Journal ArticleDOI
Cardiovascular safety of sulfonylureas: a meta-analysis of randomized clinical trials.
Reads0
Chats0
TLDR
Cardiovascular safety of sulfonylurea has been questioned by some authors and all available data on this issue from randomized trials is collected.Abstract:
Aim
Cardiovascular safety of sulfonylurea has been questioned by some authors. This article aims at collecting all available data on this issue from randomized trials.
Methods
A meta-analysis was performed including all trials with a duration of at least 6 months, comparing a sulfonylurea with a non-sulfonylurea agent in type 2 diabetes. Major cardiovascular events (MACE) and mortality were retrieved and combined to calculate Mantel-Haenzel odds ratio (MH-OR).
Results
Of the 115 selected trials, 62 reported information on MACE, and 30 reported at least one event. MH-OR for sulfonylurea was 1.08 [0.86–1.36], p = 0.52 (1.85 [1.20–2.87], p = 0.005, in the five trials vs. DPP4 inhibitors, no significant differences vs. other comparators). The MH-OR for myocardial infarction and stroke was 0.88 [0.75–1.04], p = 0.13 and 1.28 [1.03–1.60], p = 0.026, respectively. Mortality was significantly increased with sulfonylureas (MH-OR: 1.22 [1.01–1.49], p = 0.047).
Conclusions
In type 2 diabetes, the use of sulfonylureas is associated with increased mortality and a higher risk of stroke, whereas the overall incidence of MACE appears to be unaffected. Significant differences in cardiovascular risk could be present in direct comparisons with specific classes of glucose-lowering agents, such as DPP4 inhibitors, but this hypothesis needs to be confirmed in long-term cardiovascular outcomes trials. The results of this meta-analysis need to be interpreted with caution, mainly because of limitations in trial quality and under-reporting of information on cardiovascular events and mortality. However, the cardiovascular safety of sulfonylureas cannot be considered established unless it is evaluated in long-term cardiovascular outcomes trials.read more
Citations
More filters
Journal Article
Securite cardiovasculairedes inhibiteurs de la DPP-4 compareea celle des sulfamides hypoglycemiants.
Journal ArticleDOI
Avandia: Cardiovascular Safety Concern Remains
TL;DR: Avandia has been successfully used to achieve glycemic control in a manner that is at least as effective as sulfonylureas and metformin and attenuates the development of atherosclerosis.
Book ChapterDOI
Plant Alkaloids with Antidiabetic Potential
TL;DR: In this article, the potential pharmaceutical properties of plant alkaloids in the treatment/prevention of type-2 diabetes mellitus and its comorbidities were comprehensively reviewed.
Journal ArticleDOI
Correction to: “Cardiovascular Outcomes Comparison of Dipeptidyl Peptidase-4 Inhibitors Versus Sulfonylurea as Add-on Therapy for Type 2 Diabetes Mellitus: A Meta-Analysis”
TL;DR: As add-on therapies to metformin, SUs and DPP4 inhibitors showed no significant differences in all-cause mortality and cardiovascular mortality, however, some of the favorable results of D PP4 inhibitors suggest good safety and feasibility of the drugs.
Journal ArticleDOI
Enfoque terapéutico de la diabetes mellitus tipo 2 en adultos. Más allá de una meta glucémica
TL;DR: In this paper, the authors discuss the importance of cardiovascular risk in people with Type 2 diabetes mellitus and therapeutic options that have an impact on this risk and discuss new therapeutic targets for the treatment of this entity, with the development of molecules that have demonstrated acceptable glycemic control as well as cardiovascular safety; some have even been shown to decrease cardiovascular risk.
References
More filters
Journal ArticleDOI
Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test
TL;DR: Funnel plots, plots of the trials' effect estimates against sample size, are skewed and asymmetrical in the presence of publication bias and other biases Funnel plot asymmetry, measured by regression analysis, predicts discordance of results when meta-analyses are compared with single large trials.
