scispace - formally typeset
Search or ask a question

Showing papers by "Jaap H. van Dieën published in 2017"


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: Patients with LBP have impaired lumbar proprioception compared with controls when measured actively in sitting positions (particularly those in the O'Sullivan flexion impairment subgroup) or via threshold to detection of passive motion (TTDPM).

108 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: It is hypothesized that changes in motor behavior in individuals with low-back pain are adaptations aimed at minimizing the real or perceived risk of further pain, which contribute to cortical reorganization and proprioceptive impairments that reduce the ability to control lumbar movement in a robust manner.
Abstract: We hypothesize that changes in motor behavior in individuals with low-back pain are adaptations aimed at minimizing the real or perceived risk of further pain. Through reinforcement learning, pain and subsequent adaptions result in less dynamic motor behavior, leading to increased loading and impoverished sensory feedback, which contributes to cortical reorganization and proprioceptive impairments that reduce the ability to control lumbar movement in a robust manner.

96 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: This cwt-based algorithm for step detection measured at the lower back is in high agreement with the optoelectronic system in both PD patients and older adults and could provide a valuable tool for future research on home-based gait analysis in these vulnerable cohorts.
Abstract: Introduction: Inertial measurement units (IMUs) positioned on various body locations allow detailed gait analysis even under unconstrained conditions. From a medical perspective, the assessment of vulnerable populations is of particular relevance, especially in the daily-life environment. Gait analysis algorithms need thorough validation, as many chronic diseases show specific and even unique gait patterns. The aim of this study was therefore to validate an acceleration-based step detection algorithm for patients with Parkinson’s disease (PD) and older adults in both a lab-based and home-like environment. Methods: In this prospective observational study, data was captured from a single 6-degrees of freedom IMU (APDM) (3-DOF accelerometer and 3-DOF gyroscope) worn on the lower back. Detection of heel strike (HS) and toe off (TO) on a treadmill was validated against an optoelectronic system (Vicon) (11 PD patients and 12 older adults). A second independent validation study in the home-like environment was performed against video observation (20 PD patients and 12 older adults) and included step counting during turning and non-turning, defined with a previously published algorithm. Results: A continuous-wavelet-transform (cwt) based algorithm was developed for step detection with very high agreement with the optoelectronic system. HS detection in PD patients/older adults, respectively, reached 99%/99% accuracy. Similar results were obtained for TO (99%/100%). In HS detection, Bland-Altman plots showed a mean difference of 0.002s (95% Confidence Interval (CI) -0.09 to 0.10) between the algorithm and the optoelectronic system. The Bland-Altman plot for TO detection showed mean differences of 0.00s (95% CI -0.12 to 0.12). In the home-like assessment, the algorithm for detection of occurrence of steps during turning reached 90% (PD patients)/90% (older adults) sensitivity, 83%/88% specificity and 88%/89% accuracy. The detection of steps during non-turning phases reached 91%/91% sensitivity, 90%/90% specificity and 91%/91% accuracy. Conclusion: This continuous-wavelet-transform based algorithm for step detection from accelerations measured at the lower back is in high agreement with the optoelectronic system in both PD patients and older adults. This approach and algorithm thus could provide a valuable tool for future research on home-based gait analysis in these vulnerable cohorts.

74 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In the present framework for optimal work-related MSD prevention, research disciplines are linked and can help to improve theories and strengthen the development and implementation of prevention strategies for work- related MSD.
Abstract: Objectives Work-related musculoskeletal disorders (MSD) are highly prevalent and put a large burden on (working) society. Primary prevention of work-related MSD focuses often on physical risk factors (such as manual lifting and awkward postures) but has not been too successful in reducing the MSD burden. This may partly be caused by insufficient knowledge of etiological mechanisms and/or a lack of adequately feasible interventions (theory failure and program failure, respectively), possibly due to limited integration of research disciplines. A research framework could link research disciplines thereby strengthening the development and implementation of preventive interventions. Our objective was to define and describe such a framework for multi-disciplinary research on work-related MSD prevention. Methods We described a framework for MSD prevention research, partly based on frameworks from other research fields (ie, sports injury prevention and public health). Results The framework is composed of a repeated sequence of six steps comprising the assessment of (i) incidence and severity of MSD, (ii) risk factors for MSD, and (iii) underlying mechanisms; and the (iv) development, (v) evaluation, and (vi) implementation of preventive intervention(s). Conclusions In the present framework for optimal work-related MSD prevention, research disciplines are linked. This framework can thereby help to improve theories and strengthen the development and implementation of prevention strategies for work-related MSD.

