for similar problems [12,13].
Q10. How many new cables were installed to supplement the original suspension system?
Eighteen new locked-coil cables were installed and stressed to supplement the original suspension system, primarily to help carry the additional dead load of the new cantilever lanes and associated temporary works (Figure 2).
Q11. What is the effect of adding a temperature variable on the general fit to all recorded data?
Over short time periods (as illustrated in the inset figures) the addition of a temperature variable has no visible effect, however, the general fit to all recorded data (main figures) appears to be improved, which suggests that the temperature has more of a seasonal influence than daily, for this mode at least.
Q12. Why did the model fail to perform well on the second modal frequency?
This was due, as explained previously, to the fact that large drops occur in the time history of the second modal frequency that the model cannot recreate, which are thought to be caused by traffic patterns.
Q13. What is the effect of adding a variable dependent on the wind speed on the bridge?
As the bridge is orientated east-west, the increasing response with increased wind speed occurs, not surprisingly, when the wind hits the bridge side on.
Q14. How many tonnes of traffic is on the bridge during the week?
From toll counts and web cam images, the instantaneous traffic loading on the bridge is estimated to increase by between 100 to 200 tonnes during very busy periods, which occur around 8am on weekdays.