Journal ArticleDOI
Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement
TL;DR: A structured summary is provided including, as applicable, background, objectives, data sources, study eligibility criteria, participants, interventions, study appraisal and synthesis methods, results, limitations, conclusions and implications of key findings.
Journal ArticleDOI
Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses: The PRISMA Statement
TL;DR: PRISMA (Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses) is introduced, an update of the QUOROM guidelines for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses.
Journal Article
Intensive blood-glucose control with sulphonylureas or insulin compared with conventional treatment and risk of complications in patients with type 2 diabetes (UKPDS 33)
R C Turner,Rury R. Holman,Carole A. Cull,Irene M Stratton,David R Matthews,V Frighi,Susan E. Manley,Andrew Neil,K McElroy,D Wright,E. M. Kohner,Caroline S. Fox,D R Hadden,Z Mehta,Albert V. Smith,Z Nugent,Richard Peto,A I Adlel,Jim Mann,P A Bassett,S. Oakes,Tim Dornan,Stephen J Aldington,H Lipinski,R Collum,K Harrison,C MacIntyre,S Skinner,A Mortemore,D Nelson,S Cockley,S Levien,L Bodsworth,R Willox,T Biggs,S Dove,E Beattie,M Gradwell,S Staples,R Lam,F Taylor,L Leung,R D Carter,S M Brownlee,K E Fisher,K Islam,R. Jelfs,P A Williams,F A Williams,P J Sutton,A Ayres,Lisa Logie,C Lovatt,M A Evans,L A Stowell,I Ross,I A Kennedy,D. J. Croft,A H Keen,C Rose,M Raikou,A E Fletcher,Christopher J. Bulpitt,Clare Battersby,J S Yudkin,Richard Stevens,M R Stearn,S L Palmer,M S Hammersley,S L Franklin,R S Spivey,Jonathan C. Levy,C R Tidy,N J Bell,J Steemson,B A Barrow,R Coster,K Waring,L Nolan,E Truscott,N Walravens,L Cook,H Lampard,C Merle,P Parker,J McVittie,I Draisey,L E Murchison,Brunt Ahe.,M J Williams,D W Pearson,Petrie Xmp.,Lean Mej.,D Walmsley,F Lyall,E Christie,J Church,E Thomson,A Farrow,J M Stowers,M Stowers,K McHardy,N Patterson,Alex D. Wright,N A Levi,Shearer Aci.,Thompson Rjw.,G Taylor,S Rayton,M Bradbury,A Glover,A Smyth-Osbourne,C Parkes,J Graham,P England,S Gyde,C Eagle,B Chakrabarti,Josh Smith,J Sherwell,N. W. Oakley,M. Whitehead,G P Hollier,T. Pilkington,J Simpson,Michael W. Anderson,S Martin,J Kean,B Rice,A Rolland,J Nisbet,E M Kohner,A Dornhorst,M C Doddridge,M Dumskyij,S Walji,P Sharp,M Sleightholm,G Vanterpool,G Frost,M Roseblade,S Elliott,S Forrester,Meredith C. Foster,K Myers,R Chapman,J R Hayes,R W Henry,M S Featherston,Archbold Gpr.,M Copeland,R Harper,I Richardson,H A Davison,L Alexander,Scarpello Jhb.,D E Shiers,R J Tucker,Worthington Jrh.,S Angris,A Bates,J Walton,M Teasdale,J Browne,S Stanley,B A Davis,R C Strange,Hadden,L Kennedy,A B Atkinson,P M Bell,D R McCance,J Rutherford,A M Culbert,C Hegan,H Tennet,N