66 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: The results of this study can be used by clinicians to identify and monitor potential fallers in MS patients and considering the area under the curves (AUCs), PROs were more accurate compared to PBMs.
Abstract: Background Accurate fall screening tools are needed to identify those multiple sclerosis (MS) patients at high risk of falling. The present study aimed at determining the validity of a series of performance-based measures (PBMs) of lower extremity functions and patient-reported outcomes (PROs) in predicting falls in a sample of MS patients (n = 84), who were ambulatory independent. Methods Patients were assessed using the following PBMs: timed up and go (TUG), timed 25-foot walk (T25FW), cognitive T25FW, 2-min walk (2MW), and cognitive 2MW. Moreover, a series of valid and reliable PROs were filled in by participants including the activities-specific balance confidence (ABC), 12-item multiple sclerosis walking scale (MSWS-12), fall efficacy scale international (FES-I), and modified fatigue impact scale (MFIS). The dual task cost (DTC) of 2MW and T25FW tests were calculated as a percentage of change in parameters from single to dual task conditions. Participants were classified as none-fallers and fallers (⩾1) based on their prospective fall occurrence. Results In the present study, 41(49%) participants recorded ≥ 1 fall and were classified as fallers. The results of logistic regression analysis revealed that each individual test, except DTC of 2MW and T25FW, significantly predicted future falls. However, considering the area under the curves (AUCs), PROs were more accurate compared to PBMs. In addition, the results of multiple logistic regression with the first two factors extracted from principal component analysis revealed that both factor 1 (PROs) and factor 2 (PBMs) significantly predicted falls with a greater odds ratio (OR) for factor 1 (factor 1: P = Conclusions The results of this study can be used by clinicians to identify and monitor potential fallers in MS patients.

47 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: The meta-analysis results are in line with motor unit loss as the main cause of the effect of ageing on force steadiness and this effect can partially explain decreased motor performance associated with ageing.

38 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: Independent of the type of gait assessment, qualitative gait characteristics are better fall predictors than clinical assessments, and Clinicians should consider gait analyses as an alternative for identifying fall-prone stroke survivors.
Abstract: Objective: This exploratory study investigated to what extent gait characteristics and clinical physical therapy assessments predict falls in chronic stroke survivors. Design: Prospective study. Subjects: Chronic fall-prone and non-fall-prone stroke survivors. Methods: Steady-state gait characteristics were collected from 40 participants while walking on a treadmill with motion capture of spatio-temporal, variability, and stability measures. An accelerometer was used to collect daily-life gait characteristics during 7 days. Six physical and psychological assessments were administered. Fall events were determined using a “fall calendar” and monthly phone calls over a 6-month period. After data reduction through principal component analysis, the predictive capacity of each method was determined by logistic regression. Results: Thirty-eight percent of the participants were classified as fallers. Laboratory-based and daily-life gait characteristics predicted falls acceptably well, with an area under the curve of, 0.73 and 0.72, respectively, while fall predictions from clinical assessments were limited (0.64). Conclusion: Independent of the type of gait assessment, qualitative gait characteristics are better fall predictors than clinical assessments. Clinicians should therefore consider gait analyses as an alternative for identifying fall-prone stroke survivors.

