Quantifying Glucocorticoid Plasticity Using Reaction Norm Approaches: There Still is So Much to Discover!

TLDR: In this paper, the authors highlight the insights gained by repeatedly assessing an individual's glucocorticoid concentrations along a gradient of environmental or internal conditions using a "reaction norm approach".

Abstract: Hormones are highly responsive internal signals that help organisms adjust their phenotype to fluctuations in environmental and internal conditions. Our knowledge of the causes and consequences of variations in circulating hormone concentrations has improved greatly in the past. However, this knowledge comes from population-level studies which generally tend to make the flawed assumption that all individuals respond in the same way to environmental changes. Here, we advocate that we can vastly expand our understanding of the ecology and evolution of hormonal traits once we acknowledge the existence of individual differences by quantifying hormonal plasticity at the individual level, where selection acts. In this review, we use glucocorticoid hormones as examples of highly plastic endocrine traits that interact intimately with energy metabolism but also with other organismal traits like behavior and physiology. First, we highlight the insights gained by repeatedly assessing an individual's glucocorticoid concentrations along a gradient of environmental or internal conditions using a 'reaction norm approach'. This study design should be followed by a hierarchical statistical partitioning of the total endocrine variance into the among-individual component (individual differences in average hormone concentrations, i.e. in the intercept of the reaction norm) and the residual (within-individual) component. The latter is ideally further partitioned by estimating more precisely the hormonal plasticity (i.e. the slope of the reaction norm), which allows to test whether individuals differ in the degree of hormonal change along the gradient. Second, we critically review the published evidence for glucocorticoid variation, focusing mostly on among- and within-individual levels, finding only a good handful of studies that used repeated-measures designs and random regression statistics to investigate glucocorticoid plasticity. These studies indicate that individuals can differ in both the intercept and the slope of their glucocorticoid reaction norm to a known gradient. Third, we suggest rewarding avenues for future work on hormonal reaction norms, for example to uncover potential costs and trade-offs associated with glucocorticoid plasticity or to test whether glucocorticoid plasticity varies when an individual's reaction norm is repeatedly assessed along the same gradient, whether reaction norms in glucocorticoids covary with those in other traits like behavior and fitness (generating multivariate plasticity) or to quantify glucocorticoid reaction norms along multiple external and internal gradients that act simultaneously (leading to multidimensional plasticity). Throughout this review we emphasize the power that reaction norm approaches offer for resolving unanswered questions in ecological and evolutionary endocrinology.