Webb,I Robinson,J Holmes,S Nesbitt,A S Spathis,S Hyer,M E Nanson,L M James,J M Tyrell,C Davis,P Strugnell,M Booth,H Petrie,D Clark,S Hulland,J L Barron,B C Gould,J Singer,A Badenoch,M McGregor,L Isenberg,M Eckert,K Alibhai,E Marriot,Christopher E. Cox,R Price,M Fernandez,A Ryle,S Clarke,G Wallace,E Mehmed,J A Lankester,E Howard,A Waite,S MacFarlane,R H Greenwood,J Wilson,M J Denholm,R C Temple,K Whitfield,F Johnson,C Munroe,S Gorick,E Duckworth,M Fatman,S Rainbow,L J Borthwick,D J Wheatcroft,R J Seaman,R A Christie,W Wheatcroft,P Musk,Jennifer White,S McDougal,M Bond,P Raniga,J L Day,M J Doshi,James G. Wilson,J. Howard-Williams,H Humphreys,A Graham,K Hicks,S Hexman,P Bayliss,D Pledger,R W Newton,R T Jung,C Roxburgh,B Kilgallon,L Dick,N Waugh,S Kilby,A Ellingford,J Burns,C Fox,M C Holloway,H M Coghill,N Hein,A J Fox,W Cowan,M Richard,K Quested,S J Evans,Richard B Paisey,Brown Npr.,A J Tucker,R Paisey,F Garrett,J Hogg,P Park,K Williams,P Harvey,R Wilcocks,S Mason,J. C. Frost,C Warren,P Rocket,L Bower,J M Roland,D J Brown,J Youens,K Stanton-King,H Mungall,V Ball,W Maddison,D Donnelly,S King,P Griffin,Sidney C. Smith,S Church,Graham Dunn,Andrew D. Wilson,K Palmer,P M Brown,D Humphriss,Davidson Ajm.,Richard Rose,L Armistead,S Townsend,P Poon,Peacock Ida.,Culverwell Njc.,M H Charlton,Connolly Bps.,J Peacock,J Barrett,J Wain,W Beeston,George L. King,P G Hill,Boulton Ajm.,A M Robertson,V Katoulis,A Olukoga,H McDonald,S Kumar,F Abouaesha,B Abuaisha,E A Knowles,S Higgins,J Booker,J Sunter,K Breislin,R Parker,P Raval,J Curwell,H Davenport,G Shawcross,A Prest,J Grey,H Cole,C Sereviratne,R J Young,J R Clyne,M Gibson,I O'Connell,L M Wong,S J Wilson,K L Wright,Chris Wallace,D McDowell,A C Burden,E M Sellen,R Gregory,M Roshan,N Vaghela,M Burden,C Sherriff,S Mansingh,J Clarke,J Grenfell,Je Tooke,K. M. MacLeod,C Seamark,M Rammell,C Pym,J Stockman,C Yeo,J Piper,L Leighton,Ellen Green,M Hoyle,K Jones,A Hudson,A J James,Angela C. Shore,A Higham,B Martin,Neil Haw.,Butterfield Wjh.,Doll Wrs.,R Eastman,F R Ferris,N Kurinij,K McPherson,R F Mahler,Tom W. Meade,G Shafer,P J Watkins,H Keen,D Siegel,D J Betteridge,R D Cohen,D Currie,Julie L Darbyshire,J V Forrester,T Guppy,D G Johnston,Alistair McGuire,Mike Murphy,A M el-Nahas,B Pentecost,D Spiegelhalter,Alberti Kgmm.,R Denton,Philip Home,S Howell,Jarrett,V Marks,Michael Marmot,J D Ward,Grp Ukpds. +398 more
TL;DR: In this article, the effects of intensive blood-glucose control with either sulphonylurea or insulin and conventional treatment on the risk of microvascular and macrovascular complications in patients with type 2 diabetes in a randomised controlled trial were compared.
Journal ArticleDOI
Assessing the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials : is blinding necessary?