31 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: This wearable sensor- and relative orientation-based algorithm yields very high agreement with clinical observation for the detection and evaluation of ≥90° turns under non-standardized conditions in PD patients and older adults and can be suggested for the assessment of turning in daily life.
Abstract: Introduction: Aging and age-associated disorders such as Parkinson’s disease (PD) are often associated with turning difficulties, which can lead to falls and fractures. Valid assessment of turning and turning deficits specifically in non-standardized environments may foster specific treatment and prevention of consequences. Methods: Relative orientation, obtained from 3D-accelerometer and 3D-gyroscope data of a sensor worn at the lower back, was used to develop an algorithm for turning detection and qualitative analysis in PD patients and controls in non-standardized environments. The algorithm was validated with a total of 2304 turns ≥90° extracted from an independent dataset of 20 PD patients during medication ON- and OFF-conditions, and 13 older adults. Video observation by two independent clinical observers served as gold standard. Results: In PD patients under medication OFF, the algorithm detected turns with a sensitivity of 0.92, a specificity of 0.89, and an accuracy of 0.92. During medication ON, values were 0.92, 0.78 and 0.83. In older adults, the algorithm reached validation values of 0.94, 0.89 and 0.92. Turning magnitude (difference, 0.06°; standard error of the mean (SEM) 0.14°) and duration (difference, 0.004s; SEM, 0.005s) yielded high correlation values with gold standard. Overall accuracy for direction of turning was 0.995. Intra class correlation of the clinical observers was 0.92. Conclusion: This wearable sensor- and relative orientation-based algorithm yields very high agreement with clinical observation for the detection and evaluation of ≥90° turns under non-standardized conditions in PD patients and older adults. It can be suggested for the assessment of turning in daily-life.

25 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: The coordination of joints motions, as reported here, can serve as a guideline for drag flick training and coaches should emphasise trunk rotations and wrist flexion and extension movements for maximising stick head speed.
Abstract: Attaining high speed of the stick head and consequently of the ball is essential for successful performance of the drag flick in field hockey, but the coordination pattern used to maximise stick head speed is unknown. The kinematics of the drag flick was studied in ten elite hockey players who performed twenty shots each towards a target located 1.5 m high. A 150 Hz active marker motion analysis system was used, alongside two force plates to detect foot touchdown. Angular velocity and contribution to stick endpoint speed of upper body joints were analysed. Repeated measures ANOVA was used to compare timing of onset and peak angular velocities between joints. Participants used a kinematic pattern that was close to a proximal-to-distal sequence. Trunk axial rotation and lateral rotation towards the target, right wrist flexion and left wrist extension were the main contributors to stick endpoint speed. Coaches should emphasise trunk rotations and wrist flexion and extension movements for maximising stick head speed. Given the high level of the participants in this study, the coordination of joints motions, as reported here, can serve as a guideline for drag flick training.

25 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
23 Oct 2017-PLOS ONE
TL;DR: It is concluded that over the speed range tested, inexperienced runners may not need to adapt their SF to running speed, since SFself were lower than the SFopt of 83 strides·min-1, the runners could reduce HR by increasing their SFself.
Abstract: During running at a constant speed, the optimal stride frequency (SF) can be derived from the u-shaped relationship between SF and heart rate (HR). Changing SF towards the optimum of this relationship is beneficial for energy expenditure and may positively change biomechanics of running. In the current study, the effects of speed on the optimal SF and the nature of the u-shaped relation were empirically tested using Generalized Estimating Equations. To this end, HR was recorded from twelve healthy (4 males, 8 females) inexperienced runners, who completed runs at three speeds. The three speeds were 90%, 100% and 110% of self-selected speed. A self-selected SF (SFself) was determined for each of the speeds prior to the speed series. The speed series started with a free-chosen SF condition, followed by five imposed SF conditions (SFself, 70, 80, 90, 100 strides·min-1) assigned in random order. The conditions lasted 3 minutes with 2.5 minutes of walking in between. SFself increased significantly (p<0.05) with speed with averages of 77, 79, 80 strides·min-1 at 2.4, 2.6, 2.9 m·s-1, respectively). As expected, the relation between SF and HR could be described by a parabolic curve for all speeds. Speed did not significantly affect the curvature, nor did it affect optimal SF. We conclude that over the speed range tested, inexperienced runners may not need to adapt their SF to running speed. However, since SFself were lower than the SFopt of 83 strides·min-1, the runners could reduce HR by increasing their SFself.

23 citations


Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: While reasonable moment estimates can be obtained with 6 sensors, omitting the forearm sensors led to unacceptable errors, and vertical GRF information is sufficient to estimate L5S1 moments in lifting.

