Boundary layer turbulence and freestream turbulence interface, turbulent spot and freestream turbulence interface, laminar boundary layer and freestream turbulence interface

TLDR: In this paper, the boundary-layer turbulence and freestream turbulence interface (BTFTI), the turbulent spot and free-stream turbulence interfaces (TSFTI) and the laminar boundary layer and free stream turbulence interface were modeled using direct simulation.

Abstract: We study the boundary-layer turbulence and freestream turbulence interface (BTFTI), the turbulent spot and freestream turbulence interface (TSFTI), and the laminar boundary-layer and freestream turbulence interface (LBFTI) using direct simulation. Grid spacings in the freestream are less than 1 Kolmogorov length scale during transition. Probability density functions of temperature and its derivatives are used to select the interface identification threshold, corroborated by a vorticity-based method. The interfaces so detected are confirmed to be physical a posteriori by the distinctive quasi-step-jump behavior in the swirling strength and temperature statistics along traverses normal to the BTFTI and TSFTI. No interface-normal inflection is detected across the LBFTI for either swirling strength, temperature, vorticity magnitude, Reynolds shear stress, streamwise velocity, normal velocity, or turbulence kinetic energy. The present direct numerical simulation data thus cast serious doubts on the shear-sheltering hypothesis/theory, which asserts that a subset of freestream fluctuations is blocked by the LBFTI. In the early stage of transition, quasi-spanwise structures exist on the LBFTI. The TSFTI shape is dominated by head prints of concentrated hairpin vortices. Further downstream, the BTFTI geometry is strongly modulated by groves of hairpin vortices (the boundary layer large-scale motions) with a distinct streamwise preferential orientation. Streamwise velocity and turbulence kinetic energy only exhibit minor plateaus (rather than quasi-step-jump) across the BTFTI and the TSFTI. We emphasize that it is more meaningful and important to acquire reproducible and reliable interface-normal statistics prior to considering any plausible substructures and elusive transient dynamics of the BTFTI, TSFTI, and LBFTI.