What do civil society organisations expect from participation in science? Lessons from Germany and Spain on the issue of GMOs

TLDR: In this article, the authors present two case studies of civil society participation in the field of novel biotechnologies in Germany and in Spain, showing that current institutional approaches, which are inspired by the "democratization of expertise" perspective and set up essentially at the "downstream" level, seem less promising than "upstream" models of participation, which, in contrast, appear more meaningful from a "co-production of science" framing.

Abstract: Recent debates in science and technology studies, as well as more practical approaches to science policy both at national and European level, have stressed the relevance of citizen participation in the field of science. This paper investigates what some of the key actors in this debate, civil society organisations, expect from participation. The paper presents two case studies of civil society participation in the field of novel biotechnologies in Germany and in Spain. Despite the differences between the experiences of participation in these two countries, our study shows that current institutional approaches, which are inspired by the ‘democratisation of expertise’ perspective and set up essentially at the ‘downstream’ level, seem less promising than ‘upstream’ models of participation, which, in contrast, appear more meaningful from a ‘co-production of science’ framing.