Book ChapterDOI
01 Jan 2017
TL;DR: The SPEXOR project will design a novel spinal exoskeleton to prevent low-back pain in able bodied workers and to support workers with low- back pain in vocational rehabilitation.
Abstract: Most assistive robotic devices are exoskeletons which assist or augment the motion of the limbs and neglect the role of the spinal column in transferring load from the upper body and arms to the legs. In the SPEXOR project we will fill this gap and design a novel spinal exoskeleton to prevent low-back pain in able bodied workers and to support workers with low-back pain in vocational rehabilitation.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: Direct quantification of the degree of misjudgment provides insight in the interplay between cognition and physical abilities and can be of added value towards prevention of falls and promotion of healthy ageing.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: Although stability was different between groups during a ipsilateral perturbation, it was caused by a secondary strategy to keep up with the belt speed, contrary to the hypothesis fallers group of stroke survivors have a preserved ability to cope with external gait perturbations as compared to non fallers.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: Differences in anatomy, morphology and neural drive between rat ankle plantar-flexors cause substantial intermuscular displacement during locomotion, which may affect mechanical interactions between muscle bellies and tendons.
Abstract: The functional consequences of differential muscle activation and contractile behavior between mechanically coupled synergists are still poorly understood. Even though synergistic muscles exert similar mechanical effects at the joint they span, differences in the anatomy, morphology and neural drive may lead to non-uniform contractile conditions. This study aimed to investigate the patterns of activation and contractile behavior of triceps surae muscles, to understand how these contribute to the relative displacement between the one-joint soleus (SO) and two-joint lateral gastrocnemius (LG) muscle bellies and their distal tendons during locomotion in the rat. In seven rats, muscle belly lengths and muscle activation during level and upslope trotting were measured by sonomicrometry crystals and electromyographic electrodes chronically implanted in the SO and LG. Length changes of muscle-tendon units (MTUs) and tendon fascicles were estimated based on joint kinematics and muscle belly lengths. Distances between implanted crystals were further used to assess longitudinal and transversal deformations of the intermuscular volume between the SO and LG. For both slope conditions, we observed differential timing of muscle activation as well as substantial differences in contraction speeds between muscle bellies (maximal relative speed 55.9 mm s-1). Muscle lengths and velocities did not differ significantly between level and upslope locomotion, only EMG amplitude of the LG was affected by slope. Relative displacements between SO and LG MTUs were found in both longitudinal and transversal directions, yielding an estimated maximal length change difference of 2.0 mm between their distal tendons. Such relative displacements may have implications for the force exchanged via intermuscular and intertendinous pathways.

01 Apr 2017
TL;DR: In this paper, a wearable sensor and relative orientation-based algorithm was proposed for detecting and evaluating ≥90° turning in Parkinson's disease patients and older adults in non-standardized environments.
Abstract: Introduction Aging and age-associated disorders such as Parkinson’s disease (PD) are often associated with turning difficulties, which can lead to falls and fractures. Valid assessment of turning and turning deficits specifically in non-standardized environments may foster specific treatment and prevention of consequences. Methods Relative orientation, obtained from 3D-accelerometer and 3D-gyroscope data of a sensor worn at the lower back, was used to develop an algorithm for turning detection and qualitative analysis in PD patients and controls in non-standardized environments. The algorithm was validated with a total of 2,304 turns ≥90° extracted from an independent dataset of 20 PD patients during medication ON- and OFF-conditions and 13 older adults. Video observation by two independent clinical observers served as gold standard. Results In PD patients under medication OFF, the algorithm detected turns with a sensitivity of 0.92, a specificity of 0.89, and an accuracy of 0.92. During medication ON, values were 0.92, 0.78, and 0.83. In older adults, the algorithm reached validation values of 0.94, 0.89, and 0.92. Turning magnitude (difference, 0.06°; SEM, 0.14°) and duration (difference, 0.004 s; SEM, 0.005 s) yielded high correlation values with gold standard. Overall accuracy for direction of turning was 0.995. Intra class correlation of the clinical observers was 0.92. Conclusion This wearable sensor- and relative orientation-based algorithm yields very high agreement with clinical observation for the detection and evaluation of ≥90° turns under non-standardized conditions in PD patients and older adults. It can be suggested for the assessment of turning in daily life.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: Assessment of coupled motions in multiple spine sections in vitro, before and after removal of posterior elements indicates that coupled motions were largest in the lumbar spine.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: Intrinsic stiffness and damping and muscle spindle feedback and intrinsic mechanical properties are sufficient to describe trunk stabilization in the sagittal plane under small mechanical perturbations, provided that muscle spindles encode acceleration in addition to velocity and position information.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: Fractional stability provided an improved fit of d(t) compared to exponential stability when applied to trunk accelerations during daily-life walking in community-dwelling older adults and may pave the way for a more unified concept of gait stability.
Abstract: Over the last decades, various measures have been introduced to assess stability during walking. All of these measures assume that gait stability may be equated with exponential stability, where dynamic stability is quantified by a Floquet multiplier or Lyapunov exponent. These specific constructs of dynamic stability assume that the gait dynamics are time independent and without phase transitions. In this case the temporal change in distance, d(t), between neighboring trajectories in state space is assumed to be an exponential function of time. However, results from walking models and empirical studies show that the assumptions of exponential stability break down in the vicinity of phase transitions that are present in each step cycle. Here we apply a general non-exponential construct of gait stability, called fractional stability, which can define dynamic stability in the presence of phase transitions. Fractional stability employs the fractional indices, α and β, of differential operator which allow modeling of singularities in d(t) that cannot be captured by exponential stability. The fractional stability provided an improved fit of d(t) compared to exponential stability when applied to trunk accelerations during daily-life walking in community-dwelling older adults. Moreover, using multivariate empirical mode decomposition surrogates, we found that the singularities in d(t), which were well modeled by fractional stability, are created by phase-dependent modulation of gait. The new construct of fractional stability may represent a physiologically more valid concept of stability in vicinity of phase transitions and may thus pave the way for a more unified concept of gait stability.