Alejandro R. Jadad,R. A. Moore,Dawn Carroll,C. Jenkinson,David Reynolds,David J. Gavaghan,Henry J McQuay +6 more
TL;DR: An instrument to assess the quality of reports of randomized clinical trials (RCTs) in pain research is described and its use to determine the effect of rater blinding on the assessments of quality is described.
Related Papers (5)
Intensive blood glucose control and vascular outcomes in patients with type 2 diabetes.
Anushka Patel,Stephen MacMahon,John Chalmers,Bruce Neal,Laurent Billot,Mark Woodward,Mark Woodward,Michel Marre,Mark E. Cooper,Paul Glasziou,Paul Glasziou,Diederick E. Grobbee,Pavel Hamet,Stephen B. Harrap,Simon Heller,Lisheng Liu,Giuseppe Mancia,Carl Erik Mogensen,C. Y. Pan,Neil R Poulter,Anthony Rodgers,Bryan Williams,Severine Bompoint,Bastiaan E. de Galan,Bastiaan E. de Galan,Rohina Joshi,F. Travert +26 more
Intensive blood-glucose control with sulphonylureas or insulin compared with conventional treatment and risk of complications in patients with type 2 diabetes (UKPDS 33)
R C Turner,Rury R. Holman,Carole A. Cull,Irene M Stratton,David R Matthews,V Frighi,Susan E. Manley,Andrew Neil,K McElroy,D Wright,E. M. Kohner,Caroline S. Fox,D R Hadden,Z Mehta,Albert V. Smith,Z Nugent,Richard Peto,A I Adlel,Jim Mann,P A Bassett,S. Oakes,Tim Dornan,Stephen J Aldington,H Lipinski,R Collum,K Harrison,C MacIntyre,S Skinner,A Mortemore,D Nelson,S Cockley,S Levien,L Bodsworth,R Willox,T Biggs,S Dove,E Beattie,M Gradwell,S Staples,R Lam,F Taylor,L Leung,R D Carter,S M Brownlee,K E Fisher,K Islam,R. Jelfs,P A Williams,F A Williams,P J Sutton,A Ayres,Lisa Logie,C Lovatt,M A Evans,L A Stowell,I Ross,I A Kennedy,D. J. Croft,A H Keen,C Rose,M Raikou,A E Fletcher,Christopher J. Bulpitt,Clare Battersby,J S Yudkin,Richard Stevens,M R Stearn,S L Palmer,M S Hammersley,S L Franklin,R S Spivey,Jonathan C. Levy,C R Tidy,N J Bell,J Steemson,B A Barrow,R Coster,K Waring,L Nolan,E Truscott,N Walravens,L Cook,H Lampard,C Merle,P Parker,J McVittie,I Draisey,L E Murchison,Brunt Ahe.,M J Williams,D W Pearson,Petrie Xmp.,Lean Mej.,D Walmsley,F Lyall,E Christie,J Church,E Thomson,A Farrow,J M Stowers,M Stowers,K McHardy,N Patterson,Alex D. Wright,N A Levi,Shearer Aci.,Thompson Rjw.,G Taylor,S Rayton,M Bradbury,A Glover,A Smyth-Osbourne,C Parkes,J Graham,P England,S Gyde,C Eagle,B Chakrabarti,Josh Smith,J Sherwell,N. W. Oakley,M. Whitehead,G P Hollier,T. Pilkington,J Simpson,Michael W. Anderson,S Martin,J Kean,B Rice,A Rolland,J Nisbet,E M Kohner,A Dornhorst,M C Doddridge,M Dumskyij,S Walji,P Sharp,M Sleightholm,G Vanterpool,G Frost,M Roseblade,S Elliott,S Forrester,Meredith C. Foster,K Myers,R Chapman,J R Hayes,R W Henry,M S