Earth's first stable continents did not form by subduction

TLDR: Johnson et al. as discussed by the authors performed phase equilibria modelling of the Coucal basalts from Western Australia and confirmed their suitability as parent rocks of the early continental crust of the Earth's first continents.

Abstract: Phase equilibria modelling of rocks from Western Australia confirms that the ancient continental crust could have formed by multistage melting of basaltic ‘parents’ along high geothermal gradients—a process incompatible with modern-style subduction Tim Johnson et al perform phase equilibria modelling of the Coucal basalts from Western Australia and confirm their suitability as parent rocks of the Archaean continental crust The authors suggest that these early crustal rocks were produced by 20–30 per cent melting along high geothermal gradients They conclude that the production and stabilization of the first continents required a protracted, multistage process When coupled with the high geothermal gradients, this suggests that the continents did not form by subduction Instead it favours a 'stagnant lid' regime in the early Archaean eon in which a single, rigid plate lay over the mantle The geodynamic environment in which Earth’s first continents formed and were stabilized remains controversial1 Most exposed continental crust that can be dated back to the Archaean eon (4 billion to 25 billion years ago) comprises tonalite–trondhjemite–granodiorite rocks (TTGs) that were formed through partial melting of hydrated low-magnesium basaltic rocks2; notably, these TTGs have ‘arc-like’ signatures of trace elements and thus resemble the continental crust produced in modern subduction settings3 In the East Pilbara Terrane, Western Australia, low-magnesium basalts of the Coucal Formation at the base of the Pilbara Supergroup have trace-element compositions that are consistent with these being source rocks for TTGs These basalts may be the remnants of a thick (more than 35 kilometres thick), ancient (more than 35 billion years old) basaltic crust4,5 that is predicted to have existed if Archaean mantle temperatures were much hotter than today’s6,7,8 Here, using phase equilibria modelling of the Coucal basalts, we confirm their suitability as TTG ‘parents’, and suggest that TTGs were produced by around 20 per cent to 30 per cent melting of the Coucal basalts along high geothermal gradients (of more than 700 degrees Celsius per gigapascal) We also analyse the trace-element composition of the Coucal basalts, and propose that these rocks were themselves derived from an earlier generation of high-magnesium basaltic rocks, suggesting that the arc-like signature in Archaean TTGs was inherited from an ancestral source lineage This protracted, multistage process for the production and stabilization of the first continents—coupled with the high geothermal gradients—is incompatible with modern-style plate tectonics, and favours instead the formation of TTGs near the base of thick, plateau-like basaltic crust9 Thus subduction was not required to produce TTGs in the early Archaean eon