Journal ArticleDOI
21 Dec 2017-PLOS ONE
TL;DR: The degree of misjudgment in young and older adults on four different stepping tasks met the criteria for validly assessing one’s misjudgement, but it remains unclear whether the degree ofMisjudgment is task-specific or an inherent trait.
Abstract: Disparities between perceived and actual physical abilities have been shown in older adults and may lead to balance loss or falls. However, it is unclear whether one’s misjudgment is an inherent trait and thus consistent across different tasks, and whether this misjudgment is age-related. We measured the degree of misjudgment in young and older adults on four different stepping tasks; stepping over a raised bar, crossing a declining cord by stepping over it at a self-selected height, crossing a virtual river by stepping over it at a self-selected width, and making a recovery step after release from an inclined position. Before comparison, we carefully checked the validity of the different tasks to determine the misjudgment. No substantial differences were found in the amplitude of the misjudgment between the age groups, and the degree of misjudgment did not transfer across different stepping tasks. However, since only one task (i.e., stepping over a raised bar) met our criteria for validly assessing one’s misjudgment, it remains unclear whether the degree of misjudgment is task-specific or an inherent trait. These findings stress the importance of testing the construct validity of the task, prior to the examination of the misjudgment of stepping ability.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: In patients with knee osteoarthritis, relationships between muscle strength and activity limitations are non-linear and patients with muscle strength below the described thresholds might benefit more from muscle strength training to reduce limitations in daily activities than would patients with Muscle strength above the thresholds.
Abstract: Objective To investigate whether relationships between upper leg muscle strength and activity limitations are non-linear in patients with knee osteoarthritis, and, if so, to determine muscle strength thresholds for limitations in daily activities. Design Baseline data were used for 562 patients with knee osteoarthritis in the Amsterdam-Osteoarthritis cohort. Upper leg muscle strength (Nm/kg) was measured isokinetically. Activity limitations were measured with the timed Get Up and Go test and timed Stair Climb Test, subdivided into stair-ascent and stair-descent. Linear and non-linear relationships between muscle strength and activity limitations were evaluated, and thresholds were determined. Results Non-linear models improved model fit compared with linear models. The improvement in percentage variance accounted for was 5.9, 8.2 and 5.2 percentage points for the timed Get Up and Go, stair-ascent and stair-descent times, respectively. Muscle strength thresholds were 0.93 Nm/kg (95% confidence interval (95% CI) 0.82-1.04), 0.89 Nm/kg (95% CI 0.77-1.02) and 0.97 Nm/kg (95% CI 0.85-1.11) for relationships with timed Get Up and Go, stair-ascent and stair-descent times, respectively. Conclusion In patients with knee osteoarthritis, relationships between muscle strength and activity limitations are non-linear. Patients with muscle strength below the described thresholds might benefit more from muscle strength training to reduce limitations in daily activities than would patients with muscle strength above the thresholds. Further research is needed to assess the clinical value of the thresholds determined.