Featherston,Archbold Gpr.,M Copeland,R Harper,I Richardson,H A Davison,L Alexander,Scarpello Jhb.,D E Shiers,R J Tucker,Worthington Jrh.,S Angris,A Bates,J Walton,M Teasdale,J Browne,S Stanley,B A Davis,R C Strange,Hadden,L Kennedy,A B Atkinson,P M Bell,D R McCance,J Rutherford,A M Culbert,C Hegan,H Tennet,N Webb,I Robinson,J Holmes,S Nesbitt,A S Spathis,S Hyer,M E Nanson,L M James,J M Tyrell,C Davis,P Strugnell,M Booth,H Petrie,D Clark,S Hulland,J L Barron,B C Gould,J Singer,A Badenoch,M McGregor,L Isenberg,M Eckert,K Alibhai,E Marriot,Christopher E. Cox,R Price,M Fernandez,A Ryle,S Clarke,G Wallace,E Mehmed,J A Lankester,E Howard,A Waite,S MacFarlane,R H Greenwood,J Wilson,M J Denholm,R C Temple,K Whitfield,F Johnson,C Munroe,S Gorick,E Duckworth,M Fatman,S Rainbow,L J Borthwick,D J Wheatcroft,R J Seaman,R A Christie,W Wheatcroft,P Musk,Jennifer White,S McDougal,M Bond,P Raniga,J L Day,M J Doshi,James G. Wilson,J. Howard-Williams,H Humphreys,A Graham,K Hicks,S Hexman,P Bayliss,D Pledger,R W Newton,R T Jung,C Roxburgh,B Kilgallon,L Dick,N Waugh,S Kilby,A Ellingford,J Burns,C Fox,M C Holloway,H M Coghill,N Hein,A J Fox,W Cowan,M Richard,K Quested,S J Evans,Richard B Paisey,Brown Npr.,A J Tucker,R Paisey,F Garrett,J Hogg,P Park,K Williams,P Harvey,R Wilcocks,S Mason,J. C. Frost,C Warren,P Rocket,L Bower,J M Roland,D J Brown,J Youens,K Stanton-King,H Mungall,V Ball,W Maddison,D Donnelly,S King,P Griffin,Sidney C. Smith,S Church,Graham Dunn,Andrew D. Wilson,K Palmer,P M Brown,D Humphriss,Davidson Ajm.,Richard Rose,L Armistead,S Townsend,P Poon,Peacock Ida.,Culverwell Njc.,M H Charlton,Connolly Bps.,J Peacock,J Barrett,J Wain,W Beeston,George L. King,P G Hill,Boulton Ajm.,A M Robertson,V Katoulis,A Olukoga,H McDonald,S Kumar,F Abouaesha,B Abuaisha,E A Knowles,S Higgins,J Booker,J Sunter,K Breislin,R Parker,P Raval,J Curwell,H Davenport,G Shawcross,A Prest,J Grey,H Cole,C Sereviratne,R J Young,J R Clyne,M Gibson,I O'Connell,L M Wong,S J Wilson,K L Wright,Chris Wallace,D McDowell,A C Burden,E M Sellen,R Gregory,M Roshan,N Vaghela,M Burden,C Sherriff,S Mansingh,J Clarke,J Grenfell,Je Tooke,K. M. MacLeod,C Seamark,M Rammell,C Pym,J Stockman,C Yeo,J Piper,L Leighton,Ellen Green,M Hoyle,K Jones,A Hudson,A J James,Angela C. Shore,A Higham,B Martin,Neil Haw.,Butterfield Wjh.,Doll Wrs.,R Eastman,F R Ferris,N Kurinij,K McPherson,R F Mahler,Tom W. Meade,G Shafer,P J Watkins,H Keen,D Siegel,D J Betteridge,R D Cohen,D Currie,Julie L Darbyshire,J V Forrester,T Guppy,D G Johnston,Alistair McGuire,Mike Murphy,A M el-Nahas,B Pentecost,D Spiegelhalter,Alberti Kgmm.,R Denton,Philip Home,S Howell,Jarrett,V Marks,Michael Marmot,J D Ward,Grp Ukpds. +398 more