Book ChapterDOI
07 Feb 2017
TL;DR: Methods based on questionnaires, functional tests of posture and movement, and advanced methods that quantify the ability to control or regain balance or the performance of specific subsystems of the balance control system are available to test balance control in older adults.
Abstract: To avoid falls during everyday movements, we need to maintain balance, i.e., control the position of our body’s center of mass relative to our base of support. The balance control system comprises sensory subsystems, their afferent nerves, an extensive brain network, and the motor system. Physiological aging of each of these subsystems may limit our ability to control balance in standing and walking. Methods based on questionnaires, functional tests of posture and movement, and advanced methods that quantify the ability to control or regain balance or the performance of specific subsystems of the balance control system are available to test balance control in older adults.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: The observed shift in activity toward the gastrocnemius muscles after the intervention suggests that these larger muscles are preferentially recruited when the soleus has a similar mechanical disadvantage in that it produces an unwanted flexion moment around the knee.
Abstract: Connective tissue linkages between muscle-tendon units may act as an additional mechanical constraint on the musculoskeletal system, thereby reducing the spectrum of solutions for performing a moto...

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: Whether obstacle crossing characteristics are reliable and assessed differences in stroke survivors who prospectively experienced falls or no falls cast some doubt on current protocols for testing and training of obstacle avoidance in stroke rehabilitation.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: The objective was to establish an experimental procedure and show direct results that unequivocally can be assigned as well as provide a level of confidence that the procedure can be trusted to be reliable and effective.

Journal ArticleDOI
TL;DR: The topic of the letter ‘‘On Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Intervertebral Disc Ageing’’ is peripheral to the review on exercise and the intervertebrate disc (IVD), and magnetic resonance imaging approaches for quantifying the IVD in studies of the effect of exercise on theIVD are aimed to communicate.
Abstract: Thank you for forwarding the letter from Dr. Wang regarding our recent publication [1] in Sports Medicine. It is nice to know that the article is generating interest. While we agree with most of the comments by Dr. Wang, the topic of the letter ‘‘On Magnetic Resonance Imaging of Intervertebral Disc Ageing’’ is peripheral to the review we wrote on exercise and the intervertebral disc (IVD). For example, while we know clinically that some people can have IVD degeneration in their 20s, this is not directly relevant to the point we were trying to get across: namely that perhaps there is a ‘‘critical period’’ in human development for the IVD in terms of when loading and exercise can have the greatest impact on lifetime IVD properties. If there is a ‘‘critical period’’ in ageing for the IVD, such as is considered [2] to be the case for bone tissue, then the exact age span still needs to be narrowed down. Furthermore, it is known [3] that vertebral body bone properties are related to IVD properties. In drafting the review, owing to the limited data in the literature on this particular point, we did not consider this issue to be currently of high priority to the topic of IVD and exercise. In another review [4] on the topic of IVD herniations in astronauts, some of my colleagues in the team suggested vertebral body bone loss during spaceflight as a potential explanation for increased IVD hydration after spaceflight and also for persistent changes in the IVD after prolonged bed rest [5]. In that particular area, it is therefore very relevant to consider vertebral bone properties. Vertebral body bone material properties (not to mention other factors such as bone marrow fat and end-plate properties, amongst other issues) will have an impact on forces transmitted to the IVD. However, owing to the paucity of data in the literature, it is currently too speculative to discuss how this might influence exercise protocols for training the IVD. Dr. Wang mentions other radiological grading schemes. We aimed to communicate magnetic resonance imaging approaches for quantifying the IVD in studies of the effect of exercise on the IVD. Our comments on grading schemes—as they apply to quantification of the IVD for studies of the effect of exercise on the IVD—apply to all grading schemes. Just the same as the standard Pfirrmann grading scheme, an eight-level modified Pfirrmann grading scheme, or a scheme including the end-plate, will be of similar limited sensitivity for use in a small sample size exercise (intervention) study. If one were to use a grading scheme as the primary outcome measure of an IVD and exercise study, then the sample size would need to be very large. One example is the cross-sectional study by Hangai et al. [6] on athletic populations and IVD degeneration where the authors had approximately 60 subjects in each group. Hence, we advise other researchers to use other approaches in studies of the effect of exercise on the IVD. Dr. Wang mentions T1rho as a method of interest for measurement of the IVD, after stating that ‘‘caution should & Daniel L. Belavý belavy@gmail.com